Parallax

12 April, 1861

The guns open on Fort Sumter

Thirty-four hours of shelling in Charleston harbour killed nobody and began the bloodiest war in American history. Each side spent the next century arguing that the other had started it.

Charleston, South Carolina

At half past four on the morning of 12 April 1861 a mortar at Fort Johnson, on the southern shore of Charleston harbour, lobbed a single shell high over the water. It burst above Fort Sumter, a brick pentagon on an artificial island in the harbour mouth, and was the signal for forty-odd Confederate guns and mortars ringing the bay to open fire. In the city people ran to the rooftops and the waterfront. Mary Chesnut, whose husband had carried the final demand for surrender out to the fort by rowing boat a few hours earlier, wrote in her diary that she sprang out of bed and went down on her knees to pray as she had never prayed before.

Inside the fort were Major Robert Anderson, a Kentuckian and a former slaveholder who remained loyal to the Union, some eighty-five officers and men, and a few dozen civilian workmen. They had food for only a few days. The Confederate commander, Pierre Beauregard, had been Anderson’s pupil in artillery at West Point. Anderson held his fire until daylight and then replied sparingly, keeping his men in the lower casemates and off the exposed upper tier where his heaviest guns stood. Captain Abner Doubleday aimed the first Union shot.

Beyond the bar, in rough seas, lay the ships of a relief expedition sent by President Lincoln. Its commander, Gustavus Fox, could see the smoke and could do nothing; the warship meant to lead him in had been sent elsewhere through a muddle in Washington. On the second day heated shot set the fort’s wooden barracks ablaze. The fire crept towards the powder magazine, and the garrison lay on the ground with wet cloths over their faces. The flagstaff was shot away and the flag nailed up again.

A former senator from Texas, Louis Wigfall, had himself rowed out without orders, waved a white handkerchief on his sword through an embrasure, and offered terms. Anderson accepted on the afternoon of 13 April. More than three thousand shells had been fired at the fort and no one on either side had been killed.

The first deaths came at the surrender ceremony the next day. Anderson had asked to salute his flag with a hundred guns. On the forty-seventh round a pile of cartridges exploded, killing Private Daniel Hough and mortally wounding another soldier. The salute was cut short, the garrison marched out to the tune of Yankee Doodle, and sailed for New York with the flag.

How it came to this

Abraham Lincoln had been elected in November 1860 on a platform of stopping the spread of slavery into the western territories. South Carolina seceded in December, and six more states of the lower South followed and formed the Confederate States of America, whose founders said plainly that their purpose was to protect slavery. They seized federal forts, arsenals and customs houses across their territory. Sumter was one of the few posts still held. Anderson had moved his small garrison there by night on 26 December from an indefensible fort on the shore, and in January a supply ship sent to him had been driven off by cannon fire.

By the time Lincoln took office on 4 March the garrison had about six weeks of food. Most of his cabinet advised giving the fort up; to resupply it might start a war and drive the eight slave states still in the Union out of it. Lincoln chose a middle course. On 6 April he sent word to the governor of South Carolina that he would send in provisions only, and no men or arms unless resisted. The Confederate cabinet in Montgomery decided not to wait.

How each side saw it

The Confederate government

Jefferson Davis argued, then and in his memoirs, that the fort stood on the soil of a sovereign state, that its occupation by a foreign power was itself the aggression, and that Lincoln’s supply fleet was a hostile act disguised as charity. To let it be provisioned would make the new nation look helpless. His secretary of state, Robert Toombs, is reported in a later biography to have warned the cabinet that firing first would stir a hornets’ nest and lose the South its friends in the North. The cabinet overruled him. Southern tradition long called the conflict the War of Northern Aggression.

Lincoln and the Union

Lincoln held that secession was legally void, that he had sworn to hold the property of the United States, and that he had promised the South there would be no bloodshed unless it was forced on the government. Sending bread to hungry men, with notice given, kept that promise and left the choice to Charleston. On 1 May he wrote to Fox that they could both take comfort that the cause of the country had been advanced by the attempt, even though it failed. For most Northerners the plain fact was that the flag had been fired on, and party divisions vanished for a season.

Enslaved and free Black Americans

More than half the people of South Carolina were enslaved, and the white men on Charleston’s rooftops were watching a battle fought to keep them so. Their thoughts that morning went almost unrecorded; Mary Chesnut noted that the household servants gave no sign and wondered what they made of it. Frederick Douglass, in his monthly paper, welcomed the war as the slaveholders’ own doing and at once pressed for it to become a war of emancipation fought with Black soldiers. Thirteen months later an enslaved Charleston pilot, Robert Smalls, sailed a Confederate steamer past Sumter’s guns and delivered it to the blockading fleet.

Unionists of the upper South

In Virginia, North Carolina, Tennessee and Arkansas, conventions or voters had rejected secession that winter. Their leaders had begged Lincoln to abandon Sumter and give tempers time to cool. It was not the bombardment that broke them but his proclamation of 15 April calling on every state for militia, 75,000 men in all, to put down the rebellion. Asked to supply troops to invade their neighbours, all four states seceded within weeks. Many of these men said for the rest of their lives that they had been driven out of the Union by Lincoln’s summons, not led out by South Carolina.

