Parallax

11 April, 1945

Buchenwald: liberated, or self-liberated?

When the first American soldiers reached the camp on the hill above Weimar, armed prisoners already held the gate. Who freed Buchenwald became an argument that lasted as long as the Cold War.

Buchenwald, near Weimar, Germany

In the first week of April 1945 the SS began emptying Buchenwald. The camp on the Ettersberg, eight kilometres from Goethe’s Weimar, held about 48,000 people, and American tanks were a few days away. Between 7 and 10 April some 28,000 prisoners were driven out on foot or packed into open rail wagons heading south; thousands died on the way. Jews were ordered to the parade ground first. Many tore off their yellow badges and hid in other barracks, and block leaders refused to hand over lists.

The prisoners had an underground. An International Camp Committee, dominated by German Communists who had been inside for years and held many of the internal jobs the SS delegated to inmates, had hidden rifles, pistols and grenades and built a secret radio transmitter. On 8 April a Polish engineer, Gwidon Damazyn, used it to send a call for help to the approaching army in English, German and Russian. The committee’s tactic was delay: obstruct each transport, lose the paperwork, and hold on.

On the morning of 11 April the loudspeakers ordered all SS men out of the camp. Gunfire could be heard to the north-west, and by early afternoon prisoners could see American tanks moving past the hill. Most of the guards left. At around three o’clock the committee’s armed groups cut the wire, occupied the watchtowers and the gatehouse, and rounded up SS stragglers in the woods. The camp elder, Hans Eiden, announced over the loudspeakers that the SS had gone and that the committee was in control. A white flag went up on the tower. The gatehouse clock at the memorial is kept stopped at a quarter past three.

Scouts of the United States 6th Armored Division arrived later that afternoon, and two intelligence officers, Egon Fleck and Edward Tenenbaum, drove in at about half past five. They found some 21,000 survivors, disciplined guards with captured weapons, and behind them a compound called the Little Camp where the dying lay on shelves beside the dead. About nine hundred of those alive were children and teenagers, most of them Jewish boys whom prisoners had sheltered in two barracks. One was Elie Wiesel, aged sixteen.

The radio reporter Edward R. Murrow walked through the next day. ‘I pray you to believe what I have said about Buchenwald,’ he told his listeners. ‘I have reported what I saw and heard, but only part of it. For most of it I have no words.’ On 16 April, on American orders, about a thousand citizens of Weimar were marched up the hill to look.

How it came to this

Buchenwald opened in July 1937 for political opponents of the regime, so-called asocials, Jehovah’s Witnesses and repeat offenders. Ten thousand Jewish men were sent there after the November pogrom of 1938. War brought prisoners from every occupied country, and the camp became the centre of more than a hundred sub-camps supplying forced labour to arms factories. It had no gas chambers, but about 8,000 Soviet prisoners of war were shot in a converted stable, and people died of hunger, disease, beatings and medical experiments. Of roughly 280,000 people who passed through, about 56,000 died. The gate carried the words Jedem das Seine, to each his due.

The SS ran its camps partly through prisoner functionaries. At Buchenwald, German Communist prisoners had wrested those posts from the convicted criminals who held them earlier, and by 1943 controlled the labour office and the infirmary. That gave them the means to protect people and to organise. In early 1945 transports from Auschwitz and Gross-Rosen, evacuated ahead of the Red Army, crowded tens of thousands of starving Jewish prisoners into the camp.

How each side saw it

The Communist resistance and the East German tradition

For the camp committee and for the German Democratic Republic that later honoured it, Buchenwald freed itself. The prisoners’ own report, compiled within weeks, describes the hidden arms, the storming of the gate and the taking of SS prisoners. On 19 April survivors assembled on the parade ground and swore an oath to destroy Nazism at its roots and build a world of peace and freedom. East Germany made that oath a founding text, opened a national memorial in 1958, and put Bruno Apitz’s novel Naked Among Wolves, about a child hidden by the underground, on school reading lists.

The United States Army

American accounts say the Third Army liberated the camp, and that the SS fled because armour was on the horizon. Fleck and Tenenbaum’s report of 24 April credits the prisoners with taking control before they arrived, and admires the order they found. It is also harsh about the Communist functionaries, describing a prisoner aristocracy that had been better fed and housed and had held power of life and death over other inmates. Western writers during the Cold War tended to stress the tanks and discount the rising, as firmly as the East did the reverse.

Jewish survivors of the Little Camp

Elie Wiesel’s Night gives the day a few lines: the resistance acted, the SS fled, and the first American tank reached the gate that evening. He records that the freed prisoners thought of nothing but bread, not of revenge and not of their families. His father had died in the camp ten weeks earlier. Many Jewish survivors, at the bottom of the camp’s order, remembered being left to starve in the Little Camp while the political prisoners’ organisation looked after its own; others, including boys from Block 66 and its Czech block elder Antonin Kalina, owed their lives to it.

The people of Weimar

The townspeople brought up the hill on 16 April said, to the photographer Margaret Bourke-White and to others, that they had not known. The camp’s prisoners had worked in Weimar’s factories and cleared its bomb rubble, its SS men drank in the town, and its crematorium smoke was visible from the road. Weimar’s cultural establishment had objected in 1937 to the camp’s intended name, Ettersberg, because of the hill’s links to Goethe, which is how it came to be called Buchenwald. Those who lived through it have left few accounts of their own; what they said is recorded mainly by the Americans who escorted them.

