Parallax

30 January, 1889

The heir to Austria-Hungary is found dead at Mayerling

Crown Prince Rudolf and a seventeen-year-old baroness died in a locked bedroom at a hunting lodge. The court announced a heart attack, then a suicide, and hid the girl’s body. People have been arguing about that room ever since.

Mayerling, Lower Austria

At about half past seven on the morning of Wednesday 30 January 1889, the valet Johann Loschek knocked on the bedroom door of the hunting lodge at Mayerling, in the Vienna Woods, and got no answer. An hour or so earlier the Crown Prince had come out in his dressing gown, told him to call again at that time and gone back in whistling. Loschek fetched Count Josef Hoyos, one of two guests invited for the shooting. When the second guest, Rudolf’s brother-in-law Prince Philipp of Coburg, arrived from Vienna, they agreed to break in, and Loschek split a door panel with an axe.

The shutters were closed. Rudolf, thirty years old and heir to the thrones of Austria and Hungary, was slumped at the side of the bed with the top of his skull shattered. Beside him lay Baroness Mary Vetsera, seventeen, shot through the temple and, from the state of the body, dead for some hours. A revolver was on the floor. There were letters on the table.

Mary had been at the lodge since Monday, brought out from Vienna in secret by the cab driver Bratfisch after slipping away from Rudolf’s cousin Countess Marie Larisch during a shopping trip. Neither guest knew she was in the house. On Tuesday Rudolf had pleaded a cold and stayed in while the others shot, and that evening sent his excuses to a family dinner at the Hofburg. After supper with Hoyos he withdrew, and Bratfisch, who was known for it, whistled and sang for the couple late into the night.

Hoyos drove to Baden, had the Trieste express stopped, and reached the Hofburg by mid-morning. Nobody was willing to tell the emperor. The Empress Elisabeth was informed first, during her Greek lesson, and it was she who told Franz Joseph. Hoyos, who had seen little in the dark room, at first believed and reported that the girl had poisoned the prince.

The first public bulletin gave the cause of death as apoplexy. Within two days the court conceded that Rudolf had shot himself, and the doctors’ report spoke of abnormalities of the brain indicating a deranged mind, the finding needed for a church funeral. Mary was not mentioned. On the night of 31 January two of her uncles were made to carry her body out of the lodge dressed in coat and hat, seat it upright between them in a carriage, and take it through a storm to the abbey of Heiligenkreuz, where it was buried at once.

How it came to this

Rudolf was the only son of Franz Joseph, who had ruled since 1848 and governed by routine, the army and the Church. Educated by liberal tutors, the prince became a capable ornithologist, a critic of aristocratic privilege and the anonymous author of articles in the newspaper of his friend Moriz Szeps attacking his father’s ministers. He was sympathetic to Hungarian aspirations and hostile to the alliance with Germany. The emperor gave him military duties and no part in government, and the police read his letters. His marriage in 1881 to Princess Stephanie of Belgium produced one daughter and then broke down.

By 1888 he was ill, probably with gonorrhoea, and was taking morphine and drinking heavily. He spoke often of death. That summer he proposed a suicide pact to Mizzi Kaspar, a Viennese courtesan who was his long-standing mistress; she reported it to the police, who did nothing. In the autumn Countess Larisch introduced him to Mary Vetsera, the daughter of a diplomat’s widow from a family of Levantine bankers, who had been infatuated with him from a distance. Their affair lasted about three months.

How each side saw it

The emperor and the court

For Franz Joseph the first duty was to the dynasty and the faith. A Habsburg heir who had killed a young woman and then himself could not be buried in the Capuchin crypt, so the murder was erased and the suicide ascribed to madness. The papers of the investigation were kept by the prime minister, Count Taaffe, and have never been found. Staff were sworn to silence and foreign newspapers confiscated at the border. Rudolf left letters for his wife, mother and sister, and none for his father, who is reported to have said that his son had died like a tailor.

The Vetsera family

Mary’s mother, Helene Vetsera, was refused entry to the palace, told to leave Vienna and forbidden to attend the burial. That summer she had a memorandum privately printed setting out what she knew, to answer the rumour that she had sold her daughter to the prince; the police seized almost every copy. Mary’s farewell letters to her mother, sister and brother, long thought destroyed, were found in a Vienna bank vault in 2015. In them she asks forgiveness, says she could not resist love, and writes that she is happier in death than in life.

Crown Princess Stephanie

Stephanie published her memoirs in 1935 under a title meaning ‘I was to be Empress’. She describes a husband who had become unrecognisable, restless and frightening, and says that she went to the emperor in 1888 to warn him that Rudolf was ill and in danger, and was sent away with the assurance that nothing was wrong. Rudolf’s last letter to her, which she printed, tells her she is rid of his presence and asks her to be good to their daughter. The court, she wrote, blamed her for failing to hold him.

Liberals and Hungarians

For the monarchy’s liberals, and for many Hungarians, Jews and others who feared the rising nationalist and clerical parties, Rudolf had been the hope of a different empire after his father. Szeps’s newspaper mourned him as a man of the modern age. Because the official story changed twice in three days, almost nobody believed the final version either, and rumours spread at once: that he had been killed by a jealous forester, by Mary’s relatives, or for political reasons. The secrecy that was meant to protect the dynasty did lasting harm to its credit.

