Parallax

2 January, 1492

Granada changes hands

The last Muslim-ruled city in western Europe was surrendered under a treaty that promised its people their faith, their law and their property. The promise lasted less than ten years.

Granada, Spain

In the night of 1 to 2 January 1492 a Castilian officer, Gutierre de Cardenas, was led with a body of troops up a back road into the Alhambra, the palace-fortress above Granada. The emir, Abu Abdallah Muhammad XII, whom the Christians called Boabdil, had asked for it to be done this way. The surrender had been agreed weeks earlier and was not due for some time yet, but the city was crowded with refugees and hungry, there had been riots against the treaty, and he feared that a public handover would end in bloodshed.

By daylight a silver cross and the banners of Castile and of St James had been raised on one of the towers, where the besieging army in the plain could see them. A herald shouted the names of Ferdinand and Isabella. Among those watching, by his own later account, was a Genoese petitioner named Christopher Columbus, still waiting for an answer about his voyage.

Boabdil rode out with a small escort and met Ferdinand near the river Genil. He offered to dismount and kiss the king’s hand and was told he need not. He handed over the keys. The chroniclers who describe the scene give him different speeches, and none can be trusted word for word. His young son, held by the Castilians as a hostage, was returned to him. The Count of Tendilla took command of the Alhambra and the mild Hernando de Talavera was named the city’s first archbishop. The monarchs made their own formal entry on 6 January.

The siege that ended that morning had lasted since April 1491 and had seen little fighting. Ferdinand and Isabella had camped in the plain with a large army, burned the crops and waited. When their tented camp caught fire in the summer they rebuilt it in stone as a town, Santa Fe, to make plain that they would not leave. Secret negotiations followed between the royal secretary Hernando de Zafra and Boabdil’s vizier Abu’l-Qasim al-Mulih, and terms were signed on 25 November.

On paper the terms were generous. The Muslims of Granada were to keep their mosques, their judges and their own law, their property, their dress and their language. No one was to be forced to convert, and anyone who wished to leave for North Africa would be carried there free. Boabdil received a small lordship in the Alpujarra mountains to the south.

He did not stay. In 1493 he sold his rights and crossed to Morocco with his household. The usual account has him dying in Fez decades later.

How it came to this

Muslim armies had crossed from North Africa in 711 and within a few years ruled most of the Iberian peninsula. Over the following centuries the Christian kingdoms of the north expanded southwards, in a process that was neither continuous nor always religious in motive: Christian and Muslim rulers allied with and against each other freely. By the middle of the thirteenth century Cordoba and Seville had fallen to Castile, and what remained was the Nasrid emirate of Granada, a mountain kingdom with the ports of Malaga and Almeria, which survived for 250 years partly by paying tribute to Castile.

The marriage of Isabella of Castile and Ferdinand of Aragon joined the two largest Christian realms, and from 1482 they made war on Granada year after year, with papal crusade funding and new artillery. The Nasrid family helped them by fighting each other. Boabdil rebelled against his father, was captured by the Castilians in 1483 and was released as their vassal to prolong the civil war. Malaga fell in 1487 and most of its people were enslaved. By 1491 only the capital was left.

How each side saw it

The Castilian court and its chroniclers

For Hernando del Pulgar, Andres Bernaldez and other writers close to the monarchs, the day completed a recovery of land lost by the Visigothic kings 780 years before, a just war won by God’s favour. Rome agreed: bells were rung and bullfights held there by the Spanish cardinal Rodrigo Borgia, and the pope later granted Ferdinand and Isabella the title of Catholic Monarchs. In this tradition, which shaped Spanish national history into the twentieth century, 2 January was a deliverance and the founding moment of a united Spain. The city of Granada still marks it each year with a civic ceremony, the Toma, which now draws protests as well as crowds.

The Muslims of Granada

An anonymous Arabic account written a generation later, the Nubdhat al-asr, tells the war from inside the city: hunger, betrayal by its own princes, and a surrender that the notables accepted because the alternative was the fate of Malaga. Later Arabic writers, above all the historian al-Maqqari in the seventeenth century, made the loss of al-Andalus a lasting theme of mourning. Boabdil is treated harshly in much of this tradition as the man who gave the kingdom away. After the forced conversions, Granadan Muslims sent a long poem to the Ottoman sultan Bayezid II listing the treaty promises one by one and how each had been broken.

The Jews of Spain

Less than three months after entering Granada, and in the Alhambra itself, Ferdinand and Isabella signed the decree of 31 March 1492 ordering every Jew in their kingdoms to accept baptism or leave by the end of July. Isaac Abravanel, a financier who had helped pay for the Granada war, recorded in his biblical commentaries that he pleaded with the king three times and offered money. For Jewish memory the fall of Granada and the expulsion belong together. Estimates of those who left range widely, from about 40,000 to well over 100,000, and many of the exiles settled in North Africa and the Ottoman empire.

Modern historians

The word Reconquista, with its suggestion of one continuous Christian project from 711 to 1492, is a nineteenth-century coinage, and many historians now use it with caution or not at all. They disagree, too, about what was lost. Americo Castro and those who followed him described medieval Spain as a convivencia, a creative coexistence of three faiths. Critics from Claudio Sanchez-Albornoz to more recent writers reply that the coexistence was unequal and frequently violent under both Christian and Muslim rule. The historian L. P. Harvey notes that for Granada’s Muslims themselves the question was practical: whether to stay under Christian rule or emigrate.

