Parallax

17 January, AD 532

Constantinople burns and an empress refuses to run

Five days into the worst riot in the city’s history, with half the capital on fire, Justinian’s court was packing to flee. What stopped it, according to the one historian who was near the room, was a speech by a former actress.

Constantinople (Istanbul)

By Saturday 17 January 532 the centre of Constantinople had been burning for four days. It had begun with a bungled hanging. Seven men from the city’s chariot-racing factions, the Blues and the Greens, had been condemned for murder after a street fight. The scaffold broke under two of them, one Blue and one Green, and monks carried the survivors across the Golden Horn to sanctuary. At the races on Tuesday 13 January the two factions, normally enemies, chanted together for the men’s pardon. The emperor Justinian, in his box, gave no answer. By the twenty-second race the chant had changed to a single word, Nika, ‘conquer’, and that evening the crowd stormed the city prefect’s headquarters, freed the prisoners and set it alight.

The fire took the entrance to the palace, the senate house and the great church of Holy Wisdom. Justinian tried concession. He dismissed the three officials the crowd hated most, including his tax-raising prefect John the Cappadocian and his law minister Tribonian. It made no difference. The rioters went looking for a new emperor and, when they could not find the man they wanted, burned his house.

On the 17th fresh troops brought in from Thrace fought the crowds through the streets, and the soldiers or the rioters, the sources disagree, set more fires. A hospital had already burned with its patients inside. That evening Justinian ordered the senators sheltering in the palace to go home. Among them were Hypatius and Pompeius, nephews of the former emperor Anastasius. Whether he distrusted them or simply could not feed them, it was a mistake.

Next morning, Sunday the 18th, Justinian went to the Hippodrome carrying the Gospels and swore an amnesty. Part of the crowd jeered him as a perjurer. They fetched Hypatius from his house, his wife clinging to him, and crowned him with a gold collar for want of a diadem. In the palace, the historian Procopius says, the council discussed taking ship. Then the empress Theodora spoke. Everyone must die, she said, but for one who has reigned it is unbearable to be a fugitive; the ships were ready and the sea was there, but for her part she held to the old saying that royalty makes a good burial shroud.

The court stayed. The eunuch Narses went among the Blues with gold and reminded them that Hypatius was a Green. The generals Belisarius and Mundus then led their men, mostly Goths and Heruls, into the packed Hippodrome by two gates and killed until evening. Procopius gives the dead as 30,000. Hypatius and Pompeius were executed the following day and their bodies thrown into the sea.

How it came to this

The Blues and Greens were far more than sports clubs. They were chartered associations that staged the chariot races and theatre shows, with their own seating, funds and gangs of young partisans, and the Hippodrome was the one place where the people of the capital met their emperor face to face and could shout at him. Emperors usually favoured one colour. Justinian and Theodora were Blues, and in the early years of the reign Blue toughs were said to rob and kill with little fear of the courts.

Justinian had come to the throne in 527, the nephew of a peasant soldier from the Balkans who had become emperor. He was an outsider to the old senatorial families, and he had married a woman from the theatre, which the law had forbidden until his uncle changed it for him. By 532 he was fighting an expensive war with Persia, and John the Cappadocian was squeezing the provinces to pay for it, driving ruined men into the capital. When the government finally tried to discipline both factions at once, it united them.

How each side saw it

Procopius, in public and in private

Almost everything rests on Procopius of Caesarea, secretary to Belisarius, who was in the city. In his History of the Wars, written for circulation, Theodora’s speech is the hinge of the crisis and Justinian is rescued by his wife and his generals. In his Secret History, kept hidden in his lifetime, the same author describes Theodora as a child of the circus who performed obscene acts on stage, and the imperial couple as demons in human form. Readers have to decide how the two fit together. Many now think the courage in the first and the pornography in the second are both literary constructions aimed at Justinian.

The crowd

The rioters left no account of their own. Their voice survives in a strange document copied into later chronicles, a shouted exchange in the Hippodrome between the Greens and the emperor’s herald, in which the Greens complain that they are murdered and get no justice and the herald calls them Jews, Manichaeans and Samaritans. The chroniclers John Malalas and the Easter Chronicle, closer to street level than Procopius, record what was demanded: pardon for two men, then the removal of named ministers. Only when those were granted and the fighting went on did the demand become a new emperor.

Hypatius and the senators

Procopius says Hypatius was dragged to the Hippodrome against his will and told Justinian afterwards that he had meant to deliver the crowd to him. Justinian is reported to have asked why, if he controlled them, he had not stopped them burning the city. Eighteen senators had their property confiscated, which suggests the court believed the old aristocracy had used the riot. Some of it was later returned, and Hypatius’s family received his estate back, a hint that Justinian himself came to doubt how guilty he had been.

The Syriac Christian tradition

To the Miaphysite Christians of Syria and Egypt, whom the imperial church counted as heretics, Theodora was neither Procopius’s heroine nor his harlot. John of Ephesus, who knew her, calls her the believing queen who sheltered persecuted bishops and monks inside the palace itself, and mentions without embarrassment that she came ‘from the brothel’. The Syriac Orthodox Church still honours her. This tradition takes no interest in the Nika speech, but it is the only contemporary portrait written by someone who liked her.

