Parallax

9 January, 1916

The last boats leave Gallipoli

After eight and a half months and something like half a million casualties on the two sides, the last British soldiers slipped away from the Dardanelles in the dark, and their enemies woke to find the beaches empty.

Cape Helles, Gallipoli peninsula, Ottoman Empire

By the first week of 1916 the British army at Cape Helles, the toe of the Gallipoli peninsula, was an army pretending to be there. Anzac Cove and Suvla Bay, further up the coast, had been emptied over two nights before Christmas without the Ottoman defenders noticing until the beaches were bare. Nobody at Helles expected the same trick to work twice. The French had already gone. Some 35,000 British troops remained, with their guns, mules and mountains of stores, in trenches that in places lay only a few yards from the enemy.

They were taken off by night, a few thousand at a time, while the men left behind kept up the routine of a full garrison: the same rifle fire, the same flares, the same cooking smoke. For weeks the troops had also been practising long silences, so that a quiet line would not seem strange. On 7 January the Ottoman Fifth Army, commanded by the German general Otto Liman von Sanders, tested the front with the heaviest bombardment of the campaign and an infantry assault at Gully Spur. The thin line of the 13th Division held, and many of the attackers, by British and Turkish accounts alike, were reluctant to leave their trenches.

The last night was 8 January. About 17,000 men filed down to the piers at W Beach and V Beach, past the hulk of the River Clyde, the collier that had been run aground there during the landings in April. Behind them rifles were rigged to fire by themselves, with water dripping from one tin into another until the weight pulled the trigger, and candles burned down towards fuses. The wind rose towards a gale and began to break up the piers. Major-General Stanley Maude, whose lighter had stuck fast at Gully Beach, had to walk some two miles across the dark peninsula with his staff, and reached W Beach with very little time to spare.

At about a quarter to four on the morning of 9 January the last boats pushed off. Minutes later the fuses reached the ammunition dumps and the main magazine went up, throwing debris far enough out to sea to kill a sailor in one of the departing boats. He is usually counted as the only death of the night. The Ottoman guns then opened on beaches where there was no longer anyone to hit.

Left behind were hundreds of slaughtered mules, wrecked wagons and stores that the Ottoman soldiers, hungry and badly clothed after a winter in the open, spent days collecting. Left behind too were the dead. The men who had planned the campaign had talked of taking Constantinople and knocking the Ottoman Empire out of the war. The village of Krithia, about four miles from the Helles beaches and an objective for the first day, was never taken.

How it came to this

The Ottoman Empire had entered the war on Germany’s side in November 1914. In London Winston Churchill, First Lord of the Admiralty, pressed for a naval attack on the Dardanelles, the narrow strait leading towards Constantinople, as a way round the deadlock in France and a way to help Russia. When British and French battleships tried to force the strait on 18 March 1915 they ran into an unsuspected line of mines; three were sunk and three more badly damaged. The plan then became a landing by the army under General Sir Ian Hamilton.

The landings of 25 April put British troops ashore at Helles and Australians and New Zealanders further north at what became Anzac Cove. Neither force broke out. A second landing at Suvla Bay in August failed as well. Heat, flies and dysentery in summer gave way in late November to a storm and blizzard that drowned men in their trenches and froze others to death. By then Bulgaria had joined the Central Powers, opening a railway from Germany along which heavy guns and shells could reach the Ottoman army. Hamilton was replaced by Sir Charles Monro, who recommended leaving within days of arriving. Lord Kitchener came out to see for himself and agreed.

How each side saw it

The Ottoman army and Turkish memory

For the Ottoman army this was Canakkale, the defence of the homeland against an invasion aimed at the capital, and its greatest victory of the war. The Turkish General Staff history and soldiers’ memoirs stress the cost, and the victory is commemorated on 18 March, the day the fleets were turned back, not on the day the invaders left. The battle made the name of Mustafa Kemal, the divisional commander who later founded the republic as Ataturk. Liman von Sanders wrote in Five Years in Turkey that he had not known the final withdrawal was under way, and regretted the escape. Some Turkish writers have held instead that an exhausted army was content to let the enemy go.

Australians and New Zealanders

Their troops had left three weeks earlier, from Anzac Cove, and it is the landing of 25 April, not the departure, that both countries mark each year as Anzac Day. The official historian Charles Bean, who was there, presented Gallipoli as the place where a distinct Australian character proved itself, and that view shaped national memory for a century. It carried a companion belief that brave colonial soldiers were wasted by incompetent British generals. Recent Australian historians, Robin Prior among them, have questioned both halves: the planning was poor at every level, and British and French troops did most of the fighting and dying on the peninsula.

Churchill, Hamilton and their critics in London

Churchill lost his office over the Dardanelles and defended the idea for the rest of his life. In The World Crisis he argued that the fleet had been within reach of success in March and that hesitation, not the plan, was fatal. The Dardanelles Commission, which reported in 1917 and 1919, blamed muddled decision-making in the War Council and underestimation of the enemy. One of its witnesses was the Australian journalist Keith Murdoch, whose letter of September 1915 had helped bring Hamilton down. Hamilton’s own Gallipoli Diary insists he was starved of men and shells by a government that would not choose between this front and France.

