Parallax

27 January, AD 98

Nerva dies and a general on the Rhine inherits Rome

An elderly emperor who had been bullied by his own guard died after sixteen months in power. His adopted heir, a soldier born in Spain, heard the news in Cologne and took more than a year to come to Rome.

Rome and Cologne

The emperor Nerva died in Rome in late January of the year 98, in a villa in the Gardens of Sallust. A late Roman summary of the emperors’ lives says that he lost his temper with a man named Regulus, shouted, broke into a sweat, and was seized by a chill and fever from which he did not recover. He was in his sixties and had ruled for sixteen months. His ashes were placed in the mausoleum of Augustus, the last emperor’s to be laid there.

He left no son, but he had settled the succession three months earlier, and under duress. In the autumn of 97 the Praetorian Guard, still loyal to the memory of the murdered Domitian, had besieged Nerva in the palace and demanded the men who had arranged the assassination. Nerva is said to have bared his throat to the soldiers and offered it instead. They ignored him, took the two men they wanted, and killed them. The emperor was then made to thank the guard in public.

Shortly afterwards Nerva climbed the Capitol and announced that he was adopting Marcus Ulpius Traianus, governor of Upper Germany, who commanded legions on the Rhine and was not a relative. According to the historian Cassius Dio he sent Trajan a ring and a line of Homer asking that his tears be avenged. Trajan was made co-ruler in all but name without leaving his province.

The news of Nerva’s death was carried north to Cologne. The later biography of Hadrian claims that the young Hadrian, Trajan’s ward, raced to be first with it, that his brother-in-law Servianus had his carriage sabotaged to stop him, and that he finished the journey on foot and still arrived ahead of the official messenger. Trajan, who was forty-four, was acclaimed by the troops, wrote politely to the Senate promising that he would put no senator to death, and stayed where he was.

He spent the rest of 98 and much of 99 inspecting the Rhine and Danube frontiers. One of his first acts was to summon Casperius Aelianus, the Praetorian prefect who had led the mutiny, together with his men, as though he had work for them. Dio says simply that he put them out of the way. When Trajan finally entered Rome he did so on foot, embracing senators at the gate, in a show of modesty that the Senate remembered for centuries.

How it came to this

Domitian, the last of the Flavian emperors, was stabbed to death in his palace on 18 September 96 by members of his own household. The Senate, which had feared and hated him, proclaimed Marcus Cocceius Nerva the same day. Nerva was an elderly jurist and former consul with no military record and no children, acceptable to everyone because he threatened no one. He recalled exiles, ended treason trials and spent carefully. But the armies and the guard had liked Domitian, who had raised their pay, and a ruler without soldiers behind him was at the mercy of the first general who chose to move.

Trajan was born in 53 at Italica, near modern Seville, into a family of Italian settlers long established in southern Spain. His father had risen under Vespasian to the consulship and the governorship of Syria. The son had spent most of his adult life with the legions. He was the first emperor to come from a province rather than from Italy. Why Nerva chose him rather than another commander is nowhere explained in the sources, which were written under Trajan and present the choice as the selection of the best man.

How each side saw it

The Senate

Senators left the fullest record, and it is admiring. Pliny the Younger’s Panegyric, delivered before Trajan in 100, praises an emperor who behaved as a fellow citizen and contrasts him at every turn with Domitian. Tacitus wrote that Nerva had joined two things formerly incompatible, the rule of one man and liberty, and that Trajan was daily increasing the happiness of the age. The Senate voted him the title Optimus, the best, and later generations greeted new emperors with the wish that they be luckier than Augustus and better than Trajan. These are the judgments of a class relieved to be safe.

The Dacians

Trajan’s reputation was built on conquest. In two wars, 101-102 and 105-106, he destroyed the Dacian kingdom north of the Danube, whose king Decebalus killed himself rather than be captured. The Dacians left no account. Trajan’s own commentary is lost except for one sentence, and the history by his doctor Crito has perished, so the war is known mainly from Dio’s abridged text and the carved spiral of Trajan’s Column, which shows villages burned and captives led away. Ancient claims about the gold taken and the numbers enslaved cannot be checked. Romanian tradition counts both conquerors and conquered as ancestors.

Jewish communities of the eastern Mediterranean

In 115-117, while Trajan was campaigning against Parthia, Jewish populations rose in Cyrenaica, Egypt, Cyprus and Mesopotamia. The Roman and Christian writers who describe the revolt, Dio and Eusebius, dwell on atrocities by the rebels; papyri from Egypt record ruined estates and confiscated Jewish property. The suppression, directed in the east by the general Lusius Quietus, all but ended the ancient Jewish communities of Egypt, Cyrene and Cyprus. Rabbinic literature remembers the period briefly and grimly as the war of Quietus. No Jewish narrative of the events survives.

Christians

Around 112 Pliny, then governing Bithynia, asked Trajan how to deal with people denounced as Christians. The reply, preserved in Pliny’s letters, says they are not to be hunted out and anonymous accusations are to be ignored, but that those who are accused and refuse to sacrifice must be punished. The Christian writer Tertullian, a century later, mocked the ruling as incoherent: if they are guilty, why not seek them, and if innocent, why punish them? Church tradition places the martyrdom of Ignatius of Antioch in this reign. A medieval legend, used by Dante, nevertheless put Trajan in heaven.

