Parallax

16 April, 1746

Culloden

The last pitched battle fought in Britain was over in under an hour. What the winners did in the weeks afterwards is the reason it is still argued about.

Culloden Moor, near Inverness, Scotland

The Jacobite army had been awake for most of two days. On the evening of 15 April, the Duke of Cumberland’s twenty-fifth birthday, Prince Charles Edward Stuart sent his men on a twelve-mile night march to surprise the government camp at Nairn while it slept off its brandy. The columns lost touch in the dark and the bog, dawn found them still short of the enemy, and they turned back. Many had eaten one biscuit in twenty-four hours. Some were asleep in the parks of Culloden House, and others had gone to Inverness to look for food, when the drums of Cumberland’s army were heard coming on.

Between five and six thousand men formed up on Drummossie Moor, open, level and wet, ground chosen by the prince’s Irish adjutant John O’Sullivan. His best general, Lord George Murray, had argued that it was made for the enemy’s cannon and cavalry and had wanted broken ground across the river. He was overruled. Facing them were about eight thousand regulars, fed and rested, in three lines, with ten field guns and mortars. It was cold, and sleet blew into the Jacobites’ faces.

The government artillery opened at about one o’clock and for some minutes the Jacobite line stood under round shot waiting for an order. When the charge came it was ragged. The clans of the right and centre, Camerons, Stewarts of Appin, Atholl men, Clan Chattan, ran forward through grapeshot, swerved from boggy ground and crowded together, and struck the left of Cumberland’s front line. They broke into Barrell’s regiment and were caught by the second line and by musketry on their flank from behind a stone wall. On the Jacobite left the Macdonalds, with further to go over worse ground, never closed.

It lasted perhaps forty minutes. The Jacobites lost some 1,500 dead; Cumberland reported fifty killed and about 260 wounded. His dragoons rode down fugitives along the road to Inverness, bystanders among them. Wounded men were bayoneted on the field, and others lay there for two days before parties were sent to shoot or club them.

Charles was led away by his officers. He spent five months hiding in the western Highlands and islands with a price of 30,000 pounds on his head, was taken over the sea to Skye disguised as Flora MacDonald’s maid, and was never betrayed. A French ship took him off in September. He did not see Scotland again.

How it came to this

The Stuarts had lost the thrones of England, Scotland and Ireland in 1688, when the Catholic James II and VII was driven out in favour of his Protestant daughter and her Dutch husband. His supporters, called Jacobites from the Latin for James, rose for him and for his son in 1689, 1715 and 1719 and failed each time. They were strongest in the Scottish Highlands and the Episcopalian north-east, where clan chiefs and lairds could bring out their tenants, but there were Jacobites in England and Ireland too, and the cause always depended on the hope of French troops.

In July 1745, with Britain and France at war, the exiled claimant’s son Charles landed in the Hebrides with seven companions and no army. Within two months he had raised the clans, taken Edinburgh and routed a government force at Prestonpans. He marched into England and reached Derby, 125 miles from London, on 4 December. English Jacobites did not rise and the French did not come, and his council forced him to turn back. Cumberland, the king’s younger son, followed him north through the winter.

How each side saw it

The Jacobite officers

The defeated blamed each other at once. Lord George Murray wrote to the prince the day after the battle resigning his commission and condemning the choice of ground, the neglect of supplies and the influence of O’Sullivan and the Irish officers. Charles, who had commanded in person for the first time, came to believe Murray had betrayed him and refused ever to receive him again. The Chevalier de Johnstone, an aide who escaped to France, left a memoir that describes starving men sent to fight on a plain against artillery, and judged that the army was thrown away.

Gaelic Scotland

The Highlanders’ own record is in Gaelic verse. John Roy Stuart, who commanded the Edinburgh regiment on the day, composed two songs on Culloden lamenting the dead and cursing the wind, the hunger and the generalship. Their experience of what followed was gathered by an Episcopalian clergyman, Robert Forbes, who spent years collecting signed statements from survivors and witnesses in a manuscript he called The Lyon in Mourning: townships burned, cattle driven off by the thousand, men shot in their fields, women raped, prisoners left to die in ships’ holds.

The government and its supporters

To Whig Britain the rising was an attempt, backed by an enemy power in wartime, to impose a Catholic and absolutist dynasty by force, and its defeat was a deliverance. Cumberland was voted an income by Parliament, Handel wrote Judas Maccabaeus in his honour, and Glasgow and the Presbyterian Lowlands, which had been made to pay levies to the prince’s army, gave thanks. Three Scottish regiments and Highland companies of Campbells fought in Cumberland’s ranks. The duke wrote that mild measures would not do with such people. His officers pointed to an order, said to have been found on a prisoner, telling the Jacobites to give no quarter.

What is disputed

The date is Old Style; by the modern calendar the battle fell on 27 April. The ‘no quarter’ order is the sharpest dispute: copies of Murray’s genuine orders survive without the phrase, and most historians regard the version used to justify the killings as a forgery or a tampered text. Figures for both armies and for the Jacobite dead vary by several hundred. The battle was not Scotland against England, nor simply Highlands against Lowlands: Murray Pittock argues the Jacobite army was a conventionally drilled force drawn from much of Scotland, and that the image of a doomed charge by swordsmen was a later simplification. The Highland Clearances came generations later and from different causes.