The peninsula’s civilians

The villages on the battlefield, Krithia among them, were largely Greek Orthodox. Ottoman authorities deported the peninsula’s Greek inhabitants, by most accounts some 20,000 people, in the spring of 1915 as a security measure, and few ever returned. They left almost no testimony of their own; what is known comes mainly from Greek Patriarchate reports and foreign consuls. The arrest of Armenian leaders in Constantinople on 24 April 1915, the eve of the landings, is treated by most historians as the opening of the Armenian genocide, a term the Turkish state rejects.

What is disputed

Casualty figures are uncertain on both sides. Allied losses are usually put at 200,000 to 250,000 including the sick, with some 44,000 dead. Ottoman totals are given in a similar range, but Edward Erickson and Turkish historians differ over how many died, with estimates from about 57,000 to 87,000 and higher. Whether the Ottomans were truly deceived at Helles, or chose not to press a departing enemy, is debated. The larger argument is whether the campaign could ever have worked. Churchill, and later Alan Moorehead, saw a near miss; Robin Prior argues that even the capture of Constantinople would not have shortened the war.

What followed

The evacuated divisions went to Egypt, Salonika, Mesopotamia and the Western Front; some of the men who got away from Helles were on the Somme by July. The Ottoman troops released from the peninsula were sent against the Russians in the Caucasus and the British in Iraq, where the garrison of Kut surrendered in April 1916. The straits stayed closed to Russia. The peninsula is now a national park of cemeteries and memorials visited by Turks, Australians, New Zealanders, Britons and French, each of whom tends to arrive with a different story about what happened there.

Read further

  • Robin Prior, Gallipoli: The End of the Myth (2009)
  • Edward J. Erickson, Gallipoli: The Ottoman Campaign (2010)
  • Peter Hart, Gallipoli (2011)
  • Otto Liman von Sanders, Five Years in Turkey (1927)
  • C. F. Aspinall-Oglander, Military Operations: Gallipoli (1929-32)

Same day, other years

1349

The Jews of Basel are burned

Basel, Holy Roman EmpireEurope

As the Black Death moved up the Rhine, a rumour travelled ahead of it that Jews were poisoning the wells. In Basel the city council at first resisted, and had even banished some nobles for violence against Jews. The guilds marched on the town hall and forced it to give way. On 9 January 1349 the Jewish community was shut inside a wooden building put up for the purpose on an island in the Rhine and burned alive. Chroniclers give the number as 600; many historians think it was lower. Children were spared, baptised by force and placed in convents. The plague had not yet reached the city.

Seen from elsewhere. Pope Clement VI had already issued bulls in 1348 pointing out that Jews were dying of the plague like everyone else, and forbidding attacks on them. The chronicler Matthias of Neuenburg, the main source, records the burning without much comment. Historians note that many of those pressing for it owed money to their victims.

1960

Nasser starts work on the Aswan High Dam

Aswan, EgyptAfrica

President Gamal Abdel Nasser set off the first charge of dynamite at Aswan on 9 January 1960, beginning a dam across the Nile more than two miles long. The United States and Britain had withdrawn their offer of finance in 1956, which led Nasser to nationalise the Suez Canal; the Soviet Union supplied the money and engineers instead. Finished in 1970, the dam ended the annual flood, protected Egypt from the droughts of the 1980s and for a time supplied half its electricity. The lake behind it drowned the land of Nubia. Around 100,000 Nubians in Egypt and Sudan were moved, and UNESCO led a campaign to cut the temples of Abu Simbel out of the rock and rebuild them on higher ground.

Seen from elsewhere. Nubians were resettled in purpose-built villages far from the river and have campaigned ever since for a right to return to the lake shore, a promise written into Egypt’s 2014 constitution and not yet kept. Critics also point to what the flood used to bring: the silt now settles in the lake, and the delta coast is eroding.

1964

The flag riots in the Panama Canal Zone

Panama City and the Canal Zone, PanamaThe Americas

The Canal Zone was a strip of United States territory running through the middle of Panama. On 9 January 1964 about two hundred students from Panama’s Instituto Nacional walked into it carrying their school’s Panamanian flag, intending to raise it beside the American flag at Balboa High School as an agreement between the two governments allowed. In a scuffle with American students and police the flag was torn. By nightfall crowds were fighting Zone police and then US troops along the boundary. Three days of violence left more than twenty Panamanians and four American soldiers dead. Panama broke off diplomatic relations, and keeps the date as Martyrs’ Day.

Seen from elsewhere. American residents of the Zone said they were defending their homes, and the US Army said its soldiers fired on snipers. An inquiry by the International Commission of Jurists found the force used had been excessive but also faulted the Panamanian authorities for failing to restrain the crowds. The riots led, thirteen years later, to the treaties that returned the canal.

2005

Peace agreement ends Sudan’s long civil war

Nairobi, KenyaAfrica

The war between Sudan’s government in Khartoum and the Sudan People’s Liberation Movement in the south had run since 1983 and, with the famines that came with it, had killed about two million people. On 9 January 2005, after years of talks in the Kenyan town of Naivasha, Vice-President Ali Osman Taha and the rebel leader John Garang signed the Comprehensive Peace Agreement in Nairobi. It shared oil revenue and power, gave the south its own government, and promised southerners a vote on independence after six years. Garang died in a helicopter crash that July. The referendum opened on 9 January 2011, and almost 99 per cent voted to leave.

Seen from elsewhere. The agreement was a bargain between two armed parties. It left out Darfur, where another war was then at its worst, as well as the northern opposition and other southern factions, and it left the border district of Abyei unsettled. South Sudan itself fell into civil war in 2013, two years after independence.

Also on 9 January