Parallax

4 April, 1774

Oliver Goldsmith doses himself to death

The author of The Vicar of Wakefield had trained as a physician and trusted his own judgment over his doctors’. He died owing two thousand pounds, mourned by Johnson, Burke and Reynolds and by a staircase full of London’s poor.

Brick Court, Middle Temple, London

On Friday 25 March 1774 Goldsmith came back to his chambers in the Temple from a stay in the country, feverish and troubled by a bladder complaint he had suffered before. That night he sent for William Hawes, an apothecary in the Strand, and told him what he intended to take: Dr James’s Fever Powder, a fashionable patent remedy based on antimony which he had long sworn by. Hawes thought it the wrong medicine for a man already weak and begged him not to. A physician, George Fordyce, was fetched and said the same. Goldsmith, who called himself Doctor on the strength of studies at Edinburgh and Leiden, overruled them both.

The powder purged and exhausted him. When the first dose did not act as he expected he blamed Hawes for sending the wrong article and had a servant buy more from the proprietor’s own shop. A second physician, John Turton, was called in. For some days the patient seemed to hold his ground, sleeping little and eating nothing. Turton, puzzled, told him his pulse was in greater disorder than the degree of fever could explain, and asked whether his mind was at ease. ‘No, it is not,’ Goldsmith said. They are the last words of his that anyone recorded.

He died in convulsions at about a quarter to five on the morning of Monday 4 April, aged forty-five by the usual reckoning. What had been on his mind was not hard to guess. He had earned large sums from two successful comedies and from histories written at speed for the booksellers, and had spent more, on clothes, on dinners, on gambling and on anyone who asked. Samuel Johnson put the debts at not less than two thousand pounds and added: ‘Was ever poet so trusted before?’

Edmund Burke wept at the news. Joshua Reynolds, who rarely let anything interrupt his work, put down his brushes for the day. His early biographers recorded that the stairs at Brick Court filled with mourners of another kind, the destitute and outcast of the neighbourhood, women especially, to whom he had been giving money he did not have.

His friends planned a public funeral at Westminster Abbey with peers as pall-bearers, then learned the size of the debts and thought better of it. He was buried quietly on the evening of 9 April in the Temple churchyard, in a grave whose exact position was later lost. Two years on, a monument by Nollekens went up in the Abbey with a Latin epitaph by Johnson, saying that there was almost no kind of writing he had not touched and none he touched that he did not adorn.

How it came to this

Goldsmith was the son of a Church of Ireland clergyman and grew up at Lissoy in County Westmeath. Short, plain and scarred by smallpox, he went to Trinity College Dublin as a sizar, a poor student who paid his way by menial service, and took an undistinguished degree. He was rejected for ordination, lost the money given him to study law, read medicine without clear result, and spent a year or more walking through Flanders, France, Switzerland and Italy, by his own telling paying for his supper with a flute.

He reached London in 1756 with nothing, and worked as an apothecary’s drudge, a school usher and a reviewer paid by the sheet before his essays brought him to the notice of Johnson. In 1764 he was one of the nine founding members of the Club that met at the Turk’s Head. The Traveller made his name as a poet that year, The Vicar of Wakefield followed in 1766, The Deserted Village in 1770 and She Stoops to Conquer in 1773. He remained a jobbing writer throughout, turning out compilations on Rome, England and natural history to pay the bills.

How each side saw it

Johnson and the Club

His friends admired the writing and laughed at the man. In company he blurted, boasted and sulked, and David Garrick’s mock epitaph said he wrote like an angel but talked like poor Poll. Goldsmith answered in Retaliation, a set of verse portraits of the whole circle left unfinished at his death and still the sharpest thing written about them. Johnson’s private verdict was generous: ‘Let not his frailties be remembered; he was a very great man.’ When the Club petitioned him in a round robin to write the Abbey epitaph in English, Johnson refused to disgrace the walls with anything but Latin.

Boswell and the biographers who answered him

The Goldsmith most readers know is the one in Boswell’s Life of Johnson: vain, envious, absurd in a plum-coloured coat, forever trying to shine and failing. Boswell was a rival for Johnson’s attention and disliked him. Nineteenth-century biographers, James Prior in 1837 and John Forster in 1848, set out to correct the picture, gathering testimony from Ireland and from surviving friends to show a generous and self-mocking man whose jokes Boswell had been too literal to catch. Modern scholars tend to think both overdid it, and that Goldsmith sometimes played the fool on purpose in a company where he could not win an argument.

The apothecary and the patent-medicine trade

Within weeks William Hawes published an account of the illness to clear himself, describing how he and Fordyce had pleaded with the patient not to take the powder. Francis Newbery, who sold Dr James’s remedy and whose family had been Goldsmith’s publishers, replied in the newspapers with statements from Goldsmith’s servants suggesting that the fault lay in the delay or in Hawes’s own preparation. The quarrel was commercial as well as medical: the powder was among the best-selling medicines of the century, and its formula was a guarded secret. Hawes went on that same year to help found the society for reviving the drowned that became the Royal Humane Society.

Ireland

English critics read The Deserted Village as a poem about enclosure and the removal of an English hamlet to make a nobleman’s park, and Goldsmith himself said he had seen such things in England. Irish readers have long taken ‘Sweet Auburn’ to be Lissoy, and the poem to be about landlord clearances and emigration at home; a local tradition names the general who evicted the tenants. Goldsmith left Ireland at twenty-four and never returned, yet wrote of it constantly in his letters. His statue stands beside Burke’s at the gate of Trinity College Dublin, and Irish literary history counts him among its own.

