Martin Luther reached Worms on 16 April 1521 in a two-wheeled cart, with an imperial herald riding ahead and, by several accounts, a couple of thousand people in the streets to see him arrive. He was 37, a professor of theology at the small Saxon university of Wittenberg, and had been excommunicated by the pope three months earlier. He came under a safe-conduct from the emperor. Everyone present knew that Jan Hus had held one too, a century before, and had been burned at Constance all the same.
The next afternoon he was brought before Charles V, the electors and the princes of the empire. A pile of his books lay on a bench. Johann von der Ecken, an official of the archbishop of Trier, put two questions: were these his, and would he retract what was in them? Luther acknowledged the books. To the second question he replied, in a voice some could hardly hear, that it touched faith and the salvation of souls and he begged time to think. The emperor allowed him one day.
On 18 April the hearing moved to a larger hall. It was evening before he was called, the room was lit by torches and so crowded that few besides the emperor could sit. This time he spoke firmly, in German and then again in Latin. His books, he said, were of three kinds. Some dealt with faith and morals so simply that even his enemies found them useful. Some attacked the papacy, and to withdraw those would be to strengthen tyranny. Some attacked individuals, more harshly than became a monk, but he could not retract those either.
Von der Ecken told him he had not answered and demanded a reply without horns. Luther gave it. Unless he were convinced by the testimony of scripture or by clear reason, since he trusted neither popes nor councils alone, he was bound by the texts he had cited and his conscience was captive to the word of God. He could not and would not recant anything, because to act against conscience was neither safe nor right. God help him, amen.
The emperor rose and the session broke up in noise. Luther went out raising his arms like a knight who has won a bout; Spanish attendants at the door shouted that he should go to the fire. Next day Charles read the princes a statement in French written in his own hand. He was descended, he said, from the most Christian emperors and Catholic kings, and a single friar who set himself against a thousand years of Christendom must be in error. He would proceed against him as a notorious heretic. But he would keep his word on the safe-conduct.
How it came to this
The quarrel had begun in 1517 over indulgences, the remissions of penance then being sold across Germany to help pay for the rebuilding of St Peter’s in Rome and to clear the debts of the archbishop of Mainz. Luther’s ninety-five theses questioned the practice; the arguments that followed pushed him much further. At Leipzig in 1519 his opponent Johann Eck manoeuvred him into saying that councils could err and that Hus had been condemned unjustly. In 1520 he published three tracts denying the pope’s authority over scripture, reducing the seven sacraments to two or three, and calling on the German nobility to reform the church themselves.
Rome answered with the bull Exsurge Domine, which Luther burned outside the gate of Wittenberg in December 1520. Excommunication followed in January. Normally the secular power would then have acted. But Luther’s prince, Elector Frederick of Saxony, insisted that a German should not be condemned unheard, and the newly elected Charles V, 21 years old and in need of the princes’ money and soldiers, agreed to summon him before the imperial diet.