Parallax

5 January, 1066

Edward the Confessor dies without an heir

The old king’s last words about the succession were heard by four or five people in a bedchamber. Three armies spent the rest of the year arguing over what he had meant.

Westminster, England

King Edward kept Christmas of 1065 at Westminster, where the great church he had spent years building beside the Thames was ready to be consecrated. He was about sixty and had been unwell since the autumn, when a rebellion in Northumbria had forced him to exile his favourite, Earl Tostig, and left him raging at his own helplessness. He managed to appear at the feast on Christmas Day. On 28 December the abbey was dedicated without him. He was in bed in the palace next door, and he did not get up again.

The fullest account of what followed comes from a Life of the king written within a year or two for his widow, Queen Edith. It places four people at the bedside: Edith herself, sitting on the floor warming his feet in her lap; her brother Harold, Earl of Wessex, the most powerful man in the kingdom; Robert fitzWimarc, a Norman-born steward of the household; and Stigand, the Archbishop of Canterbury.

After two days in which he barely spoke, Edward woke and described a dream. Two monks he had known in his youth in Normandy had told him that because of the sins of England’s earls and churchmen God had given the kingdom into the hands of the enemy for a year and a day, and that devils would go through the land with fire and sword. Its troubles would end only when a green tree, cut through the trunk and carried far off, joined itself again and bore fruit. Stigand whispered to Harold that the old man was worn out and raving.

Then, according to the Life, Edward thanked Edith for serving him like a daughter, stretched his hand towards Harold and said that he commended this woman and all the kingdom to his protection. He asked that his foreign servants be allowed to stay or to go home safely, and that his death not be hidden. He died in the night between 4 and 5 January.

Things moved fast. On 6 January, the feast of the Epiphany, Edward was buried before the high altar of his new church. The same day, in the same building, the assembled magnates accepted Harold as king and he was crowned. No earlier English king is known to have been consecrated so soon after his predecessor’s death.

Across the Channel, Duke William of Normandy received the news while hunting near Rouen, and is said to have gone home without speaking to anyone. In Norway, King Harald Hardrada began to gather ships. Harold Godwinson reigned for a little over nine months.

How it came to this

Edward was the son of King Aethelred and Emma of Normandy. When the Danes conquered England in his childhood he was taken to his mother’s homeland and grew up there, an exile for a quarter of a century, while Cnut and then Cnut’s sons ruled. He was called back in 1041 and became king the next year, a middle-aged man with Norman habits and friends in a country run by three great earls. The greatest was Godwin of Wessex, whose daughter Edith he married in 1045. The marriage produced no children.

That left the succession open. In 1051 Edward quarrelled with Godwin and drove the whole family abroad, and Norman writers say that he then promised the throne to his cousin’s son, Duke William. The Godwins forced their way back within a year. In 1057 a nephew, Edward the Exile, was brought home from Hungary and died within days of landing, leaving a small son, Edgar. Around 1064 Harold Godwinson crossed to the Continent, fell into William’s hands and swore him some kind of oath. By the end of 1065 Harold commanded the army and governed in the king’s name.

How each side saw it

The English account

The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, in the versions kept in these years, says that Earl Harold succeeded to the kingdom as the king had granted it to him and as men had chosen him to it. It adds a short poem praising Edward and saying that the wise king entrusted the realm to a man of high rank. The twelfth-century chronicler John of Worcester, working from earlier English material, says Harold was elected by the chief men of all England and crowned by Ealdred, Archbishop of York. In English law as these writers understood it, a dying king’s word and the assent of the great men made a king. By both tests Harold qualified.

The Norman account

William of Poitiers, the duke’s chaplain, writing in the 1070s, states that Edward had long since made William his heir with the consent of the English magnates, had given hostages, and had sent Harold to Normandy to confirm it by oath. Harold had sworn on relics to uphold William’s claim and was therefore a perjurer and usurper. Norman writers also say he was crowned by Stigand, whom the papacy did not recognise, so the coronation was void. The Bayeux Tapestry shows the oath and the deathbed without saying what was sworn or said. Pope Alexander II is reported to have sent William a banner.

Norway, and the boy with the best blood

The Norse claim is known mainly from sagas written down more than a century later, chiefly Snorri Sturluson’s Heimskringla. It rested on a treaty of about 1040 between Magnus of Norway and Cnut’s son Harthacnut, under which each was to inherit the other’s kingdoms. Harald Hardrada regarded himself as Magnus’s heir. The claimant with the strongest hereditary right was Edgar, grandson of Edmund Ironside, who was perhaps thirteen. No source records anyone speaking for him in January. After Hastings the English leaders in London did elect him king, and he submitted to William before he could be crowned.

Queen Edith

Edith is the only one of those at the deathbed whose view was written down at her own request, and the Life she commissioned is a strange document. It was begun to glorify her father and brothers and breaks off, after the disasters of 1066 in which three of her brothers died, to become a portrait of a holy king. It hints that the marriage was chaste, which later made Edward a saint and also explained the lack of an heir without blame to her. It never says that Edward made Harold king, only that he placed the kingdom in his protection.