What is disputed

His beginnings are less certain than his end. The year of birth is given as 1728 or 1730, since the family Bible leaf is damaged, and the place as Pallas in County Longford or his grandmother’s house near Elphin in Roscommon. Whether he ever took a medical degree is doubtful; no university has a record of one. Doctors have argued since 1774 over whether a kidney infection or the antimony powder killed him. The story that Johnson sold The Vicar of Wakefield for sixty pounds to save him from arrest exists in several conflicting versions. His authorship of the children’s book Goody Two-Shoes is a guess.

What followed

The debts were never paid in full. The Vicar of Wakefield became one of the most reprinted English novels of the following century and was admired by Goethe; She Stoops to Conquer has rarely been off the stage. Dr James’s Powder went on selling for generations, and was given to George III in his illness. The episode is still cited in histories of medicine as an early public argument about patent remedies and a patient’s right to ignore advice. A stone marking his supposed grave beside the Temple Church was laid in 1860 and reads only ‘Here lies Oliver Goldsmith’.

Read further

  • James Boswell, The Life of Samuel Johnson (1791)
  • James Prior, The Life of Oliver Goldsmith (1837)
  • John Forster, The Life and Adventures of Oliver Goldsmith (1848)
  • Ralph M. Wardle, Oliver Goldsmith (1957)
  • Norma Clarke, Brothers of the Quill: Oliver Goldsmith in Grub Street (2016)

Same day, other years

1581

Elizabeth I has Francis Drake knighted on his own deck

Deptford, EnglandEurope

Drake had come home in September 1580 after nearly three years, the first captain to take his own ship round the world, with a hold full of silver, gold and jewels taken from Spanish vessels and towns along the Pacific coast of America. The queen’s share is said to have exceeded a year’s ordinary revenue. For months she kept her distance while Spain demanded restitution. Then she dined aboard the Golden Hind in the Thames at Deptford and, with a joke about having a gilded sword to strike off his head, handed the blade to the French envoy, the Marquis de Marchaumont, to perform the dubbing, drawing France into the gesture.

Seen from elsewhere. To Spain there had been no war and Drake was a pirate; the ambassador Bernardino de Mendoza called him the master thief of the unknown world. On the Spanish American coast ‘El Draque’ remained a name to frighten children. His earlier career included slaving voyages to West Africa with John Hawkins, and he had beheaded one of his own gentlemen on the voyage out.

1968

Martin Luther King is shot in Memphis

Memphis, Tennessee, United StatesThe Americas

King had come to Memphis to support black sanitation workers striking for recognition after two of them were crushed to death in a rubbish truck. At a minute past six in the evening, as he stood on the balcony of the Lorraine Motel talking to colleagues in the car park below, a single rifle bullet struck him in the jaw and neck. He was pronounced dead an hour later, aged thirty-nine. Riots broke out in more than a hundred American cities. James Earl Ray, an escaped convict arrested at London’s Heathrow airport two months later, pleaded guilty and received ninety-nine years, then withdrew his confession within days.

Seen from elsewhere. King’s family came to believe that Ray had not acted alone and supported his request for a trial. A Memphis civil jury in 1999 found that a conspiracy had existed; a Justice Department review the next year found no reliable evidence for it. What is documented is that the FBI had spent years wiretapping King and trying to discredit him.

1979

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto is hanged

Rawalpindi, PakistanAsia

At two in the morning Pakistan’s deposed prime minister was hanged in Rawalpindi district jail and flown for burial to his family village in Sindh before the news was announced. Bhutto, founder of the Pakistan People’s Party and the country’s first elected civilian leader after the loss of Bangladesh, had been overthrown in July 1977 by his own army chief, General Zia-ul-Haq, amid protests over a disputed election. He was then tried for ordering the 1974 shooting of a political opponent, in which the man’s father was killed. The Lahore High Court sentenced him to death and the Supreme Court upheld it by four votes to three. Zia rejected appeals for clemency from many governments.

Seen from elsewhere. Zia said the law had taken its course. Bhutto’s supporters called it judicial murder, and one of the judges later spoke of pressure on the bench. In 2024 Pakistan’s Supreme Court gave its opinion that he had not received a fair trial. His opponents remember his own harshness in office, in Balochistan and towards rivals.

2002

Angola’s twenty-seven-year war ends

Luanda, AngolaAfrica

Generals of the Angolan army and of the rebel movement UNITA signed a ceasefire at a ceremony in Luanda, six weeks after government troops had tracked down and killed UNITA’s leader, Jonas Savimbi, in the eastern province of Moxico. The war had begun before the Portuguese left in 1975 and had outlasted every reason given for it: first a Cold War contest in which Cuban troops and Soviet arms backed the governing MPLA while South Africa and the United States backed Savimbi, then a struggle financed by oil on one side and diamonds on the other. At least half a million people died and some four million were driven from their homes.

Seen from elsewhere. UNITA’s men said they had been starved into the agreement by an army that emptied the countryside around them. The MPLA, in power since independence, has governed ever since; the opposition says peace was never followed by a fair contest. The separatist conflict in oil-rich Cabinda was not covered, and landmines still maim farmers.

Also on 4 April