Parallax

19 January, 1568

Philip II arrests his own son

Close to midnight the King of Spain, wearing armour under his robe, walked into the bedroom of his heir and took away his sword. Six months later the prince was dead, and Europe has been arguing about it, in pamphlets, plays and opera, ever since.

Madrid, Spain

At about eleven on the night of 18 January 1568, Philip II came down the stairs of the Alcazar in Madrid with four of his councillors and a handful of guards. He had a helmet on his head and carried a sword, which was not his habit. The party stopped at the door of the apartments of Don Carlos, Prince of Asturias, his only son, twenty-two years old and heir to Spain, the Netherlands, half of Italy and the Americas.

The prince was known to sleep with weapons to hand and had fitted his door with a mechanism of bolts he could work from his bed. The king had arranged for the engineer who built it to disable it. The councillors went in first and removed a sword and a loaded arquebus from the bedside before Carlos woke. When he saw his father he is reported to have asked whether the king had come to kill him. Philip told him to be calm; what was being done was for his own good.

The king then ordered the windows nailed shut, the fire irons and every blade taken out, and the prince’s papers collected in a chest. Carlos, by the accounts sent home by foreign ambassadors over the following days, cried out that he was not mad but desperate, and tried to throw himself into the fire. Philip told him that from now on he would be treated not as a father treats a son but as a king treats a subject. The household was dismissed and a guard of noblemen set over him. It was past midnight, the early hours of the 19th, when the king went back upstairs.

What had brought matters to this point was a plan of escape. Carlos had been trying to raise money and horses to leave Spain, probably for Italy or the rebellious Netherlands, and had asked his young uncle Don John of Austria to go with him. Don John rode to tell the king. At Christmas the prince had told his confessor that he hated a man and wished him dead, and on being pressed had named his father.

He never left confinement. Through the spring and summer he alternately starved himself and gorged, swallowed a ring, and in the heat of July had his room flooded and slept naked on ice. He died on 24 July 1568, aged twenty-three. Philip wrote to the Pope and to the courts of Europe that he had acted not from anger but from duty to God and his kingdoms. He never published his reasons.

How it came to this

Carlos was born in 1545 to Philip and his first wife and double first cousin, Maria Manuela of Portugal, who died four days later. Generations of Habsburg and Portuguese cousin marriage meant he had four great-grandparents where most people have eight. He grew up largely apart from his father, was slow to speak, had one shoulder higher than the other and suffered recurrent fevers. In 1562 he fell down a staircase at Alcala and fractured his skull; surgeons, the great anatomist Vesalius among those consulted, operated, and the mummified body of a local holy friar was laid beside him in bed. He recovered, but those around him thought his temper worse afterwards.

Reports of violence multiplied: he threatened councillors with a dagger, was said to have forced a bootmaker to eat a badly made pair of boots, and attacked the Duke of Alba when Alba, not he, was sent to govern the Netherlands in 1567. Philip kept him off the council and postponed his marriage. The princess once intended for him, Elisabeth of Valois, had instead married Philip himself in 1559, a diplomatic rearrangement on which later legend would build a love story.

How each side saw it

Philip II

Philip’s own explanation survives in letters to Pope Pius V, to his aunt the Queen of Portugal and to his sister the Empress. The cause, he wrote, was neither a particular offence nor rebellion, nor was the confinement meant as a punishment with an end; it arose from the prince’s nature and condition, which made him unfit to rule, and the king had sacrificed his own flesh and blood to the good of his subjects. He ordered that no one in his realms offer public prayers treating it as a misfortune. Historians sympathetic to Philip, such as Geoffrey Parker, read this as the plain truth told by a secretive man.

William of Orange and the king’s enemies

In his Apology of 1581, written after Philip put a price on his head, William of Orange accused the king of murdering his son and then his wife Elisabeth, who died in childbirth that October, in order to marry his niece. Philip’s exiled secretary Antonio Perez added hints of his own. The charge became a staple of Protestant and Dutch writing and a pillar of what Spaniards later named the Black Legend. It rests on no evidence: Carlos’s decline was witnessed by a household of dozens and reported in detail by ambassadors with no reason to shield Philip.

The foreign ambassadors

Much of the detail comes not from Spanish records but from diplomats: the French envoy Fourquevaux, the Venetian Cavalli, the imperial ambassador Dietrichstein and the papal nuncio. They had competing interests, since Vienna had hoped to marry an archduchess to Carlos, and they wrote from gossip gathered at one remove, because the arrest took place behind closed doors. They agree on the night, the nailing of the windows and the prince’s despair, and disagree on his words. Dietrichstein, who knew Carlos well, described him as unbalanced but not an imbecile, and thought neglect had made him worse.

Schiller, Verdi and the romantic tradition

The Don Carlos most people know was invented a century after the event by the Abbe de Saint-Real, whose historical novel of 1672 made the prince a liberal-minded lover of his stepmother, destroyed by a jealous father and the Inquisition. Schiller’s play of 1787 gave him a friend, the Marquis of Posa, who pleads for freedom of thought, and Verdi’s opera of 1867 set it to music. In this tradition the real subject is tyranny and conscience, and the historical prince, who showed no interest in Dutch liberties beyond wanting a government of his own, is beside the point.

