Parallax

3 January, 1521

Rome cuts off Martin Luther

Pope Leo X declared a Saxon friar and everyone who sheltered him excommunicate. The document was so awkwardly drafted that the pope’s own envoy in Germany hid it in his luggage.

Rome, Papal States

The bull that Leo X sealed in Rome on 3 January 1521 opens with the words Decet Romanum Pontificem, ‘it befits the Roman pontiff’, and runs to a few pages. It states that Martin Luther, an Augustinian friar and professor at Wittenberg, had been given sixty days to withdraw his errors, that he had not done so, and that he was therefore a declared heretic. So were his followers and protectors. Any place that harboured them fell under interdict, which meant the suspension of church services and sacraments.

It was the second half of a process. The previous June another bull, Exsurge Domine, had condemned 41 statements drawn from Luther’s writings and set the deadline. Luther’s old opponent Johann Eck carried it into Germany, where in several towns students tore it down or threw it in the river. On 10 December 1520, at the Elster Gate of Wittenberg, in front of a crowd of students and colleagues, Luther put a copy on a bonfire along with volumes of canon law. He then published a pamphlet explaining why.

After that Rome had little choice. But the new bull arrived in Germany at a bad moment and in a bad form. The young emperor Charles V was holding his first imperial diet at Worms. The papal envoy there, Girolamo Aleandro, wanted the princes to outlaw Luther on the pope’s word alone. When he read the text he found that it named not only Luther but the popular knight and writer Ulrich von Hutten and others, which was likely to enrage half the German nobility. He kept it back and wrote to Rome asking for a version that named Luther only.

On Ash Wednesday Aleandro addressed the diet for three hours. The princes were not persuaded to act without a hearing. Luther’s own ruler, the Elector Frederick of Saxony, insisted that a German should not be condemned unheard, and the estates had their own long list of complaints against Roman taxes and appointments. Charles issued a safe conduct.

Luther reached Worms on 16 April in a cart, escorted by an imperial herald and cheered along the road. Before the emperor he was shown a pile of his books and asked whether he would recant them. He asked for a day, and on 18 April he answered that unless he was convinced by Scripture and plain reason he could not and would not retract anything, since his conscience was captive to the word of God.

He left under safe conduct, and on the road home Frederick’s men staged an abduction and hid him in the Wartburg castle. In May the emperor placed him under the ban of the empire. Leo X died that December.

How it came to this

The quarrel had started over money and forgiveness. In 1517 a papal indulgence was being preached in German lands near Saxony by the Dominican Johann Tetzel. Half the proceeds went to rebuilding St Peter’s in Rome and half, by a private arrangement, to pay off the debts that Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz had run up buying his offices. Luther, who had come to believe that sinners are made right with God by faith and not by any transaction, sent Albrecht 95 theses for debate on 31 October. Printers spread them across Germany within weeks.

Rome moved slowly, partly because it needed Frederick of Saxony’s vote in the coming imperial election. A hearing before Cardinal Cajetan at Augsburg in 1518 ended in deadlock. At Leipzig in 1519 Eck manoeuvred Luther into saying that the council which burned Jan Hus had condemned true Christian statements, and that popes and councils could err. In 1520 Luther published three tracts that went far beyond indulgences, attacking the papacy’s authority over rulers, reducing the seven sacraments to two or three and calling the pope Antichrist. By then the dispute was no longer about abuses.

How each side saw it

The papal court

As Rome saw it, Luther had been treated with patience. Three years had passed since the theses. He had been heard by a cardinal, offered a hearing in Rome with his expenses paid, and given a further sixty days after formal condemnation. Exsurge Domine set out his statements and judged them heretical, scandalous or offensive to pious ears, reviving positions the Church had already condemned in Hus and Wyclif. He had answered by burning the pope’s letter and the Church’s law. Eck and Aleandro argued that a pastor who lets one man teach that popes and councils err has abandoned his duty to the unity of all Christians.

Luther

Luther’s replies survive in print in great quantity. He held that he had asked from the beginning to be shown from Scripture where he was wrong and had instead been ordered to say the single word ‘revoco’. Exsurge Domine, he pointed out, condemned 41 sentences without saying which were heretical and which merely offensive, and without refuting any. By late 1520 he had concluded that an institution which placed itself above Scripture was the Antichrist foretold in the New Testament, so that its excommunication carried no weight. He wrote to his friend Spalatin that he felt freer once the bull had come.

The Elector of Saxony and the German estates

Frederick the Wise was a conventional Catholic prince with one of the largest relic collections in Europe, and he almost certainly never spoke to Luther face to face. He protected him as a matter of law and of the standing of his university. When he asked Erasmus at Cologne in late 1520 what Luther had done wrong, Erasmus is recorded by Spalatin as answering that he had attacked the pope’s crown and the monks’ bellies. The estates at Worms presented more than a hundred grievances against Roman finance. Many who disliked Luther’s theology still refused to see him condemned on a foreign court’s say-so.

The Catholic Church since

The excommunication has never been formally lifted, and the Vatican’s position, when Lutheran groups have asked, is that such a penalty ends with the death of the person and cannot be withdrawn afterwards. Catholic scholarship changed markedly in the twentieth century. Joseph Lortz argued that the late medieval Church bore much of the blame and that Luther had rejected a Catholicism that was not fully Catholic. In 1999 the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation signed a Joint Declaration stating that their teachings on justification no longer fall under each other’s sixteenth-century condemnations. Pope Francis joined the Lutheran commemoration of the Reformation at Lund in 2016.