What is disputed

The best known detail is the least reliable. The story that Boabdil looked back from a mountain pass and wept, and that his mother Aixa told him he wept like a woman for what he could not defend like a man, first appears decades later in a text by the Spanish bishop Antonio de Guevara and is generally regarded as invention. The pass called the Moor’s Sigh was named after the tale. The date and place of Boabdil’s death are also uncertain: al-Maqqari puts it in Fez in the 1530s, another tradition much earlier in Tlemcen. And the secret entry on the night before means the public ceremony of 2 January was staged.

What followed

The treaty held while Talavera was in charge. In 1499 Cardinal Cisneros arrived, began mass baptisms and burned Arabic books in a public square. A revolt in the Alpujarras was crushed, and by 1502 all Muslims in Castile had to convert or leave. Their descendants, the Moriscos, rebelled again in 1568 and were expelled from Spain altogether between 1609 and 1614, about 300,000 people. Meanwhile, in April 1492, the monarchs who had just taken Granada agreed in the camp at Santa Fe to back Columbus. The year’s three decisions, conquest, expulsion and voyage, were taken within a few miles of each other.

Read further

  • L. P. Harvey, Islamic Spain, 1250 to 1500 (1990)
  • Elizabeth Drayson, The Moor’s Last Stand: How Seven Centuries of Muslim Rule in Spain Came to an End (2017)
  • Joseph F. O’Callaghan, The Last Crusade in the West: Castile and the Conquest of Granada (2014)
  • Miguel Angel Ladero Quesada, Castilla y la conquista del reino de Granada (1967)
  • L. P. Harvey, Muslims in Spain, 1500 to 1614 (2005)

Same day, other years

1757

Clive retakes Calcutta

Calcutta (Kolkata), Bengal, IndiaAsia

Six months after the Nawab of Bengal, Siraj ud-Daulah, had captured the East India Company’s settlement at Calcutta, a force from Madras under Robert Clive and Admiral Charles Watson sailed up the Hooghly and took it back with little resistance. The Company then went on the offensive. It forced a treaty on the Nawab in February, seized the French post at Chandernagore, and entered a conspiracy with Bengali bankers and the Nawab’s own commander Mir Jafar. At Plassey in June, Siraj was defeated largely by the defection of his army, and was killed soon after. Within a decade a trading company was collecting the revenues of Bengal.

Seen from elsewhere. Siraj’s grievances were real: the Company had fortified Calcutta without leave, abused its duty-free trade passes and sheltered a fugitive from his court. British opinion was inflamed by John Holwell’s account of the Black Hole, in which he said 123 of 146 prisoners died in one night. Later historians, including Brijen Gupta, put both figures far lower.

1905

Port Arthur surrenders to Japan

Port Arthur (Lushun), Manchuria, ChinaAsia

After a siege of five months, the Russian commander Anatoly Stessel surrendered the fortress and naval base of Port Arthur to General Nogi Maresuke. The Japanese had taken it by repeated infantry assaults on concrete forts defended by machine guns and barbed wire, a foretaste of the Western Front, and had lost about 58,000 men killed and wounded, including both of Nogi’s sons. From the captured height called 203 Metre Hill their howitzers had sunk the Russian Pacific squadron at its moorings. It was the first time in the modern era that an Asian power had beaten a European one in a major war, and it was reported around the world.

Seen from elsewhere. Stessel still had food and ammunition; a Russian court martial sentenced him to death, later commuted. The war was fought on Chinese soil over who should control Manchuria and Korea, and neither country was asked. Nationalists from India to Egypt took heart from the result. Koreans lost their independence to Japan within the year.

1920

The Palmer Raids

United StatesThe Americas

On a single night, agents of the United States Department of Justice and local police raided meeting halls, pool rooms and homes in more than thirty cities and arrested several thousand people suspected of belonging to the two new communist parties. Estimates run from about 3,000 to as many as 10,000 over the following days. Most were immigrants, many were held without warrants or lawyers, and some were beaten. The operation was planned by Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer and a 25-year-old official named J. Edgar Hoover, with the aim of deporting foreign-born radicals. In the end Louis Post, at the Department of Labor, cancelled most of the warrants, and 556 people were deported.

Seen from elsewhere. Palmer, whose own house had been bombed by an anarchist in June 1919, argued that he had forestalled a revolution in a year of strikes and mail bombs, and the press at first applauded. In May 1920 twelve prominent lawyers, among them Felix Frankfurter and Roscoe Pound, published a report charging his department with illegal practices.

1963

The battle of Ap Bac

Ap Bac, Mekong Delta, South VietnamAsia

Near a hamlet 40 miles south-west of Saigon, about 350 Viet Cong guerrillas dug into a tree line stood their ground against a South Vietnamese force several times larger, supported by American helicopters, armoured carriers, artillery and aircraft. They shot down five helicopters, killed about 80 government soldiers and three Americans, and slipped away after dark having lost, by their own count, 18 dead. The senior American adviser on the spot, Lieutenant Colonel John Paul Vann, called it a miserable performance by the South Vietnamese command. The American headquarters in Saigon declared a victory because the enemy had left the field. Reporters who had been there wrote otherwise.

Seen from elsewhere. For the National Liberation Front it proved that guerrillas could beat helicopters and armour, and ‘emulate Ap Bac’ became a slogan. South Vietnamese officers resented Vann’s public criticism and pointed out that President Diem, fearing coups, discouraged commanders from taking casualties. Historians such as Mark Moyar argue the defeat’s importance was inflated by the press.

Also on 2 January