What is disputed

The arrest is often dated 19 January; the king entered the room around eleven on the 18th and the business ran past midnight, so both are defensible. How Carlos died is settled for most historians as self-neglect, fever and dysentery, but the documents Philip seized and any record of the commission he set up to examine the case have never been found, and it is usually assumed he had them destroyed. Whether the prince was insane, brain-injured, or a difficult young man broken by a cold father divides his biographers: Gachard and Parker stress incapacity, while others note how much of the evidence was assembled to justify the king.

What followed

Philip was left without a male heir until 1578 and the succession passed eventually to Philip III, a son by his fourth wife and niece, Anna of Austria. The silence he kept did him more damage than any confession could have: the death of Don Carlos joined the Inquisition and the conquest of the Americas as a fixed item in anti-Spanish polemic for three centuries. Spanish historians from the nineteenth century onward spent great effort refuting it, and the phrase Black Legend, coined by Julian Juderias in 1914, was in part a reply to Schiller.

Read further

  • Louis-Prosper Gachard, Don Carlos et Philippe II (1863)
  • Geoffrey Parker, Imprudent King: A New Life of Philip II (2014)
  • Henry Kamen, Philip of Spain (1997)
  • William of Orange, Apology (1581)
  • Friedrich Schiller, Don Carlos, Infant von Spanien (1787)

Same day, other years

1839

The East India Company seizes Aden

Aden, YemenMiddle East

Steamships needed coal, and the route from Bombay to Suez needed somewhere to keep it. Captain Stafford Haines of the Indian Navy had been negotiating to buy the decayed port of Aden from the Sultan of Lahej, using as leverage the plundering of a wrecked Indian ship on the coast. When the sultan’s family repudiated the sale, two warships and some 700 troops bombarded and stormed the town on 19 January 1839. It had perhaps six hundred inhabitants. It was the first territory added to the British Empire in Victoria’s reign and became one of the busiest harbours in the world.

Seen from elsewhere. The Abdali sultans of Lahej held that Aden had been extorted, and tried three times to retake it by 1841. British rule lasted 128 years and ended in 1967 after an armed insurgency. In Yemeni memory the date marks the start of an occupation; 30 November, the day the last troops left, is the national holiday.

1915

Zeppelins bomb Britain for the first time

Great Yarmouth and King’s Lynn, EnglandEurope

Two German naval airships, L3 and L4, crossed the North Sea after dark on 19 January 1915. Their target was the Humber, but wind and navigation errors brought them over Norfolk instead. L3 dropped its bombs on Great Yarmouth, killing a shoemaker, Samuel Smith, and an elderly woman, Martha Taylor, in the street. L4 wandered along the coast and bombed King’s Lynn, where a boy of fourteen and a young war widow died. Four dead and sixteen injured was a tiny toll by the standards of the Western Front, but it was the first time civilians in Britain had been killed from the air.

Seen from elsewhere. The Kaiser had authorised raids on military and dock targets only and had at first forbidden attacks on London. German newspapers celebrated the end of Britain’s island immunity; the British press called the crews baby-killers. Both sides bombed cities on a far greater scale within a generation, using arguments first rehearsed that winter.

1990

The flight of the Kashmiri Pandits begins

Srinagar, KashmirAsia

An armed insurgency against Indian rule had been growing in the Kashmir Valley through 1989, and several prominent members of its small Hindu minority, the Pandits, had been assassinated. On the night of 19 January 1990, as the state government collapsed and a new governor took over, crowds filled the streets of Srinagar and mosque loudspeakers carried slogans for independence and for Islamic rule, some of them threats against Pandits. Families began leaving before dawn. Within months the great majority of a community of well over 100,000 had gone, mostly to camps in Jammu and Delhi.

Seen from elsewhere. Pandit organisations call it ethnic cleansing and count several hundred of their people killed; official figures are lower. Many Kashmiri Muslims say the governor, Jagmohan, encouraged the departure to clear the way for a crackdown, pointing to the shooting of some fifty protesters at Gawkadal bridge two days later. Few Pandits have returned.

2007

Hrant Dink is shot outside his newspaper

Istanbul, TurkeyMiddle East

Hrant Dink edited Agos, a weekly published in Turkish and Armenian, and argued that Turks and Armenians had to be able to talk about the mass killing of Ottoman Armenians in 1915 without either side making it a test of identity. He had been convicted under the law against insulting Turkishness and had received many threats. On the afternoon of 19 January 2007 a seventeen-year-old from Trabzon shot him in the back of the head on the pavement outside his office. At his funeral some hundred thousand people walked through Istanbul with placards reading ‘We are all Hrant Dink, we are all Armenians’.

Seen from elsewhere. Nationalists answered with the chant ‘We are all Turks’, and photographs emerged of police posing proudly with the gunman. The European Court of Human Rights ruled in 2010 that the state had known of the plot and failed to protect him. Turkish courts later convicted former police intelligence chiefs. The Turkish state continues to reject the term genocide.

Also on 19 January