What is disputed

Several fixed points of the story are less fixed than they look. The Catholic historian Erwin Iserloh argued in 1961 that Luther never nailed his theses to the church door but only posted them by letter, and the question remains open. The words ‘Here I stand, I can do no other’ are missing from the records made at Worms and first appear in a version printed at Wittenberg. On the excommunication itself, canon lawyers note that Luther strictly incurred it when the sixty days expired in late 1520, and that the bull of 3 January declared a state of affairs that already existed. Whether any compromise was still possible by then divides historians.

What followed

The emperor’s ban could not be enforced in Saxony, and within a decade a number of German princes and cities had reorganised their churches on Luther’s lines. The division became permanent and was fought over, in Germany until 1555 and across Europe until 1648. Luther’s German Bible shaped the written language. His legacy also includes his tract of 1525 urging princes to kill rebellious peasants and his writings of 1543 calling for synagogues to be burned, which Lutheran churches have formally repudiated. A document that its own envoy was reluctant to publish marks the point at which western Christianity stopped being one church.

Read further

  • Martin Brecht, Martin Luther: His Road to Reformation, 1483-1521 (1985)
  • Lyndal Roper, Martin Luther: Renegade and Prophet (2016)
  • Heiko A. Oberman, Luther: Man between God and the Devil (1989)
  • Scott H. Hendrix, Martin Luther: Visionary Reformer (2015)
  • Erwin Iserloh, The Theses Were Not Posted: Luther between Reform and Reformation (1968)

Same day, other years

1833

Britain takes control of the Falklands

Port Louis, Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas)The Americas

Captain John Onslow of HMS Clio had arrived at Port Louis the day before with orders to assert British sovereignty. He told Jose Maria Pinedo, commanding the small garrison placed there by the government in Buenos Aires, that the British flag would be hoisted in the morning and asked him to lower his own and leave. Pinedo, outgunned and with British-born sailors among his crew, protested and sailed two days later without firing. Britain based its claim on a settlement of 1765 that it had withdrawn in 1774, leaving a plaque. Buenos Aires based its claim on inheritance from Spain and on the colony it had licensed under Louis Vernet in the 1820s.

Seen from elsewhere. Argentina holds that an established population and administration were expelled by force in peacetime and has protested ever since. Britain replies that only the garrison was asked to go, that the civilian settlers were encouraged to stay, and that the islanders’ own wishes decide the matter. The two countries fought over the islands in 1982.

1868

The Meiji Restoration is proclaimed

Kyoto, JapanAsia

Before dawn, troops from the domains of Satsuma, Choshu and their allies took over the gates of the imperial palace in Kyoto. Inside, court nobles who were in on the plan had the 15-year-old emperor Mutsuhito issue a decree restoring direct imperial rule and abolishing the office of shogun, which the Tokugawa family had held for more than 260 years. The last shogun, Tokugawa Yoshinobu, had already offered his resignation in November, expecting to lead whatever council replaced him. He was now ordered to give up his lands as well. Fighting broke out south of Kyoto within the month, and the new government’s forces had won the civil war by mid-1869.

Seen from elsewhere. Tokugawa loyalists, above all the northern domain of Aizu, saw a palace coup by two rival domains using a boy as cover, and Aizu’s defeat is still remembered there with bitterness. Historians debate whether to call it a restoration or a revolution. For the Ainu in the north and the Ryukyu kingdom in the south it brought annexation.

1925

Mussolini claims responsibility

Rome, ItalyEurope

Seven months earlier the Socialist deputy Giacomo Matteotti had been abducted and stabbed to death by Fascist thugs days after denouncing electoral violence in parliament. The scandal nearly brought down Benito Mussolini’s coalition government. Opposition deputies withdrew from the chamber in protest and waited for the king to dismiss him. On 3 January 1925 Mussolini went to the Chamber of Deputies and, instead of defending himself, declared that he alone assumed the political, moral and historical responsibility for all that had happened, and that if Fascism was a criminal association he was its chief. Within days opposition newspapers were seized and meetings banned. Over the next two years Italy became a one-party dictatorship.

Seen from elsewhere. The opposition’s walkout, known as the Aventine secession, rested on the belief that King Victor Emmanuel III would act. He did not. Whether Mussolini personally ordered the murder is disputed: Renzo De Felice doubted it, while Mauro Canali has argued from the archives that he did, to bury evidence of corruption.

2020

The killing of Qasem Soleimani

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Shortly after midnight an American drone fired on two vehicles leaving Baghdad International Airport. The strike killed Major General Qasem Soleimani, commander of the Quds Force of Iran’s Revolutionary Guards and the architect of Iranian influence from Lebanon to Yemen, together with the Iraqi militia leader Abu Mahdi al-Muhandis and eight others. President Trump said Soleimani had been planning attacks on Americans. Five days later Iran fired ballistic missiles at bases in Iraq housing United States troops, injuring more than a hundred, and hours after that its air defences shot down a Ukrainian airliner leaving Tehran, killing all 176 people on board. Both governments then stepped back from open war.

Seen from elsewhere. Iran called it state terrorism and huge crowds attended the funeral. A United Nations special rapporteur, Agnes Callamard, judged the strike unlawful, and Iraq’s parliament voted to expel foreign troops. Many Syrians, and Iraqi protesters whom Iranian-backed militias had been shooting in the streets, celebrated the death of a man they held responsible.

Also on 3 January