What followed

About 3,500 people were taken prisoner; some 120 were executed, including three peers, and more than 900 transported to the colonies. Parliament banned Highland dress, disarmed the clans and abolished the chiefs’ hereditary courts, measures that turned chiefs into landlords. Within a decade Highland regiments were being raised for the British army. Charles died in Rome in 1788, a heavy drinker estranged from most of those who had served him. In the nineteenth century the cause he lost became romance, with tartan worn by the royal family that had defeated it. The moor is a war grave and remains a place where Scots argue about who they are.

Read further

  • Robert Forbes, The Lyon in Mourning (1895-96)
  • John Prebble, Culloden (1961)
  • Christopher Duffy, The ‘45: Bonnie Prince Charlie and the Untold Story of the Jacobite Rising (2003)
  • Murray Pittock, Culloden (2016)
  • Chevalier de Johnstone, Memoirs of the Rebellion in 1745 and 1746 (1820)

Same day, other years

1853

India’s first passenger train

Bombay to Thane, British IndiaAsia

At half past three in the afternoon a train of fourteen carriages carrying four hundred invited guests left Bori Bunder station in Bombay to a salute of twenty-one guns, hauled by three locomotives named Sahib, Sindh and Sultan. It covered the thirty-four kilometres to Thane in under an hour. The Great Indian Peninsula Railway had been built by British engineers and Indian labourers with capital raised in London. The governor-general, Lord Dalhousie, had laid out the case for trunk lines in a long minute: they would move troops quickly, carry raw cotton to the ports and bring British goods inland. By 1900 India had some 40,000 kilometres of track, among the largest networks in the world.

Seen from elsewhere. Indian economic nationalists such as Dadabhai Naoroji and Romesh Chunder Dutt argued that the railways were built for Britain’s purposes at India’s cost: investors were guaranteed a five per cent return paid from Indian taxes whatever a line earned, and freight rates favoured exports over internal trade. Defenders point to famine relief and a unified market. Both effects were real.

1917

Lenin arrives at the Finland Station

Petrograd, RussiaEurope

The tsar had abdicated a month earlier, and Vladimir Lenin, in exile in Zurich, had no way home across the front lines. The German government, calculating that he would undermine Russia’s war effort, let him and some thirty other revolutionaries cross Germany in a railway carriage treated as foreign territory. He reached Petrograd late on the evening of 3 April by the Russian calendar, 16 April in the West. A band and a guard of honour were waiting. He brushed aside the welcoming speech of the Soviet’s chairman and told the crowd that the revolution had only begun. Next day he set out his April Theses: no support for the provisional government, an end to the war, all power to the soviets.

Seen from elsewhere. His own party’s leaders in Petrograd, Kamenev and Stalin among them, thought the programme reckless, and Pravda printed it as his personal opinion. The provisional government and much of the press called him a German agent. That Germany arranged his passage and channelled money to the Bolsheviks is established; that he took German direction is not.

1961

Castro declares the Cuban revolution socialist

Havana, CubaThe Americas

On 15 April aircraft painted with Cuban markings and flown by exiles in the pay of the Central Intelligence Agency bombed three Cuban airfields, killing seven people. At their funeral the next day, at the corner of 23rd and 12th streets in Havana, Fidel Castro told a crowd of armed militia that what the United States could not forgive was that Cubans had made a socialist revolution under its very nose. It was the first time he had used the word in public for his government. Before dawn on 17 April some 1,400 exiles landed at the Bay of Pigs. They were defeated within three days, and by the end of the year Castro had declared himself a Marxist-Leninist.

Seen from elsewhere. Washington and the exiles held that Castro had been a concealed Communist from the start and had betrayed a democratic revolution. Castro’s supporters, and some historians, argue that American hostility pushed a nationalist movement towards Moscow. Cubans who had fought Batista and then opposed one-party rule were by then in prison, in exile or in the landing force.

2014

The Sewol ferry capsizes

Off Jindo, South KoreaAsia

The ferry Sewol, sailing overnight from Incheon to the island of Jeju, made a sharp turn in a channel off the south-west coast shortly before nine in the morning, listed and did not recover. She had been altered to carry more passengers and was loaded with about twice her permitted cargo, badly secured. Of the 476 people on board, 325 were pupils of Danwon High School on a school trip. The crew repeatedly told passengers over the loudspeakers to stay in their cabins. The captain and most of the crew left on the first coastguard boat. Fishermen and other vessels rescued 172 people; 304 died, about 250 of them schoolchildren.

Seen from elsewhere. The captain was sentenced to life for murder. Bereaved families held the state as much to blame as the crew: regulators had passed the ship, the coastguard failed to enter it, and President Park Geun-hye was absent from view for hours. Officials resisted an independent inquiry for years. The yellow ribbon of the families became a symbol in the protests that preceded Park’s removal.

Also on 16 April