Parallax

14 January, 1208

A papal legate is murdered on the bank of the Rhone

One lance thrust at a river crossing gave Pope Innocent III the martyr he needed to launch a crusade against Christians in the south of France. Who sent the killer has never been established.

Near Saint-Gilles, county of Toulouse

Peter of Castelnau was a Cistercian monk from the abbey of Fontfroide who had spent five years as the pope’s legate in the lands of the count of Toulouse, and had made himself hated there. His task was to get the southern lords to act against heresy, and they would not. In 1207 he excommunicated the greatest of them, Count Raymond VI, for sheltering heretics, employing mercenary bands and breaking the peace of the church, and laid his lands under interdict.

In January 1208 Raymond invited the legate to his town of Saint-Gilles, near the mouth of the Rhone, promising to make amends. The meeting went badly. According to the account Pope Innocent III later circulated, the count alternated between submission and fury and finally, when the legates said they were leaving, threatened in front of witnesses that wherever they went by land or water he would be watching. The abbot of Saint-Gilles and the townsmen escorted the churchmen out of town for safety. They spent the night near the river.

At dawn on 14 January, after Mass, the party was preparing to cross the Rhone when a horseman rode up behind Peter and drove a lance into his back. The pope’s letter says the dying man repeated, ‘May God forgive you, as I forgive you’, and gave instructions to his companions before he died. The killer rode off towards Beaucaire. The church’s writers said he was one of the count’s squires, hoping to please his master.

The news took some weeks to reach Rome. A poem written a few years later says Innocent sat with his chin in his hand and called on St James of Compostela and St Peter. On 10 March he issued a letter to the bishops and nobles of France. Peter was a martyr; Raymond was presumed guilty of his death and was excommunicated again; his vassals were released from their oaths; and any Catholic who took up arms against the heretics of the south could seize their lands and would earn the same remission of sins as a crusader to Jerusalem.

Raymond saw what was coming and gave in. In June 1209 he was led, stripped to the waist, to the abbey church of Saint-Gilles and beaten with rods by a papal legate before being absolved, and then, because of the crowd, had to leave through the crypt, past the new tomb of Peter of Castelnau. He took the cross himself. It did not stop the army already assembling at Lyon. A month later it stormed Beziers, the first town in its path, and killed the population.

How it came to this

In the twelfth century a religious movement had taken root in the towns and castles between the Rhone and the Pyrenees. Its ascetic leaders, known to their followers simply as good men and good women, taught that the visible world was the work of an evil power, rejected the sacraments and the authority of the Roman clergy, and administered a rite of their own, the consolamentum. Catholic writers called them Cathars or, after the town of Albi, Albigensians. They were protected or tolerated by much of the southern nobility, many of whom had sisters, mothers and aunts among the good women.

The region owed loose allegiance to the French king in the north and the king of Aragon in the south, and its counts could not have suppressed the dissenters even if they had wished to. Preaching missions, including one by the Spaniard Dominic Guzman, made few converts. Innocent III, the most forceful pope of the Middle Ages, had concluded before 1208 that only force would serve, and had already asked King Philip Augustus to intervene. The king, busy with his war against John of England, had declined.

How each side saw it

The papacy and the Cistercians

The crusade’s own chronicler, the monk Peter of les Vaux-de-Cernay, was a young eyewitness whose uncle was one of its bishops. For him the south was infected with a plague, its lords were accomplices, and the crusaders were soldiers of Christ doing a work of mercy on a diseased limb. He reports the burnings of heretics as occasions of great joy. Innocent’s letters show more hesitation: he worried that greed for land was driving his crusaders, admitted in 1212 that Raymond had never been convicted of heresy or of the murder, and tried at times to rein the war in. He did not stop it.

The count of Toulouse and the southern nobility

Raymond VI always denied ordering the killing and repeatedly asked to clear himself by a formal oath, which the legates refused to allow. The southern view is preserved in the Song of the Cathar Wars, an epic in Occitan, especially in the part written by an anonymous poet from Toulouse. He is a Catholic, but for him the crusade is an invasion by French barons and greedy clergy who destroy paratge, the southern ideal of honour and rightful inheritance. He rejoices when Simon de Montfort, the crusade’s leader, is killed outside Toulouse in 1218 by a stone from a catapult worked, he says, by the women of the town.

The good men and good women

The people the crusade was aimed at left almost nothing in their own words: a few ritual texts and one theological treatise survive. Otherwise they are known through their enemies, above all the registers of the inquisition that followed, in which thousands of villagers were questioned about whom they had seen, fed or bowed to decades earlier. Those records show a faith carried in households, with women prominent among its ministers, and believers who seem to have thought of themselves as good Christians. At Minerve in 1210 about 140 chose the fire over recanting; at Montsegur in 1244 more than 200.

What is disputed

Whether Raymond ordered the murder is unknown; a zealous retainer acting alone is as likely, and the killer was never tried. Some sources give 15 January. The words attributed to the abbot Arnaud Amaury at Beziers, ‘Kill them all, God will know his own’, come only from a German monk writing a decade later and are probably legend, though the abbot’s own report boasts that nearly 20,000 were killed without regard to rank, sex or age, a figure larger than the town’s likely population. Historians also disagree about the heresy itself. Malcolm Barber and Peter Biller describe an organised dualist church; Mark Pegg and R. I. Moore argue that ‘Catharism’ was largely constructed by its persecutors.