What is disputed

The day is not secure. Most reference works give 27 January for Nerva’s death, but a third-century military calendar found at Dura-Europos marks Trajan’s accession on 28 January, and some scholars place the death on that day. Nerva’s age is given differently in different sources. The larger argument is over the adoption. Ronald Syme and, more recently, John Grainger have read it as a bloodless coup, forced on a helpless emperor by a group of generals and senators who backed Trajan, possibly against a rival candidate in Syria. Others accept that Nerva chose freely. The stories of Hadrian’s race and of the Homeric message come from late or abridged texts.

What followed

Trajan ruled for nineteen years and took the empire to its greatest extent, adding Dacia, Arabia and, briefly, Armenia and Mesopotamia. He died in Cilicia in August 117, and his successor Hadrian gave up the eastern conquests almost at once. Adoption of an adult heir, begun as Nerva’s emergency measure, became the method of succession for most of the second century, the period Edward Gibbon judged the happiest in human history. That verdict, drawn from senatorial writers, has been questioned by historians who ask how it looked from the provinces Trajan conquered.

Read further

  • Julian Bennett, Trajan: Optimus Princeps (1997)
  • John D. Grainger, Nerva and the Roman Succession Crisis of AD 96-99 (2003)
  • Ronald Syme, Tacitus (1958)
  • Pliny the Younger, Letters, Book 10, and Panegyricus
  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, Book 68

Same day, other years

1302

Florence condemns Dante

Florence, ItalyEurope

Dante Alighieri had served in 1300 as one of the priors who governed Florence, and belonged to the White faction of the city’s ruling Guelph party. In November 1301 the rival Blacks took the city with the backing of Pope Boniface VIII and a French prince, Charles of Valois, while Dante was away on an embassy. On 27 January 1302 the new chief magistrate, Cante de’ Gabrielli, sentenced him in his absence for corruption in office: a fine of five thousand florins, two years of exile and a permanent ban from public life. When he did not appear, a second sentence in March ordered him burned alive if caught. He never saw Florence again and wrote the Divine Comedy in exile.

Seen from elsewhere. The charges were the standard ones used against a defeated faction, and no evidence for them survives. Florence offered an amnesty in 1315 on terms Dante thought humiliating and refused. The city has since asked Ravenna, where he died in 1321, for his bones, without success, and its council voted in 2008 to revoke the sentence.

1945

Soviet soldiers reach Auschwitz

Oswiecim, occupied PolandEurope

Troops of the Soviet 60th Army, advancing through southern Poland, entered the Auschwitz camp complex in the afternoon and found about seven thousand prisoners alive, most of them too ill to have been marched away. Ten days earlier the SS had driven some 56,000 others westward on foot in the snow, and had blown up the gas chambers and crematoria at Birkenau. The soldiers also found storerooms holding hundreds of thousands of garments and several tonnes of human hair. About 1.1 million people were murdered at Auschwitz, roughly a million of them Jews, along with tens of thousands of Poles, about 21,000 Roma and some 15,000 Soviet prisoners of war.

Seen from elsewhere. Primo Levi, who was among the sick left behind, wrote that the first four horsemen looked on in embarrassed silence and that the prisoners felt shame, not joy. Soviet reports spoke of four million victims and of citizens of many nations, without saying that most were Jews; that figure stood on the memorial until 1990.

1973

The Paris accords end America’s war in Vietnam

Paris, FranceAsia

After nearly five years of talks, the United States, North Vietnam, South Vietnam and the southern communists’ Provisional Revolutionary Government signed an agreement providing for a ceasefire, the withdrawal of remaining American forces within sixty days and the return of prisoners of war. It had been negotiated largely in secret between Henry Kissinger and Le Duc Tho. North Vietnamese troops already in the South, well over a hundred thousand of them, were allowed to stay. The ceasefire was broken by both Vietnamese sides almost immediately. Kissinger and Tho were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize; Tho declined it, saying there was no peace. Saigon fell on 30 April 1975.

Seen from elsewhere. South Vietnam’s president Nguyen Van Thieu signed under heavy pressure, with private assurances from Nixon of American force if the North attacked, which Congress later would not honour. He and many South Vietnamese regarded it as abandonment. Historians dispute whether Nixon and Kissinger sought only a ‘decent interval’ before an expected collapse, which Kissinger denied.

1996

The army overthrows Niger’s first elected president

Niamey, NigerAfrica

Mahamane Ousmane had won Niger’s first free presidential election in 1993, after a national conference ended decades of military and one-party rule. Parliamentary elections in 1995 forced him to share power with a prime minister from the opposition, Hama Amadou, and the two spent a year blocking each other while civil servants went unpaid. On 27 January 1996 the army chief of staff, Colonel Ibrahim Bare Mainassara, seized power, put both men under house arrest and suspended the constitution. He promised a quick return to civilian rule, then stood for president himself that July, replaced the electoral commission while votes were being counted and was declared the winner.

Seen from elsewhere. Bare said he had rescued the state from paralysis, and some Nigeriens weary of strikes agreed. The deposed politicians and western donors, who suspended aid, called it the theft of a young democracy. In April 1999 he was shot dead at Niamey airport by his own guard, in what the next junta at first called an unfortunate accident.

Also on 27 January