What is disputed

The day is the first problem. The reconstruction most scholars follow, set out by J. B. Bury and refined by Geoffrey Greatrex, puts the palace council and the massacre on Sunday 18 January; 17 January, the date under which popular books file the story, was the day of the street fighting and the dismissal of the senators. The speech is the second. Its closing proverb is a classical quotation about tyranny, not royalty, and Averil Cameron and others suspect Procopius composed the scene to shame Justinian. The death toll runs from 30,000 in Procopius to 50,000 in John Lydus, and no figure can be checked.

What followed

Justinian ruled for another thirty-three years and was never seriously challenged in his capital again. John the Cappadocian and Tribonian were back in office within months. On the burnt ground beside the palace he commissioned a new church of Holy Wisdom from Anthemius of Tralles and Isidore of Miletus; Hagia Sophia was dedicated on 27 December 537, less than six years after the fire, and its dome still stands. Belisarius sailed the next year to conquer Vandal Africa. Theodora died in 548 and is shown, crowned and haloed, in the mosaics at Ravenna.

Read further

  • Procopius, History of the Wars, Book 1, and The Secret History
  • John Malalas, Chronicle, Book 18
  • Geoffrey Greatrex, ‘The Nika Riot: A Reappraisal’, Journal of Hellenic Studies (1997)
  • Alan Cameron, Circus Factions: Blues and Greens at Rome and Byzantium (1976)
  • David Potter, Theodora: Actress, Empress, Saint (2015)

Same day, other years

1377

The papacy comes back to Rome

RomeEurope

Pope Gregory XI, a Frenchman, entered Rome on 17 January 1377 after a rough winter voyage from Marseille, ending nearly seventy years in which seven successive popes had lived at Avignon on the Rhone. He came because the Papal States were in revolt and slipping from his control, and because voices such as Catherine of Siena and Bridget of Sweden had insisted that Peter’s successor belonged at Peter’s tomb. He found a half-ruined city of perhaps thirty thousand people, cattle grazing among the ancient monuments, and was planning to leave again when he died in March 1378.

Seen from elsewhere. Petrarch had called Avignon a Babylonian captivity; French cardinals thought it a well-run and safer capital, and historians now tend to agree that the Avignon popes were capable administrators. The conclave after Gregory’s death, held with a Roman mob at the doors, produced two rival popes and a schism that lasted until 1417.

1893

The Hawaiian monarchy is overthrown

Honolulu, Hawaiian KingdomOceania

Queen Liliuokalani had tried to replace a constitution forced on her brother at gunpoint in 1887, which had stripped the crown of power and most Native Hawaiians of the vote. In response a Committee of Safety, made up largely of American-descended businessmen and sugar planters, declared the monarchy at an end on 17 January 1893. The United States minister, John Stevens, had marines landed from the USS Boston the day before. The queen yielded under protest, as she put it, to the superior force of the United States, expecting Washington to restore her.

Seen from elsewhere. The provisional government said it had ended misrule and sought annexation, achieved in 1898. President Cleveland’s investigator, James Blount, found the overthrow unlawful; a later Senate report cleared Stevens. Petitions against annexation gathered some 21,000 Hawaiian signatures in 1897. Congress apologised in 1993. Sovereignty groups hold that the kingdom was never lawfully extinguished.

1961

Patrice Lumumba is shot in Katanga

Near Elisabethville (Lubumbashi), CongoAfrica

Lumumba had been the first elected prime minister of independent Congo for under three months when he was dismissed, and for under seven when he died. Captured by Colonel Mobutu’s troops while trying to reach his supporters, he was flown on 17 January 1961 with two colleagues, Maurice Mpolo and Joseph Okito, to the breakaway province of Katanga, beaten on the aircraft, and shot that night by a firing squad under Belgian officers with Katangan ministers present. The bodies were later dug up and dissolved in acid. His death was announced nearly a month later as the work of villagers.

Seen from elsewhere. Western governments saw him as opening Africa to Moscow; the CIA had separately plotted to poison him. A Belgian parliamentary inquiry in 2001 found Belgium morally responsible, and Brussels apologised. A tooth kept by a Belgian policeman was returned to his family in 2022. Across Africa he is remembered as a martyr of independence.

1991

The air war against Iraq begins

Iraq and KuwaitMiddle East

In the early hours of 17 January 1991, Baghdad time, a coalition led by the United States began bombing Iraq, five and a half months after Saddam Hussein’s army had occupied Kuwait and two days after a United Nations deadline for withdrawal expired. Helicopters and stealth aircraft struck radar sites and the capital, and television viewers around the world watched anti-aircraft fire over Baghdad live. The air campaign lasted almost six weeks; the ground war that followed took a hundred hours. Iraq fired Scud missiles at Israel and Saudi Arabia from the second night.

Seen from elsewhere. The coalition, which included Egypt, Syria and Saudi Arabia, called it the enforcement of UN resolutions. Iraq called Kuwait its nineteenth province and the war an imperial assault. Estimates of Iraqi dead vary enormously, and the destruction of power and water plants, followed by years of sanctions, is blamed by many for far more civilian deaths than the bombing itself.

Also on 17 January