What followed

The war lasted twenty years. It ended in 1229 with a treaty that married the heiress of Toulouse to a brother of the French king, and by 1271 the south had passed to the crown: the crusade did as much to create France as to defeat heresy. To finish the work the papacy set up, in the 1230s, tribunals of inquisition staffed by Dominican friars, whose methods of systematic interrogation and record-keeping were used for centuries. The last known good man in Languedoc was burned in 1321. Occitan memory of the conquest fed a regional movement in the twentieth century, and ‘Cathar country’ is now a tourist brand.

Read further

  • Peter of les Vaux-de-Cernay, The History of the Albigensian Crusade, translated by W. A. and M. D. Sibly (1998)
  • William of Tudela and an anonymous successor, The Song of the Cathar Wars, translated by Janet Shirley (1996)
  • Malcolm Barber, The Cathars: Dualist Heretics in Languedoc in the High Middle Ages (2000)
  • Mark Gregory Pegg, A Most Holy War: The Albigensian Crusade and the Battle for Christendom (2008)
  • Jonathan Sumption, The Albigensian Crusade (1978)

Same day, other years

1761

The Marathas are destroyed at Panipat

Panipat, north of Delhi, IndiaAsia

By 1760 the Maratha confederacy had pushed its power from western India to the Punjab and seemed about to inherit the Mughal empire. The Afghan king Ahmad Shah Durrani came down through the passes to stop it, joined by the Rohilla Afghans and the nawab of Awadh. For two months the armies faced each other at Panipat, the Marathas under Sadashivrao Bhau cut off from supplies and starving. On 14 January 1761 they came out to fight. Their French-trained artillery did well at first, but in the afternoon the Peshwa’s young son Vishwasrao was shot dead, Bhau plunged into the fighting and vanished, and the army broke. Tens of thousands were killed in the battle and in a massacre of prisoners the next day.

Seen from elsewhere. In Marathi the word Panipat still means a catastrophe, and it is said that few families in Maharashtra did not lose someone. Afghans remember the victory of their kingdom’s founder. He could not hold India and went home within months; the power that gained most from the destruction of both was the British East India Company.

1814

Denmark signs Norway away to Sweden

Kiel, Duchy of HolsteinEurope

Denmark had stayed on Napoleon’s side too long. With Swedish and Russian troops in Holstein, Frederick VI signed a treaty at Kiel on 14 January 1814 ceding the kingdom of Norway, joined to Denmark for more than four hundred years, to the king of Sweden. Norway’s old dependencies of Iceland, Greenland and the Faroes stayed with Denmark. The Norwegians had not been consulted and refused to be transferred. An assembly at Eidsvoll wrote a liberal constitution, signed on 17 May, and elected the Danish prince Christian Frederick as king. After a short summer war Sweden accepted the constitution in exchange for a union of crowns, which lasted until Norway left it peacefully in 1905.

Seen from elsewhere. Swedes saw fair compensation for Finland, lost to Russia in 1809, and the allied powers had promised Norway to the Swedish crown prince Bernadotte as the price of joining them against Napoleon. Norwegians argued that a king could renounce his own throne but could not hand a people to another. 17 May remains their national day.

1907

Earthquake and fire destroy Kingston

Kingston, JamaicaThe Americas

At about half past three on the afternoon of 14 January 1907 an earthquake lasting less than a minute brought down most of the brick buildings in Kingston, the capital of British Jamaica. Fires broke out in the commercial district and burned for days, since the water mains were broken. Between 800 and 1,000 people died, most of them poor Black Jamaicans in the crowded lower town. American warships arrived from Cuba within three days and landed sailors to clear rubble and guard property. The governor, Sir Alexander Swettenham, took offence and asked the American admiral, in a sarcastic letter, to withdraw his men. London apologised to Washington, and Swettenham resigned.

Seen from elsewhere. Insurers refused to pay for the burned buildings on the ground that their policies excluded fire caused by earthquake; merchants insisted the fires had started separately, and the dispute went through the courts for years. Swettenham’s defenders held that armed foreign sailors had landed in a British colony without his permission.

2011

Ben Ali flees Tunisia

Tunis, TunisiaAfrica

On 17 December 2010 Mohamed Bouazizi, a street vendor in the town of Sidi Bouzid whose cart had been confiscated, set himself on fire outside the governor’s office. Protests against unemployment, police brutality and the corruption of the ruling family spread from the interior to the capital despite the shooting of demonstrators. On 14 January 2011, with a vast crowd outside the interior ministry in Tunis and the army unwilling to fire, President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali boarded a plane with his family after 23 years in power. France would not take him, and he landed in Saudi Arabia. Within weeks there were uprisings in Egypt, Libya, Yemen, Bahrain and Syria.

Seen from elsewhere. Ben Ali later said through his lawyer that he had been tricked into leaving by his security chief and had meant to return. He died in exile in 2019. Tunisia built the only democracy to come out of the Arab uprisings, but many Tunisians who found themselves no better off supported President Kais Saied when he suspended parliament in 2021.

Also on 14 January