What is disputed

Almost every element is contested. English sources date the death to 5 January; some later ones say the 4th, and it probably happened in the night. Whether Edward ever promised William the throne in 1051, and whether he could have done so without the magnates, is doubted by many historians, though Tom Licence has recently argued that Edward consistently favoured Edgar. What Harold swore in Normandy, where, and whether under duress, is known only from Norman writers. The deathbed words may describe a regency, not a bequest. Edward’s celibacy is a claim of the Life and of later monks. He is also often called England’s only canonised king, which overlooks Edmund of East Anglia and Edward the Martyr.

What followed

Harold beat the Norwegians at Stamford Bridge in September and was killed at Hastings on 14 October. William was crowned in Edward’s abbey on Christmas Day, claiming to be his lawful heir, and every English coronation since has taken place there. The conquest replaced the landowning class, the bishops and the language of government. Edward himself was canonised in 1161 at the urging of Henry II, who wanted a saintly ancestor. Henry III rebuilt the abbey around his shrine, where the body still lies. The green tree of his dream was later read as fulfilled by Henry I’s marriage to a descendant of the old royal line.

Read further

  • Frank Barlow, Edward the Confessor (1970)
  • Tom Licence, Edward the Confessor: Last of the Royal Blood (2020)
  • Frank Barlow (ed.), The Life of King Edward Who Rests at Westminster (1962)
  • William of Poitiers, Gesta Guillelmi, edited by R. H. C. Davis and Marjorie Chibnall (1998)
  • Pauline Stafford, Queen Emma and Queen Edith: Queenship and Women’s Power in Eleventh-Century England (1997)

Same day, other years

1463

Francois Villon is banished and disappears

Paris, FranceEurope

The Parlement of Paris set aside a sentence of hanging passed on Francois Villon, master of arts, and banished him from the city and its district for ten years, citing his bad way of life. He was about 31. He had killed a priest in a knife fight in 1455 and been pardoned, had taken part in a burglary at the College of Navarre, and had spent a summer in a bishop’s dungeon. The latest charge arose from a street brawl in which a papal notary was wounded. Villon wrote two short poems on the verdict, one thanking the court. Nothing is known of him after this day. His Testament survived and made him the best remembered French poet of the Middle Ages.

Seen from elsewhere. Nearly everything known of Villon’s life comes from court records found in the nineteenth century and from poems in which he plays a part, the poor scholar among thieves. Scholars warn against reading them as confession. The date is sometimes given as 3 January; the court’s ruling is dated the 5th.

1895

The degradation of Captain Dreyfus

Paris, FranceEurope

In the courtyard of the Ecole Militaire, before troops drawn up in a square and a crowd pressed against the railings, Captain Alfred Dreyfus of the French general staff had his badges of rank torn off and his sword broken in two by a warrant officer of the Republican Guard. A secret court martial had convicted him of selling military secrets to Germany. He was marched round the square shouting that he was innocent. He was then shipped to Devil’s Island off French Guiana. The handwriting on the incriminating note belonged to another officer, Major Esterhazy, and the army’s intelligence service forged documents to keep the conviction standing. Dreyfus was pardoned in 1899 and fully cleared in 1906.

Seen from elsewhere. The crowd shouted for death to the traitor and to the Jews. Anti-Dreyfusards, including much of the Catholic press, held for years that the army’s honour and a court’s verdict outweighed doubts about one man. Theodor Herzl, who reported the ceremony, later said it made him a Zionist, a claim some biographers question.

1970

The Tonghai earthquake

Tonghai, Yunnan, ChinaAsia

At about one in the morning an earthquake of magnitude 7 or more struck Tonghai county, south of Kunming, flattening villages built of rammed earth along the fault. It killed between 10,000 and more than 15,000 people; the official figure of 15,621 was not published for thirty years. The disaster came at the height of the Cultural Revolution. China declined offers of foreign help, the national press said almost nothing, and relief emphasised political morale. Survivors recalled receiving copies of Mao’s writings and Mao badges in quantity along with far smaller amounts of grain, clothing and money. The scale became public only when local officials held a memorial in 2000.

Seen from elsewhere. The authorities of the day presented self-reliance as a principle: a socialist people rebuilt by its own efforts and did not take charity from hostile powers. Chinese seismologists note that Tonghai prompted the creation of a national earthquake bureau. How many died for want of outside aid cannot now be established.

1976

Cambodia becomes Democratic Kampuchea

Phnom Penh, CambodiaAsia

Nine months after taking Phnom Penh and emptying it of its people, the Khmer Rouge promulgated a constitution that renamed the country Democratic Kampuchea. It was a short document. It declared that all important means of production were collective property, that there was no unemployment, and that every citizen had the right to work. It promised freedom of belief and in the same article banned ‘reactionary religion’. It mentioned no money, markets, courts of appeal or private land, since all had been abolished. Prince Sihanouk, nominal head of state, resigned in April and was confined to his palace. Pol Pot became prime minister. In under four years between 1.5 and 2 million people died of execution, starvation and overwork.

Seen from elsewhere. Surviving leaders tried by a United Nations-backed tribunal denied knowledge or blamed Vietnam. Democratic Kampuchea kept Cambodia’s seat at the United Nations through the 1980s, latterly inside a coalition, with Chinese, American and South-East Asian support. Scholars debate how far ‘genocide’ in the legal sense covers the killing of ethnic Khmer, as distinct from Cham Muslims and Vietnamese.

Also on 5 January