What is disputed

Who fired the first shot is uncertain: the signal shell was probably fired by Lieutenant Henry Farley or on Captain George James’s order, while a famous tradition gives the honour to the elderly Virginian secessionist Edmund Ruffin, who fired an early round from Morris Island. The larger argument is over Lincoln’s intent. Charles Ramsdell argued in 1937 that he manoeuvred the South into firing first; David Potter and Kenneth Stampp replied that he wanted to hold the fort peacefully but accepted the risk; Richard Current took a middle view. The war’s death toll, long given as about 620,000, was revised to roughly 750,000 by the demographer J. David Hacker in 2011.

What followed

The war lasted four years and destroyed slavery, freeing some four million people. Union guns later pounded Sumter to rubble, but its Confederate garrison held out until Charleston was abandoned in February 1865. On 14 April 1865, four years to the day after he had hauled it down, Robert Anderson raised the same flag over the ruins before a crowd that included freed people and abolitionists. That evening in Washington, Lincoln went to the theatre. Whether the war was about slavery or about the rights of states is settled among historians and still fought over in American public life.

Read further

  • C. Vann Woodward (ed.), Mary Chesnut’s Civil War (1981)
  • Abner Doubleday, Reminiscences of Forts Sumter and Moultrie in 1860-’61 (1876)
  • David M. Potter, The Impending Crisis, 1848-1861 (1976)
  • Richard N. Current, Lincoln and the First Shot (1963)
  • Maury Klein, Days of Defiance: Sumter, Secession, and the Coming of the Civil War (1997)

Same day, other years

1204

The Fourth Crusade breaks into Constantinople

Constantinople (now Istanbul)Europe

The crusaders had set out to recover Jerusalem by way of Egypt. Unable to pay the Venetians for their fleet, they had been diverted first to the Christian city of Zara and then to Constantinople, to restore a deposed emperor who promised to settle their debts and could not. On 12 April 1204, with a north wind behind them, Venetian ships lashed in pairs brought their flying bridges up to the towers of the sea wall along the Golden Horn. A handful of knights got across, a gate was forced, and by nightfall the attackers held a quarter of the city. Three days of looting followed, and the greatest city in Christendom was shared out between Franks and Venetians.

Seen from elsewhere. The Byzantine official Niketas Choniates, who fled with his family, described churches stripped, nuns assaulted and a prostitute set on the patriarch’s throne. The crusader Geoffrey of Villehardouin wrote of a lawful conquest and God’s favour. Pope Innocent III condemned the sack and then accepted its results. Orthodox memory of it has never faded; Pope John Paul II expressed sorrow for it in 2001.

1927

Chiang Kai-shek turns on the Communists in Shanghai

Shanghai, ChinaAsia

The Nationalists and the Chinese Communists had marched north together to reunify China, and in March 1927 Communist-led unions seized Shanghai from its warlord garrison before the army arrived. Before dawn on 12 April armed men of the Green Gang, the city’s criminal brotherhood, wearing white armbands and working with Chiang Kai-shek’s command, attacked the union pickets. Soldiers disarmed the rest. When workers and students marched in protest the next day, troops fired into the crowd. Killings and arrests continued for weeks and spread to other cities. The alliance was finished, the Communist party lost most of its urban membership, and its survivors took to the countryside.

Seen from elsewhere. Chiang’s side called it a purge that forestalled a Communist seizure of power directed from Moscow, and Shanghai’s bankers and the foreign concessions welcomed it. Communist histories call it a massacre and a betrayal. The dead in Shanghai are put at a few hundred by Nationalist accounts and at several thousand, counting the missing, by others.

1961

Gagarin orbits the Earth

Baikonur, Kazakh SSR, and Earth orbitWorldwide

Yuri Gagarin, a twenty-seven-year-old air force pilot and a carpenter’s son from a village near Smolensk, was sealed into the Vostok capsule and launched at seven minutes past nine, Moscow time. His flight lasted 108 minutes and took him once round the planet. The craft was controlled from the ground; the manual override code was in a sealed envelope, though colleagues had told him the numbers. The equipment module failed to separate cleanly on re-entry and the capsule tumbled until the connecting cables burned through. He ejected at seven kilometres, as planned, and came down by parachute in a field near the Volga, where a farm woman and her granddaughter were the first to meet him.

Seen from elsewhere. The Soviet Union hid the ejection for years, since record rules required a pilot to land in his craft, and hid the name of the chief designer, Sergei Korolev, until his death. In Washington the flight was read as proof of Soviet missile power; six weeks later President Kennedy committed the United States to the Moon.

1980

Samuel Doe’s soldiers kill President Tolbert

Monrovia, LiberiaAfrica

Liberia had been governed since 1847 by the descendants of freed American slaves, a small elite who held power through a single party and treated the indigenous majority as subjects. Before dawn on 12 April 1980 seventeen enlisted men led by Master Sergeant Samuel Doe, a twenty-eight-year-old of the Krahn people, entered the Executive Mansion and killed President William Tolbert in his quarters. Doe suspended the constitution and proclaimed a People’s Redemption Council. Ten days later thirteen ministers and officials of the old government were tied to posts on a Monrovia beach and shot in front of cameras and a crowd.

Seen from elsewhere. Many indigenous Liberians celebrated in the streets: the previous year Tolbert’s police had shot demonstrators protesting at the price of rice. Americo-Liberian families remember confiscation, killing and exile. Doe’s rule grew as corrupt and more ethnically divisive than the one it replaced, and he was tortured to death in 1990 at the start of a civil war.

Also on 12 April