Parallax

28 April, 1945

Mussolini is shot at a garden gate

Caught in a German lorry on the road to Switzerland, the founder of fascism was dead within a day and hanging by his heels in Milan within two. Who decided it, and who fired, is still argued over.

Giulino di Mezzegra, Lake Como, Italy

On the afternoon of 27 April 1945 a German anti-aircraft column retreating up the western shore of Lake Como was stopped at a roadblock of logs and boulders near the village of Musso. The partisans of the 52nd Garibaldi Brigade were far too few to fight it, so they bargained: the Germans could go on towards the frontier if they handed over any Italians travelling with them. In the square at Dongo the lorries were searched. Slumped in one of them, in a German greatcoat and helmet, feigning sleep, was Benito Mussolini.

He had left Milan two days earlier, after a meeting at the archbishop’s palace at which he learned that the Germans had been negotiating their own surrender without telling him. He talked of a last stand in the Alps for which no troops existed. His mistress, Clara Petacci, nearly thirty years his junior, was travelling in the same convoy and asked to share his captivity. The partisans held him first in the town hall, then moved him in the night, fearing a fascist rescue or an Allied claim, and finally lodged the pair in a farmhouse belonging to a family named De Maria in the hamlet of Bonzanigo.

In Milan the resistance command had a decision to make. The armistice terms required Italy to deliver Mussolini to the Allies, and American officers were already asking where he was. The communist leaders on the command, Luigi Longo chief among them, wanted him dead by Italian hands before that could happen. On the morning of 28 April they sent a partisan officer who used the name Colonel Valerio, generally identified as Walter Audisio, an accountant from Alessandria, with an escort and orders to carry out the sentence.

By the account he later published, Valerio reached the farmhouse at about four in the afternoon, told the prisoners he had come to free them, and drove them a few hundred metres to the gate of the Villa Belmonte in Giulino di Mezzegra. He stood them against the wall and pronounced sentence in the name of the Italian people. His sub-machine gun jammed, then his pistol; he took a comrade’s weapon and fired. Petacci, who he said had clung to Mussolini, died with him. It was ten past four. Mussolini was sixty-one. That evening fifteen other fascist leaders and officials taken from the column were shot on the lakefront at Dongo.

The bodies were driven to Milan overnight and dumped before dawn in Piazzale Loreto, where the previous August fascist militia had shot fifteen political prisoners and left them on display. A crowd gathered, and it kicked, spat on and fired into the corpses. Mussolini was not lynched, as is often said; the mob’s violence was done to a dead man. To get the bodies out of reach, or to show them better, they were hauled up by the heels from the girder of a petrol station: Mussolini, Petacci and several of his ministers. They were taken down that afternoon and sent to the city mortuary.

How it came to this

Mussolini had ruled Italy from 1922, taken it into Hitler’s war in June 1940, and lost. In July 1943, with the Allies in Sicily, his own Grand Council voted against him and the king had him arrested. German paratroopers lifted him off a mountain in the Abruzzi that September, and Hitler set him up as head of a rump state in the north, the Italian Social Republic, with its ministries scattered around Lake Garda. It depended entirely on German arms, helped deport Jews to the camps, and had Mussolini’s son-in-law Ciano shot for the July vote.

For twenty months the north lived through a war inside a war: Germans and fascist militias against a growing partisan movement of communists, socialists, Catholics, liberals and former soldiers. Reprisals killed thousands of civilians at places such as Marzabotto and Sant’Anna di Stazzema. When the Allied spring offensive broke the German line in April 1945, the resistance committee for the north called a general rising for 25 April and decreed that members of the fascist government were to be punished with death.

How each side saw it

The resistance command

The National Liberation Committee for Northern Italy took responsibility on 29 April, calling the shooting the necessary conclusion of a historical phase and the only way to break cleanly with the past. Its argument was that a legitimate Italian authority had sentenced a man guilty of twenty years of dictatorship and of the civil war, and that handing him to foreigners would have left the reckoning to others. Not all of its leaders accepted what followed. Ferruccio Parri, soon to be prime minister, called the scene in Piazzale Loreto a ‘Mexican butchery’, and the socialist Sandro Pertini said the insurrection had been dishonoured by it.

The Allies

Allied commanders had expected to take custody of him, and American intelligence officers were racing to find him along the lake. A trial would have been awkward as well as satisfying, given how long London and Washington had treated him as a respectable statesman. Churchill wrote in his war memoirs that the killing had at least spared the world an Italian Nuremberg. He was angrier about Petacci, and asked his commander in Italy in May 1945 whether she had been on any list of war criminals and who had given authority to shoot her.

The Petacci family and Mussolini’s loyalists

For those who remained loyal to him, and for the neo-fascist party founded in 1946, he was murdered without trial by communists, and the display at Piazzale Loreto showed the character of the victors. Clara Petacci held no office and had been charged with no crime; her family spent decades seeking a judicial finding that her death was unlawful, without success. Her brother Marcello was shot at Dongo the same evening. Mussolini’s tomb at Predappio, his birthplace, draws admirers in black shirts every year on the anniversaries of his birth, his death and the March on Rome.

Historians

Claudio Pavone’s work established ‘civil war’ as a description of 1943-45, a term the Italian left had long resisted, and placed the shooting within its logic of reprisal. Sergio Luzzatto treats the upside-down body as a founding image of the republic, an inversion of the balcony from which Mussolini had ruled. Renzo De Felice, his principal biographer, hinted late in life that British agents had a hand in the death in order to recover compromising letters from Churchill. No such letters have been produced, and most historians regard the theory as unsupported.