What is disputed

Most historians, following Brigitte Hamann and the documentary work of Fritz Judtmann, accept that Rudolf shot Mary with her consent and killed himself some hours later. The gap between the two deaths, and what he did in it, is unexplained. The former Empress Zita claimed in 1983 that the couple were murdered by foreign agents because Rudolf refused to join a plot against his father; no evidence has been produced. Other theories involve a failed abortion. Mary’s remains, disturbed in 1945 and stolen from the grave in 1991 by a man obsessed with the case, were examined with inconclusive results. A reported quarrel between father and son in the last days cannot be dated or confirmed.

What followed

The succession passed to the emperor’s brother Karl Ludwig and then to his son Franz Ferdinand, whose assassination at Sarajevo in 1914 set off the First World War. Franz Joseph had the lodge turned into a Carmelite convent, with the chapel altar on the site of the bedroom, and nuns still pray there. Elisabeth wore mourning until she was stabbed to death in Geneva in 1898. Whether Rudolf as emperor could have reformed the monarchy is unknowable, but the question has kept Mayerling alive in films, a ballet and a long shelf of books.

Read further

  • Brigitte Hamann, Rudolf: Crown Prince and Rebel (2017)
  • Fritz Judtmann, Mayerling: The Facts Behind the Legend (1971)
  • Greg King and Penny Wilson, Twilight of Empire: The Tragedy at Mayerling and the End of the Habsburgs (2017)
  • Princess Stephanie of Belgium, I Was to Be Empress (1937)
  • Frederic Morton, A Nervous Splendor: Vienna 1888-1889 (1979)

Same day, other years

1649

Charles I is beheaded outside his own banqueting hall

Whitehall, London, EnglandEurope

After seven years of civil war and a week-long trial before a court he refused to recognise, Charles I stepped through a window of the Banqueting House on to a scaffold draped in black. It was a bitterly cold afternoon and he had put on two shirts so that he would not be seen to shiver. He told the few who could hear that he died a martyr of the people and went from a corruptible to an incorruptible crown. A masked executioner took off his head with one blow, and a witness remembered a groan from the crowd. The date is by the old English calendar; it was 9 February in most of Europe.

Seen from elsewhere. The army leaders and the fifty-nine men who signed the warrant held that a king who had twice made war on his people was a ‘man of blood’ answerable like anyone else. Royalists made him a saint, and a book of his supposed meditations sold in dozens of editions. Historians disagree over whether the trial was always meant to end in death.

1933

Hindenburg appoints Hitler chancellor

Berlin, GermanyEurope

Shortly before noon the eighty-five-year-old President Paul von Hindenburg swore in Adolf Hitler as chancellor of Germany at the head of a coalition cabinet. Only two other National Socialists held posts in it. The arrangement had been put together in weeks of private dealing by the former chancellor Franz von Papen, who became vice-chancellor and assured doubters that the conservatives had hired Hitler and would soon have him squeezed into a corner. The Nazi vote had in fact fallen at the last free election, in November 1932, to a third of the total. That evening tens of thousands of stormtroopers marched with torches past the chancellery. Within two months civil liberties were suspended and parliament had voted away its powers.

Seen from elsewhere. The Nazis called the day their seizure of power, though power was handed to them. The Communists called for a general strike that the Social Democrats, distrusting them and wary of acting outside the law, did not join. The main Jewish civic association advised its members to wait calmly. Historians such as Henry Ashby Turner stress how avoidable the appointment was.

1948

Gandhi is shot on his way to prayers

New Delhi, IndiaAsia

A little after five in the afternoon Mohandas Gandhi, aged seventy-eight and leaning on two young relatives, walked across the garden of Birla House to his daily prayer meeting. A man stepped out of the crowd, bowed and fired three shots into his chest. Gandhi died within minutes. Twelve days earlier he had ended a fast undertaken to stop the killing of Muslims in Delhi and to press the Indian government to pay Pakistan money owed under the partition settlement. The killer, Nathuram Godse, was a Hindu nationalist from Pune whose group had tried to bomb the same meeting ten days before. Nehru told the nation by radio that the light had gone out of their lives.

Seen from elsewhere. Godse told the court that Gandhi’s concessions to Muslims had brought about Partition and endangered Hindus; publication of the statement was banned for years. He and Narayan Apte were hanged in 1949. The ideologue V. D. Savarkar was tried and acquitted. Whether Gandhi’s last words were ‘He Ram’ was disputed even among those beside him.

1968

The Tet Offensive begins a day early

South VietnamAsia

During the truce for the lunar new year, communist forces in several coastal and highland towns of South Vietnam, among them Nha Trang, Da Nang and Pleiku, attacked in the early hours of 30 January, apparently because of confusion over the date. The main assault came the following night: some eighty thousand North Vietnamese and Viet Cong troops struck more than a hundred towns and cities, including Saigon, where a squad broke into the American embassy compound. Most attacks were beaten off within days. The city of Hue was held for nearly a month. The attackers lost tens of thousands of men, but Americans who had been told the war was being won stopped believing it.

Seen from elsewhere. Hanoi’s leaders had expected a popular uprising in the cities, which did not happen; the southern general Tran Van Tra later wrote that the goals were beyond their strength. In Hue, communist cadres executed some 2,800 or more civilians. Some American commanders and writers have argued that press coverage turned a battlefield victory into defeat, which others dispute.

Also on 30 January