What is disputed

The central quarrel is the word self-liberation. The prisoners did seize the towers before any American entered, but only after most of the SS had withdrawn in the face of the advancing army; historians now generally describe both facts together. The conduct of the Communist functionaries is the other dispute. Lutz Niethammer’s 1994 edition of East German party files showed they had altered transport lists to save their own, sending others in their place; a Sinto boy, Willy Blum, went to Auschwitz in place of the child on whom Apitz based his novel. Claims about lampshades of human skin made for Ilse Koch were never proven in court.

What followed

An American military court tried thirty-one of the camp’s staff at Dachau in 1947 and convicted all of them. In August 1945 the Soviet secret police reopened the site as Special Camp No. 2 and held about 28,000 Germans there without trial, some of them Nazi officials and some not; more than 7,000 died before it closed in 1950, a fact East Germany did not acknowledge. Since 1990 the memorial has told both histories. The camp’s children included a future Nobel laureate and a future chief rabbi of Israel, Israel Meir Lau, who was seven.

Read further

  • Eugen Kogon, The Theory and Practice of Hell (1950)
  • David A. Hackett (ed.), The Buchenwald Report (1995)
  • Elie Wiesel, Night (1960)
  • Lutz Niethammer (ed.), Der ‘gesauberte’ Antifaschismus: Die SED und die roten Kapos von Buchenwald (1994)
  • Jorge Semprun, Literature or Life (1997)

Same day, other years

1814

Napoleon’s first abdication is sealed

Fontainebleau, FranceEurope

Paris had fallen to the allied armies on 31 March. At Fontainebleau Napoleon still had some 60,000 men and wanted to march on the capital, but his marshals, led by Ney, told him the army would not follow. He abdicated in favour of his infant son; when Marmont’s corps went over to the enemy he signed away the throne without conditions. The treaty concluded on 11 April left him the title of emperor, the island of Elba as a sovereign principality, and an income of two million francs to be paid by France. On the night of the 12th he swallowed poison he had carried since Russia, and survived it.

Seen from elsewhere. The British foreign secretary Castlereagh thought the terms reckless and declined to be a full party to them: Elba was too near France and Italy, and the imperial title kept the claim alive. The restored Bourbons never paid the pension. Ten months later Napoleon landed in Provence with a thousand men.

1856

Costa Rica’s drummer boy and the filibusters

Rivas, NicaraguaThe Americas

William Walker, an adventurer from Tennessee, had made himself master of Nicaragua with a private army of Americans and hoped to build a slaveholding state in Central America. Costa Rica’s president, Juan Rafael Mora, declared war and marched north with some 3,000 men. At Rivas on 11 April Walker attacked them, and his riflemen fortified a large inn in the town. By the national account a drummer from Alajuela, Juan Santamaria, volunteered to set it alight on condition that his mother be cared for, and was shot dead as the roof caught. The Costa Ricans held the town, then carried cholera home with them; it killed about a tenth of the country’s people.

Seen from elsewhere. Walker’s own book on the war does not mention the boy, and contemporary evidence is thin: chiefly his mother’s petition for a pension. Some historians have doubted the story, and Costa Rica raised him to national hero only a generation later. Nicaraguans honour a schoolteacher, Enmanuel Mongalo, for burning the same building in 1855.

1961

Eichmann goes on trial in Jerusalem

Jerusalem, IsraelMiddle East

Adolf Eichmann, the SS officer who had organised the deportation of Europe’s Jews to the killing centres, had been seized by Israeli agents near his home in Buenos Aires in May 1960 and flown out drugged. He faced fifteen counts in a converted theatre, sitting in a booth of bulletproof glass. The prosecutor, Gideon Hausner, called more than a hundred survivors, and for many Israelis and much of the world it was the first time the destruction of the Jews had been told at length by those who lived through it. Eichmann said he had only obeyed orders and arranged transport. He was convicted in December and hanged in 1962.

Seen from elsewhere. Argentina protested at the United Nations that its sovereignty had been violated, and jurists questioned a trial under a retroactive law by a state that had not existed during the crimes. Hannah Arendt saw in him the banality of evil; later historians, David Cesarani and Bettina Stangneth among them, found a committed ideologue who played the clerk in court.

1979

Kampala falls and Idi Amin flees

Kampala, UgandaAfrica

In October 1978 Idi Amin’s army invaded the Kagera region of Tanzania and announced its annexation. President Julius Nyerere answered with a full mobilisation. Tanzanian troops, joined by Ugandan exiles, crossed the border, beat off a Libyan force sent by Muammar Gaddafi to prop Amin up, and entered Kampala on the night of 10 to 11 April 1979. Amin escaped to Libya and later to Saudi Arabia, where he died in 2003. In eight years his government had expelled the country’s Asian population and killed a number of Ugandans usually put between 100,000 and 300,000.

Seen from elsewhere. Several African governments condemned Tanzania for breaking the rule against invading a fellow member of the Organisation of African Unity. Kampala’s crowds cheered and then looted. The war nearly bankrupted Tanzania, and the governments that followed, above all Milton Obote’s second, presided over killing on a comparable scale. Amin kept admirers in his home region.

Also on 11 April