Parallax

22 April, 1787

Catherine the Great sets off down the Dnieper

The empress’s river cruise to her new southern provinces was the most lavish state journey of the century. A diplomat who was not on it supplied the phrase by which it is remembered, and historians still argue over how much of what she saw was real.

Kiev, Russian Empire

The ice on the Dnieper broke late in 1787. Catherine II had been waiting at Kiev for almost three months, having left St Petersburg in January in a convoy of sledges, and her court was bored and quarrelsome. At noon on 22 April by the Russian calendar, 3 May in the West, cannon were fired and she boarded a galley painted red and gold. Six more like it followed, each with its own orchestra, and behind them some eighty vessels carrying about three thousand oarsmen, guards and servants. The Prince de Ligne, who was aboard, called it Cleopatra’s fleet.

The host was Grigory Potemkin, her former lover and probably her secret husband, who for a decade had governed the lands Russia had taken from the Ottomans and the Crimean khanate. The guests included the ambassadors of France, Britain and Austria and her current favourite, Alexander Dmitriev-Mamonov. At Kaniv the King of Poland, Stanislaw August Poniatowski, came aboard. He had been her lover thirty years earlier and owed her his throne, and he had spent a fortune preparing. She gave him a few hours and declined to stay for his ball.

Further down, the Emperor Joseph II joined the party under the name Count Falkenstein. The two sovereigns laid the foundation stone of a cathedral at Ekaterinoslav, a city that so far existed mostly on paper. Below the rapids they went on by carriage to Kherson, founded nine years earlier, with a fortress, shipyards and newly launched warships.

Then came the Crimea, annexed only four years before. Catherine slept in the palace of the khans at Bakhchisaray, with Tatar horsemen as her escort. On a height at Inkerman Potemkin gave a dinner in a pavilion; at a signal the curtains were drawn back and the guests looked down on a fleet of warships at anchor in the bay of Sevastopol, which fired a salute. The French ambassador, the Comte de Segur, wrote that it seemed impossible so much could have been done in so short a time.

On the way home, at Poltava, fifty thousand troops re-enacted Peter the Great’s victory over the Swedes. Catherine gave Potemkin the title Prince of Tauris. She was back near Petersburg in July after six months and some 6,000 kilometres. Within weeks the Ottoman Empire declared war.

How it came to this

The steppe north of the Black Sea had for centuries been a frontier between Russia, Poland and the Ottoman world, thinly peopled by Cossacks and by the Nogai and Crimean Tatars, whose khan was a vassal of the sultan. Catherine’s first Turkish war, ended in 1774, detached the khanate from Constantinople. In 1775 she abolished the Zaporozhian Cossack host. In 1783, on Potemkin’s urging, she annexed the Crimea outright.

Potemkin was given the whole region to rule and settle, with a budget almost beyond audit. He founded Kherson, Sevastopol, Ekaterinoslav and Nikolaev, built a Black Sea fleet, and brought in colonists: Russian and Ukrainian peasants, Greeks, Armenians, German Mennonites. His enemies at court, among them the heir to the throne, Grand Duke Paul, said that the money had vanished and the south was a desert. The journey of 1787 was his answer. It was also a piece of diplomacy, meant to show Joseph II and the Western envoys that Russia could strike at Constantinople, a project Catherine had advertised by naming her second grandson Constantine.

How each side saw it

Georg von Helbig and Potemkin’s enemies

Helbig was secretary to the Saxon legation in Petersburg and did not make the journey. After Catherine’s death he published a hostile life of Potemkin in a Hamburg journal, between 1797 and 1800, which was soon translated into French and English. It said that the villages along the river were painted screens, that the same herds and the same peasants were moved on by night to reappear downstream, and that the granaries held sacks of sand. He was repeating Petersburg gossip that had begun before the trip set out. The stories suited everyone who had resented the favourite, and they gave Europe the expression Potemkin village.

The foreign guests

The travellers themselves left three accounts and none supports the tale of cardboard villages. The Prince de Ligne ridiculed it by name in his letters. Segur’s memoirs describe real towns, real ships and a great deal of decoration: triumphal arches, illuminations, peasants in their best clothes brought to the banks. Joseph II was the sharpest critic. He wrote home that much had been run up in haste and would not last, that the fleet was built of green timber, and that such works were possible only where labour and lives were spent without counting. He thought it impressive and wasteful, not fake.

The Crimean Tatars

For the Muslim people of the peninsula the journey was a conqueror’s inspection. The manifesto of 1783 had promised them their faith and property, and Catherine made a show of respecting mosques and Tatar nobles. But land was already passing to Russian grandees, and tens of thousands of Tatars left for Ottoman territory in the first years, with estimates for the following decades running far higher. Their view of the visit has to be read from Ottoman reports and later Tatar tradition, since the surviving descriptions are those of the empress’s guests. Alan Fisher and Kelly O’Neill have reconstructed what annexation meant on the ground.

Ukrainian and Cossack memory

The fleet sailed through what had been the lands of the Zaporozhian Sich, whose fortress Catherine’s troops had surrounded and dissolved twelve years earlier; some of its Cossacks had gone over to the sultan. In 1783 she had extended serfdom to the peasants of left-bank Ukraine. Ukrainian tradition, given its lasting form in the poems of Taras Shevchenko, remembers her as the ruler who finished off Cossack liberty and gave the steppe to her favourites. The empire called the region New Russia. Odesa removed its monument to her in 2022.

