Parallax

20 April, 1889

A customs official’s son is born at Braunau

Almost nothing about Adolf Hitler’s first years is certain except the parish register. The gap has been filled ever since, first by his own myth-making and then by everyone who has tried to find the cause of what came later in a provincial childhood.

Braunau am Inn, Austria-Hungary

The baptismal register of Braunau am Inn, an Austrian town on the river that marked the frontier with Bavaria, records that a boy was born at half past six in the evening on 20 April 1889, Easter Saturday, in rented rooms above an inn in the Salzburger Vorstadt. He was baptised Adolfus two days later by the parish priest. The father, Alois Hitler, was 51 and a senior official in the imperial customs service. The mother, Klara, was 28 and his third wife.

The household was respectable and comfortably off by the standards of the place. Alois earned more than a headmaster. He had risen from a village childhood and a cobbler’s apprenticeship to the highest grade open to a man of his schooling, wore his uniform with pride and kept bees. He was also, by the testimony of those who knew him, short-tempered, a regular at the tavern and little interested in his family.

Klara Polzl came from the same cluster of villages in the Waldviertel, the poor upland north of the Danube. She had entered Alois’s house as a teenage servant during his first marriage and returned to it during his second. The two were related closely enough to need a dispensation from Rome before they could marry in January 1885; for years afterwards she is said to have gone on calling him Uncle. She had already buried children. Gustav and Ida died of diphtheria within weeks of each other in the winter of 1887-88. Another son, Otto, lived only days; he is usually placed before Adolf, though some recent research puts his short life in 1892. Neighbours remembered a quiet, pious woman who kept an immaculate house and was anxious over the baby.

The family left Braunau when the boy was three, following Alois’s postings to Passau and then Linz. A brother, Edmund, died of measles at six; a sister, Paula, survived. Alois retired in 1895, tried and failed to farm, and settled in the village of Leonding, where he collapsed and died over his morning glass of wine in January 1903. Paula, interviewed by American officers in 1946, said that her brother had provoked their father to great severity and was beaten every day, while their mother tried to make up for it with kindness.

Klara died of breast cancer in December 1907, nursed at the end by her son. Her Jewish physician, Eduard Bloch, wrote long afterwards that he had never seen a young man so broken by grief. Hitler was then 18, had left school without a certificate, and had just failed the entrance examination of the Vienna Academy of Fine Arts. He sent Bloch hand-painted postcards of thanks, and after the annexation of Austria in 1938 had him protected until he could emigrate.

How it came to this

The family name was new. Alois had been born in 1837 to Maria Anna Schicklgruber, an unmarried servant of 42, and the space for his father’s name in the register was left blank. When he was five his mother married a wandering miller’s hand, Johann Georg Hiedler, and the boy was brought up on the farm of Hiedler’s better-off brother, Johann Nepomuk. For 39 years he was Alois Schicklgruber. In 1876, with both his mother and her husband long dead, three witnesses appeared before the priest at Dollersheim and swore that Johann Georg had acknowledged the child. The priest altered the register, and the name was entered in the spelling Hitler.

The Austria into which the boy was born was the German-speaking half of a monarchy of eleven nationalities. Along its borders, and in towns such as Linz, a pan-German movement led by Georg von Schonerer preached union with Bismarck’s Reich, contempt for the Habsburgs, hostility to Slavs and a racial hatred of Jews. Its slogans and its greeting, Heil, were part of schoolboy life in the 1890s. Hitler’s history teacher at Linz was an enthusiast.

How each side saw it

Hitler’s own account

Mein Kampf opens by calling it providential that he was born in a town on the border of two German states whose reunion was his life’s task. In the pages that follow, his father is a dutiful servant of the state with whom he quarrelled only over his wish to be an artist; his mother is adored; poverty is implied and hardship in Vienna much exaggerated. He says nothing of beatings, of his father’s illegitimacy or of his siblings. As chancellor he discouraged research into his family, and biographers agree that the book is a constructed legend, useful mainly for what it leaves out.

Family and neighbours

What we know independently comes from a handful of people questioned much later, each with reasons to shade the story. Paula Hitler spoke to interrogators in 1946. His half-brother Alois junior ran away from home at 14 and described the father’s violence. August Kubizek, a boyhood friend from Linz, published a memoir in 1953 that began life as a commission from the Nazi party archive. Dr Bloch wrote in exile for an American magazine. Franz Jetzinger, an Austrian official, gathered documents and testimony after the war. None of them reported anything in the child that foretold the man.

Those who distrust the question

For many survivors, and for writers who speak with them in mind, the search for an explanation in the nursery is itself suspect. The film-maker Claude Lanzmann called it an obscenity to line up the baby photograph and the death camps as if one could lead to the other by steps, and held that to explain was to begin to excuse. The philosopher Emil Fackenheim thought the evil resisted explanation altogether. Against them, the historian Yehuda Bauer has insisted that Hitler was a human being and so in principle explicable, and that saying otherwise lets human beings off too lightly.

Braunau

The town where he lived for three years has had to carry his name ever since. In 1989 the mayor had a block of granite from the Mauthausen concentration camp quarry set on the pavement outside the house, inscribed for peace, freedom and democracy and with the words never again fascism. Residents have long complained of being defined by an accident of a customs posting, and of the visitors who come on 20 April. After years of dispute with its owner, the Austrian state expropriated the building in 2016 and decided to turn it into a police station, a choice that some historians criticised as avoidance.

