The bull that Leo X sealed in Rome on 3 January 1521 opens with the words Decet Romanum Pontificem, ‘it befits the Roman pontiff’, and runs to a few pages. It states that Martin Luther, an Augustinian friar and professor at Wittenberg, had been given sixty days to withdraw his errors, that he had not done so, and that he was therefore a declared heretic. So were his followers and protectors. Any place that harboured them fell under interdict, which meant the suspension of church services and sacraments.
It was the second half of a process. The previous June another bull, Exsurge Domine, had condemned 41 statements drawn from Luther’s writings and set the deadline. Luther’s old opponent Johann Eck carried it into Germany, where in several towns students tore it down or threw it in the river. On 10 December 1520, at the Elster Gate of Wittenberg, in front of a crowd of students and colleagues, Luther put a copy on a bonfire along with volumes of canon law. He then published a pamphlet explaining why.
After that Rome had little choice. But the new bull arrived in Germany at a bad moment and in a bad form. The young emperor Charles V was holding his first imperial diet at Worms. The papal envoy there, Girolamo Aleandro, wanted the princes to outlaw Luther on the pope’s word alone. When he read the text he found that it named not only Luther but the popular knight and writer Ulrich von Hutten and others, which was likely to enrage half the German nobility. He kept it back and wrote to Rome asking for a version that named Luther only.
On Ash Wednesday Aleandro addressed the diet for three hours. The princes were not persuaded to act without a hearing. Luther’s own ruler, the Elector Frederick of Saxony, insisted that a German should not be condemned unheard, and the estates had their own long list of complaints against Roman taxes and appointments. Charles issued a safe conduct.
Luther reached Worms on 16 April in a cart, escorted by an imperial herald and cheered along the road. Before the emperor he was shown a pile of his books and asked whether he would recant them. He asked for a day, and on 18 April he answered that unless he was convinced by Scripture and plain reason he could not and would not retract anything, since his conscience was captive to the word of God.
He left under safe conduct, and on the road home Frederick’s men staged an abduction and hid him in the Wartburg castle. In May the emperor placed him under the ban of the empire. Leo X died that December.
How it came to this
The quarrel had started over money and forgiveness. In 1517 a papal indulgence was being preached in German lands near Saxony by the Dominican Johann Tetzel. Half the proceeds went to rebuilding St Peter’s in Rome and half, by a private arrangement, to pay off the debts that Archbishop Albrecht of Mainz had run up buying his offices. Luther, who had come to believe that sinners are made right with God by faith and not by any transaction, sent Albrecht 95 theses for debate on 31 October. Printers spread them across Germany within weeks.
Rome moved slowly, partly because it needed Frederick of Saxony’s vote in the coming imperial election. A hearing before Cardinal Cajetan at Augsburg in 1518 ended in deadlock. At Leipzig in 1519 Eck manoeuvred Luther into saying that the council which burned Jan Hus had condemned true Christian statements, and that popes and councils could err. In 1520 Luther published three tracts that went far beyond indulgences, attacking the papacy’s authority over rulers, reducing the seven sacraments to two or three and calling the pope Antichrist. By then the dispute was no longer about abuses.