What is disputed

Simon Sebag Montefiore and the Russian scholar Aleksandr Panchenko hold that the Potemkin villages are a myth, a slander that predated the journey, and that the cities and the fleet were plainly real. Sceptics answer that the staging was lavish enough to blur the line: settlements were freshly painted, crowds assembled and half-built projects shown as finished, and some, like the Ekaterinoslav cathedral, were abandoned. The well-known story that an arch at Kherson bore the words ‘This is the road to Byzantium’ rests on Segur. Dates are Old Style; add eleven days for the Western calendar.

What followed

The Ottomans, provoked by the display, went to war in August 1787. Potemkin commanded in the south, took the fortress of Ochakov and died on the open steppe in 1791, months before a peace that confirmed Russia on the Black Sea. Paul, on becoming emperor, ordered his monument at Kherson destroyed and the grave hidden. The cities he founded became the ports and industrial centres of southern Ukraine. Russian claims to the Crimea in 2014 and to New Russia in 2022 appealed directly to Catherine’s conquest, and his remains were removed from Kherson by Russian forces that autumn.

Read further

  • Simon Sebag Montefiore, Prince of Princes: The Life of Potemkin (2000)
  • Isabel de Madariaga, Russia in the Age of Catherine the Great (1981)
  • Louis-Philippe, comte de Segur, Memoirs and Recollections of Count Segur
  • Alan W. Fisher, The Crimean Tatars (1978)
  • Kelly O’Neill, Claiming Crimea: A History of Catherine the Great’s Southern Empire (2017)

Same day, other years

1500

Cabral’s fleet sights Brazil

Monte Pascoal, Bahia, BrazilThe Americas

Thirteen Portuguese ships under Pedro Alvares Cabral, bound for India by the route Vasco da Gama had just opened, swung far out into the Atlantic and on the Wednesday after Easter saw a round mountain to the west. They anchored, met people on the beach, and stayed just over a week. The fleet’s secretary, Pero Vaz de Caminha, described the meeting in a long letter to King Manuel: naked men and women painted red and black, hats and caps exchanged for feather headdresses, a Mass on shore which the inhabitants watched and imitated. Cabral set up a cross, left two convicts behind and sailed on.

Seen from elsewhere. The Tupiniquim left no account; we see them only through Caminha, who judged them innocent and ready for conversion. Several million people lived in what became Brazil. Whether the landfall was an accident or the Portuguese already knew land lay there is debated, and a Spanish captain had touched the northern coast three months before. Indigenous groups protested at the 500th anniversary.

1889

The Oklahoma land run

Indian Territory (Oklahoma), United StatesThe Americas

At noon, at a signal from army buglers, about 50,000 people on horses, in wagons and aboard crowded trains raced across a line into nearly two million acres of prairie that the federal government had declared open to settlement. Each could claim 160 acres or a town lot by driving a stake. By nightfall Guthrie and Oklahoma City were tent towns of some ten thousand people apiece, with streets marked out and lawyers already arguing over titles. Those who had slipped in early to hide near the best land were called sooners, a name the state later adopted with pride.

Seen from elsewhere. The land lay in the territory to which the Muscogee, Seminole and other nations had been removed in the 1830s under promises that it would be theirs for ever; it was taken from them after the Civil War and bought out in 1889. Further runs and the allotment policy dismantled the remaining tribal lands before statehood in 1907.

1915

Chlorine at Ypres

Langemark, near Ypres, BelgiumEurope

At about five in the afternoon German engineers opened the valves on nearly six thousand cylinders dug into their front line and released about 170 tonnes of chlorine on the breeze. A greenish-yellow cloud rolled over trenches held by French territorials and Algerian infantry. Men choked, went blind and ran, and a gap several miles wide opened in the Allied line. The Germans, with few reserves and wary of their own gas, advanced about two miles and stopped at dusk. Canadian troops closed the flank and were gassed in their turn two days later. It was the first large-scale use of lethal gas in war.

Seen from elsewhere. Germany argued that the Hague rules banned only gas shells and that France had already used tear gas. Fritz Haber, the chemist who directed the attack, held that gas was no crueller than high explosive; his wife Clara, also a chemist, shot herself days later. Early Allied claims of 5,000 dead are now thought too high, and the true figure is unknown.

1995

The killings at Kibeho camp

Kibeho, RwandaAfrica

A year after the genocide of Rwanda’s Tutsi, some 80,000 or more displaced Hutu were still living in a camp on a hilltop in the south-west. The new government, led by the former rebel army, believed the camp sheltered killers and was determined to close it. After days in which soldiers penned the crowd into an ever smaller space without food or water, troops opened fire with rifles, machine guns and grenades. Zambian peacekeepers and Australian army medics from the UN mission were present and were not allowed to intervene. The Australians counted more than 4,000 bodies before they were made to stop.

Seen from elsewhere. The government put the dead at 338 and said armed militiamen inside the camp had fired first and used the crowd as cover; the United Nations settled on about 2,000. An international inquiry found the shooting unplanned, a conclusion many witnesses rejected. Ministers who protested left the government, and one, Seth Sendashonga, was murdered in exile.

Also on 22 April