What is disputed

Who Alois’s father was is unknown: Johann Georg Hiedler, his brother Johann Nepomuk, or someone else. The story told by Hans Frank before his execution in 1946, that the grandfather was a Jew from Graz named Frankenberger, has been rejected by Ian Kershaw, Brigitte Hamann and most others, since no such family is recorded and Jews were not then permitted to live in Graz. Psychological readings built on the beatings, such as Alice Miller’s, are widely thought to explain too much, since such upbringings were common. When his hatred of Jews formed, in Linz, in Vienna or only after 1918, remains open.

What followed

He moved to Vienna in 1908, to Munich in 1913, and found a purpose in the German army in 1914. From 1933 his birthday was a day of flags and parades in Germany, and a public holiday in 1939. He spent his last one, his fifty-sixth, in the bunker in Berlin and killed himself ten days later. The war he began cost tens of millions of lives, among them six million Jews murdered by his state. The date is still marked by neo-Nazi groups, which is one reason Germany and Austria police it, and why the fate of one ordinary house remains a public question.

Read further

  • Ian Kershaw, Hitler, 1889-1936: Hubris (1998)
  • Brigitte Hamann, Hitler’s Vienna: A Dictator’s Apprenticeship (1999)
  • Franz Jetzinger, Hitler’s Youth (1958)
  • Ron Rosenbaum, Explaining Hitler: The Search for the Origins of His Evil (1998)
  • Volker Ullrich, Hitler: Ascent, 1889-1939 (2016)

Same day, other years

1770

Cook’s lookout sights the Australian coast

Point Hicks, south-eastern AustraliaOceania

At six in the morning Lieutenant Zachary Hicks, on watch aboard HMS Endeavour, saw land ahead: low hills and sand on what is now the coast of Victoria. James Cook, coming west from New Zealand after observing the transit of Venus at Tahiti, turned north and followed the shore for four months, charting some 2,000 miles of it. He landed first at Botany Bay, where two Gweagal men stood on the rocks and opposed the boats with spears until one was wounded by musket shot. In August, on an island off Cape York, he claimed the whole east coast for George III.

Seen from elsewhere. The continent had been inhabited for 50,000 years or more, and Dutch ships had charted its western and northern shores since 1606. Cook’s instructions told him to take possession with the consent of the natives; none was asked. His journal gives the date as the 19th, by ship’s time kept from noon and without correction for longitude.

1792

France declares war on Austria

ParisEurope

Louis XVI came to the Legislative Assembly and, in a flat voice, proposed war against his own wife’s nephew, the new Habsburg ruler Francis, styled King of Bohemia and Hungary. Only seven deputies voted against. The Girondin leader Brissot and his friends wanted a crusade that would carry liberty abroad and force traitors at home into the open. The court wanted war for the opposite reason, expecting a French defeat and rescue by foreign armies. Both got more than they expected. Fighting continued, with one short pause, for twenty-three years and drew in every European power.

Seen from elsewhere. Robespierre had spent the winter arguing against it at the Jacobin club, warning that nobody loves armed missionaries and that war would hand power to generals. Marie Antoinette secretly sent the French campaign plans to Vienna. The first battles went so badly that the monarchy was overthrown within four months.

1914

The Ludlow massacre

Ludlow, ColoradoThe Americas

Some 1,200 striking coal miners and their families, most of them Greek, Italian, Slav and Mexican immigrants evicted from company housing, had spent the winter in a tent colony on the Colorado plain. They were striking against the Rockefeller-controlled Colorado Fuel and Iron Company for union recognition and the enforcement of state mining law. On the morning after Orthodox Easter the state militia, by then largely made up of company guards, opened fire on the camp with rifles and a machine gun and at dusk set the tents alight. Two women and eleven children suffocated in a pit dug beneath one of them.

Seen from elsewhere. The militia’s inquiry held that the strikers fired first, and counts of the dead range from nineteen to twenty-five. Miners answered with ten days of open warfare across the coalfield until federal troops arrived. John D. Rockefeller Jr, who had defended the company’s stand before Congress weeks earlier, hired a publicist and introduced a company union.

1980

The Berber Spring

Tizi Ouzou, AlgeriaAfrica

In March the Algerian authorities cancelled a lecture on ancient Kabyle poetry that the writer Mouloud Mammeri was to give at the university of Tizi Ouzou. Students occupied the campus, and strikes spread through the Berber-speaking region of Kabylia with demands that its language, Tamazight, be recognised alongside Arabic. Before dawn on 20 April riot police stormed the university, the hospital and nearby factories, injuring hundreds and arresting hundreds more. Kabylia answered with a general strike. It was the first mass challenge to the single-party state since independence in 1962.

Seen from elsewhere. The governing FLN held that Algeria was an Arab and Muslim nation and that talk of a separate Berber identity revived a French colonial tactic of divide and rule. Rumours of deaths that night were never confirmed. Tamazight was made a national language in 2002 and an official one in 2016, after further protests in which gendarmes killed more than a hundred people.

Also on 20 April