What is disputed

Almost every detail of the shooting rests on Audisio, whose versions differed, and on comrades bound by party discipline. Others have been named as the man who fired: Aldo Lampredi, Michele Moretti, even Longo. A rival account, pressed by the neo-fascist journalist Giorgio Pisano, holds that the pair were killed that morning at the farmhouse and the scene at the gate was staged. A former partisan, Bruno Lonati, claimed in the 1990s to have done it alongside a British officer. The post-mortem carried out in Milan does not settle the question. The fate of the valuables carried by the column, the ‘gold of Dongo’, was never established.

What followed

German forces in Italy signed their surrender at Caserta the next day. Italians voted the monarchy out in June 1946, and an amnesty that month, drawn up by the communist justice minister Palmiro Togliatti, freed most fascists from prosecution; there was no Italian Nuremberg. Mussolini’s body was stolen from its unmarked grave in 1946 by young neo-fascists, hidden for eleven years, and handed to his widow in 1957. Italy keeps 25 April as Liberation Day and argues every year over what it means.

Read further

  • R. J. B. Bosworth, Mussolini (2002)
  • Sergio Luzzatto, The Body of Il Duce: Mussolini’s Corpse and the Fortunes of Italy (2005)
  • Ray Moseley, Mussolini: The Last 600 Days of Il Duce (2004)
  • Claudio Pavone, A Civil War: A History of the Italian Resistance (2013)
  • Denis Mack Smith, Mussolini (1981)

Same day, other years

1192

The king-elect of Jerusalem is stabbed in Tyre

Tyre, LebanonMiddle East

Conrad of Montferrat, the north Italian nobleman who had saved Tyre from Saladin in 1187, had learned only days before that the barons of the crusader kingdom had chosen him as king over Richard of England’s candidate. Walking home through the narrow streets after dining with the bishop of Beauvais, he was approached by two men he knew as Christian converts in his own service. They stabbed him. One was cut down on the spot; the other, under torture, was said to have named his employer. Both were Nizari Ismailis, sent by Rashid al-Din Sinan, the Syrian leader of the sect that Europeans called the Assassins. Within days Conrad’s pregnant widow, Isabella, was married to Richard’s nephew.

Seen from elsewhere. Who hired them was never agreed. French chroniclers blamed Richard, and he was later held prisoner in Germany partly on that charge. Ibn al-Athir says Saladin paid for the deaths of both Conrad and Richard. Saladin’s secretary Imad al-Din denies it, noting that Conrad was then negotiating with the sultan. A crusader source says Conrad had simply seized an Ismaili merchant ship.

1789

Mutiny on the Bounty

Off Tofua, TongaOceania

At dawn Fletcher Christian, acting lieutenant of the armed vessel Bounty, had his commander, Lieutenant William Bligh, dragged from his cabin in his nightshirt and put into the ship’s launch with eighteen loyal men. The Bounty had spent five months at Tahiti collecting breadfruit seedlings, intended as cheap food for enslaved workers on Britain’s Caribbean plantations. Bligh navigated the open boat some 3,600 nautical miles to Timor in forty-seven days, losing one man, killed by islanders on Tofua. Christian, with eight mutineers, six Polynesian men, twelve women and a baby, eventually hid on uninhabited Pitcairn Island and burned the ship. When an American sealer found the settlement in 1808, one of the mutineers was still alive.

Seen from elsewhere. Bligh blamed the lure of Tahiti; Christian’s family blamed Bligh’s tongue, and the argument has run ever since. The Polynesians have one witness, a woman named Teehuteatuaonoa, called Jenny, whose account was printed in 1819. She says most of the women were carried off by a trick, and that the Tahitian men were treated as servants until they rebelled.

1952

Japan regains its sovereignty, without Okinawa

Tokyo, JapanAsia

The peace treaty signed at San Francisco the previous September came into force, and the Allied occupation of Japan ended after six years and eight months. Japan gave up Korea, Taiwan, the Kuriles and its Pacific mandates and accepted the verdicts of the war crimes tribunals. A security treaty that took effect the same day kept American bases in the country. The settlement was partial: the Soviet Union refused to sign, neither Chinese government was invited, and the two Koreas were left out. Under the treaty’s third article Okinawa and the other Ryukyu Islands, scene of the war’s last great land battle, stayed under American military rule, as they would until 1972.

Seen from elsewhere. Okinawans call 28 April the Day of Humiliation, the day Tokyo bought its freedom by leaving them behind, and thousands protested when the government held a sovereignty anniversary ceremony in 2013. Koreans and Taiwanese living in Japan lost their Japanese nationality on the same day. China and both Koreas have never accepted the treaty’s handling of territory and reparations.

1965

US Marines land in Santo Domingo

Santo Domingo, Dominican RepublicThe Americas

Four days into a revolt by soldiers and civilians seeking to restore Juan Bosch, the elected president overthrown by a coup in 1963, the military junta’s forces were losing control of the capital. President Lyndon Johnson ordered in some 400 Marines that evening, saying they were needed to protect American lives. Within days he gave another reason, that communists had taken over the rising and there must be no second Cuba, and the force grew to more than 22,000. It was the first open United States military intervention in Latin America in three decades. The troops split the city and stayed, under an Organization of American States flag, until 1966. Around 3,000 Dominicans died.

Seen from elsewhere. Dominicans remember the April Revolution and honour its leader, Colonel Francisco Caamano, as a national hero. Washington held that it stopped a civil war and brought elections, which the conservative Joaquin Balaguer won. The embassy’s list of communists among the rebels, a few dozen names, was challenged at once by reporters and by Senator William Fulbright.

Also on 28 April