Parallax

18 January, 1871

A German emperor is proclaimed in the palace of the French kings

The ceremony that founded the German Empire took place in Louis XIV’s Hall of Mirrors while Paris starved a few miles away. The man it honoured had spent the previous day in tears, saying it would bury the Prussia he loved.

Versailles, France

On the afternoon of 17 January 1871, in the prefecture at Versailles that served as Prussian royal headquarters, King Wilhelm I quarrelled with his chief minister for three hours about a title. Wilhelm, who was seventy-three, wanted to be Emperor of Germany if he had to be emperor at all. Bismarck told him it could not be done: the south German kings had agreed only to ‘German Emperor’, a presiding rank among equals that claimed no territory of theirs. Wilhelm broke off the meeting, wept, and told those around him that tomorrow would be the unhappiest day of his life, for they were carrying the Prussian kingship to its grave.

The next day was chosen with care. On 18 January 1701 the first Prussian king had crowned himself at Koenigsberg, and exactly 170 years later the princes, generals and regimental delegations of the German armies besieging Paris filed into the Hall of Mirrors at noon. Above them, on the ceiling, Le Brun’s paintings showed Louis XIV crossing the Rhine and humbling German towns. A field altar stood where the French court had danced. Several hundred officers crowded the gallery with their colours; civilians were scarce, and no deputy of any German parliament had a part in the ceremony.

A court chaplain preached a sermon that dwelt heavily on French sins. Then Bismarck, in his blue cuirassier’s tunic, read the proclamation to the German people in a flat voice. The awkward matter of the title was solved by the Grand Duke of Baden, Wilhelm’s son-in-law, who stepped forward and called for cheers for ‘His Imperial and Royal Majesty, Kaiser Wilhelm’, naming neither Germany nor the Germans.

The hall roared. The new emperor came down from the dais, walked past Bismarck without a glance or a handshake, and greeted his generals. Bismarck wrote to his wife that the imperial birth had been a difficult one and that he had felt like a bomb ready to burst.

It was not, in the usual sense, a coronation. There was no crown, no anointing and no oath; the new constitution had in law taken effect on 1 January. What happened at Versailles was the announcement, by soldiers to soldiers on conquered ground, of a state that already existed on paper. Ten days later Paris capitulated.

How it came to this

Germany in 1860 was a geographical term covering more than thirty sovereign states, loosely joined in a confederation presided over by Austria. The liberals who had tried to unite it by parliamentary vote in 1848-49 had offered a crown to the King of Prussia, who refused to pick it up, as he said, from the gutter. Bismarck, appointed in 1862 to fight the Prussian parliament over army funding, took the opposite road. A war against Denmark in 1864 and another against Austria in 1866 expelled the Habsburgs from German affairs and left Prussia at the head of a North German Confederation.

The Catholic south, Bavaria above all, stayed outside and wary. The war with France, which broke out in July 1870 over a Hohenzollern candidacy for the Spanish throne and a telegram Bismarck had edited to give offence, brought the southern armies in on Prussia’s side. Napoleon III was captured at Sedan in September. During the autumn Bismarck negotiated the southern states into the union one by one, and Ludwig II of Bavaria was induced, with a letter Bismarck drafted and secret annual payments, to invite Wilhelm to take the imperial title.

How each side saw it

The French

For France the choice of room was the point and the insult. Versailles was the monument of the monarchy at its height, and the Germans had made it a military hospital and then the birthplace of their empire while shelling the capital. The peace signed at Frankfurt in May took Alsace and much of Lorraine and imposed an indemnity of five billion francs. Gambetta’s advice about the lost provinces, to think of them always and speak of them never, set the tone for a generation, and schoolroom maps showed them shaded in mourning. In 1919 the French government insisted that Germany sign its defeat in the same hall.

Bavarians and other south Germans

The Bavarian parliament ratified the treaties only on 21 January, after the proclamation, and only by a margin of two votes over the required two thirds. The Catholic Patriot Party saw the new Reich as a Protestant Prussian barracks swallowing an older country. Ludwig II stayed away from Versailles and his brother Otto, who attended, wrote home that everything had seemed cold, proud, glittering and heartless. Bavaria kept its own army in peacetime, its own post and railways and its beer tax, reserved rights that Bavarians still cite, and its king’s letter of invitation had been bought.

German socialists and democrats

August Bebel and Wilhelm Liebknecht, the two socialist deputies in the North German parliament, had abstained on the first war credits and voted against the later ones once the war became one of conquest, and they denounced the annexation of Alsace-Lorraine as a guarantee of future war. Both were convicted of preparing treason in 1872 and imprisoned. Liebknecht called the Reich a princely insurance company against democracy. Old 1848 liberals were divided: many accepted unity from Bismarck’s hands as the thing they had wanted, others noted that parliament had been invited to the founding of the nation only as a petitioner.

The Prussian court

Wilhelm’s reluctance was sincere. He thought the imperial title a hollow brevet rank and feared Prussia would dissolve into Germany. His son, Crown Prince Friedrich Wilhelm, felt the opposite: his war diary shows a romantic enthusiast for a restored empire who pressed his father and found Bismarck too cautious. Bismarck himself treated the title as a political necessity to bind the south. In his memoirs he describes the dispute over the wording with open exasperation, and the king’s refusal to shake his hand as a grievance that lasted some days.

What is disputed

Popular accounts, and the familiar paintings, call it a coronation; it was a proclamation, and Anton von Werner’s best-known canvas of it, painted in 1885, puts Bismarck in a white uniform he did not wear and at the centre of a scene in which he had stood to one side. The larger argument is what was founded. Hans-Ulrich Wehler and the Sonderweg school saw an authoritarian military monarchy whose birth on a battlefield marked it for catastrophe; David Blackbourn, Geoff Eley and Thomas Nipperdey replied that imperial Germany was a law-bound state with universal male suffrage, and that 1933 cannot be read back into 1871.

What followed

The empire proclaimed at Versailles lasted forty-seven years and had three emperors, the last of whom abdicated in November 1918. On 28 June 1919 German delegates were brought to the Hall of Mirrors to sign the peace treaty that returned Alsace-Lorraine and assigned Germany responsibility for the war. Hitler in turn staged the French armistice of 1940 in the railway carriage used in 1918. The use of ceremony as revenge, begun on 18 January, ran through three wars, and the Franco-German reconciliation after 1945 was built in conscious rejection of it.

Read further

  • Otto Pflanze, Bismarck and the Development of Germany (1990)
  • Michael Howard, The Franco-Prussian War (1961)
  • Christopher Clark, Iron Kingdom: The Rise and Downfall of Prussia, 1600-1947 (2006)
  • Jonathan Steinberg, Bismarck: A Life (2011)
  • Otto von Bismarck, Gedanken und Erinnerungen (1898)

Same day, other years

1535

Pizarro founds the City of the Kings

Lima, PeruThe Americas

Francisco Pizarro needed a capital with access to the sea, which the Inca city of Cuzco, high in the Andes, could not give him. On 18 January 1535 he laid out a grid of streets on the south bank of the Rimac river, a few miles from the Pacific, and named it the Ciudad de los Reyes. The site was no empty plain. It was the irrigated valley of a local lord, Taulichusco, with temples, canals and fields, and the Spanish plaza was set over his compound. The older name of the valley, Lima, outlasted the official one.

Seen from elsewhere. For Andean peoples the foundation moved the centre of their world from the mountains to a foreign port facing Spain. In 1536 an Inca army under Quizu Yupanqui besieged the new town and was beaten off with the help of coastal allies. Peruvian historians still debate whether 18 January is a birthday to celebrate.

1778

James Cook’s ships sight the Hawaiian Islands

Oahu and Kauai, HawaiiOceania

Sailing north from Tahiti towards the American coast on his third voyage, Cook saw the island of Oahu at daybreak on 18 January 1778, then Kauai, where he landed two days later at Waimea. He was astonished to find people speaking a language close to Tahitian thousands of miles away, and wrote admiringly of the reach of the Polynesian nation. He named the group after the Earl of Sandwich. His men traded iron nails for food and, despite his orders, slept with Hawaiian women. Cook was killed on the island of Hawaii thirteen months later.

Seen from elsewhere. Hawaiians had settled the islands centuries earlier; ‘discovery’ is a European term. The nineteenth-century Hawaiian historian Samuel Kamakau recorded traditions that the ships brought venereal disease and the first of the epidemics that cut the population by most estimates by more than three quarters within a century. Scholars still argue over whether Cook was taken for the god Lono.

1919

The Paris Peace Conference opens

Paris, FranceWorldwide

Delegates of twenty-seven victorious nations met at the French foreign ministry on the Quai d’Orsay on 18 January 1919 to settle the peace after the First World War. Clemenceau, who presided, had chosen the anniversary of the German proclamation of 1871. The defeated powers were not invited to negotiate, and Russia, in the middle of civil war, was not represented at all. Over six months the leaders of France, Britain, the United States and Italy redrew the map of Europe and the Middle East, created the League of Nations and distributed Germany’s colonies and the Ottoman Arab lands among themselves as mandates.

Seen from elsewhere. Germans called the result a dictated peace. Outside Europe, Wilson’s talk of self-determination raised hopes that the conference ignored: Egyptian, Korean and Indian nationalists were refused a hearing, a young Vietnamese later known as Ho Chi Minh petitioned in vain, and the award of German rights in Shandong to Japan set off China’s May Fourth protests.

1943

The first shots of resistance in the Warsaw Ghetto

Warsaw, German-occupied PolandEurope

The previous summer the Germans had deported some 265,000 Jews from the Warsaw Ghetto to the gas chambers of Treblinka almost without opposition. When SS and police units entered again on 18 January 1943 to seize several thousand more, members of the Jewish Fighting Organisation led by Mordechai Anielewicz, armed with a few pistols and grenades, joined a column of deportees and opened fire at close range. Others fought from buildings. The Germans took about 5,000 people in four days, killed more than a thousand in the streets, and then withdrew, short of their quota.

Seen from elsewhere. Ghetto residents believed, wrongly, that resistance had stopped a final liquidation; the belief brought the fighters recruits, money and bunkers for the larger rising in April. Many elders had long opposed armed action as an invitation to massacre. How much the Polish underground could or should have supplied in arms is still argued between Polish and Jewish historians.

Also on 18 January