Parallax

20 January, 1936

The King’s doctor hastens the end

George V died at Sandringham five minutes before midnight. Fifty years passed before the public learned that his physician had injected him with morphia and cocaine to make sure of it, and had the morning papers in mind when he did.

Sandringham, Norfolk, England

The King had been failing for a week. George V was seventy, a lifelong heavy smoker with ruined lungs and a weak heart, and since a near-fatal chest infection in 1928 he had never been fully well. In the middle of January 1936 he took to his bedroom at Sandringham House, the Norfolk estate he loved above all his palaces, drowsy and short of breath. His physician, Lord Dawson of Penn, was sent for.

On the morning of Monday 20 January a handful of privy counsellors were brought to the bedroom door so that the King could approve a council of state to act for him. He was propped in a chair, and it took him several minutes, with Dawson kneeling to guide his hand, to make two marks on the paper that stood for a signature. He apologised to the counsellors for keeping them waiting.

That evening, over dinner in the household dining room, Dawson took a menu card and wrote on the back the bulletin that the BBC read out at half past nine: ‘The King’s life is moving peacefully towards its close.’ By about eleven the King was in a coma and, in Dawson’s judgment, might linger for hours. Dawson recorded what he did next in his private notes. He injected three quarters of a grain of morphia and, shortly afterwards, a grain of cocaine into the distended jugular vein. The nurse in attendance, Catherine Black, was unwilling to give the injections, so he gave them himself.

Breathing grew quieter within a quarter of an hour. Queen Mary and the King’s children stood round the bed while the Archbishop of Canterbury read the prayers for the dying. George V died at 11.55 pm. The Queen turned to her eldest son, now Edward VIII, bowed and kissed his hand. The new king, to the distress of some present, broke into loud weeping and then ordered the Sandringham clocks, which his father had always kept half an hour fast, put back to the correct time.

Dawson’s notes are frank about a second motive. A death before midnight could be announced first in the morning newspapers, The Times above all, ‘rather than the less appropriate evening journals’. He had already had his wife telephone The Times in London to advise that the presses be held. The edition of 21 January carried the news with black borders.

How it came to this

Bertrand Dawson was the most eminent doctor in Britain: physician to four sovereigns, raised to the peerage in 1920, president of the Royal College of Physicians. He had saved the King’s life in 1928 by locating and draining an abscess behind the lung. His standing with the public was more mixed, and a rhyme went round that Lord Dawson of Penn had killed lots of men, which was why people sang God save the King.

Deliberately ending a patient’s life was murder in English law in 1936, as it is now. What many doctors did in practice, and seldom wrote down, was to give opiates in rising doses to the dying in the knowledge that this might shorten life. A Voluntary Euthanasia Legalisation Society had been founded in 1935, and a bill to permit it under safeguards came before the House of Lords at the end of 1936. Dawson spoke against that bill. He told the Lords that easing death was a matter for the wisdom and conscience of the medical profession and not something to be regulated by statute.

How each side saw it

Lord Dawson

Dawson’s notes, kept in the Royal Archives, present the act as a mercy to the patient and to those watching. Hours of waiting for a mechanical end when all that is really life has departed, he wrote, only exhausts the onlookers and keeps them so strained that they cannot find the solace of thought, communion or prayer. He recorded that he had discussed the matter beforehand with the Queen and the Prince of Wales, and that both had said they did not wish life prolonged if the illness was mortal. He decided the moment himself and did not record asking anyone’s consent to the injections.

The royal family

No member of the family left a public account that mentions the injections, and it is not known how much they understood. Queen Mary’s diary says only that her husband passed away peacefully and that she was heartbroken. Edward VIII, in his memoirs, describes the bedside and the clocks. When the facts were published in 1986 Buckingham Palace had nothing of substance to say beyond the fact that it had all happened long ago. The King’s biographers before that date, including Harold Nicolson, who wrote the official life, either did not know or did not say.

Medical and legal critics

When Dawson’s own biographer, Francis Watson, revealed the notes in 1986, having left the episode out of his 1950 book at the request of Dawson’s widow, reaction among doctors was sharp. The King had not asked to die, was in no recorded pain, and was unconscious. Dr J. H. R. Ramsay, writing in the British Medical Journal in 1994, argued that on Dawson’s own evidence this was neither the relief of suffering nor voluntary euthanasia but a convenience killing arranged around a newspaper deadline, and that in law it was murder. Others replied that Dawson did, with a syringe, what his generation did routinely and silently.

What is disputed

The King’s last words were officially given as an inquiry after the Empire, made to his secretary that morning. The cheerfully rude ‘Bugger Bognor’, supposedly a reply to the suggestion that he would soon be well enough to visit the resort, is more likely a story from his 1929 convalescence, if he said it at all. Dawson’s notes record something else again: ‘God damn you’, addressed to the nurse as she gave him a sedative near the end. Whether the injections shortened his life by hours or only by minutes cannot be known, and whether Dawson’s motive was chiefly compassion, the family’s ordeal or the press timetable depends on how one weighs three sentences in his own hand.

What followed

Edward VIII reigned for 325 days and abdicated in December 1936 to marry Wallis Simpson; his brother, the stammering Duke of York, became George VI. Dawson attended that king as well and died in 1945 with his reputation intact. The 1936 euthanasia bill was defeated, and assisted dying remained unlawful in Britain into the present century, with Parliament still divided over it. Dawson’s case is cited by both sides: as proof that doctors have always quietly eased death, and as proof of what a doctor may do when no one is checking.

Read further

  • Francis Watson, ‘The Death of George V’, History Today (1986)
  • J. H. R. Ramsay, ‘A king, a doctor, and a convenient death’, British Medical Journal (1994)
  • Kenneth Rose, King George V (1983)
  • Francis Watson, Dawson of Penn (1950)
  • Jane Ridley, George V: Never a Dull Moment (2021)

Same day, other years

1265

Simon de Montfort’s parliament meets

Westminster, EnglandEurope

Simon de Montfort, Earl of Leicester, had defeated and captured his brother-in-law Henry III at Lewes the previous May and was ruling England in the king’s name. To shore up a government that most of the great barons would not support, he summoned a parliament to Westminster for 20 January 1265 and, alongside bishops and nobles, called two knights from every shire and, for the first time, two citizens from each of the major towns. It sat until March. In August Montfort was killed and dismembered at Evesham by the army of the king’s son Edward.

Seen from elsewhere. Victorians hailed him as founder of the House of Commons. To royalists he was a usurper packing an assembly with his own partisans: only five earls and eighteen barons were summoned. His followers had massacred Jews in London and elsewhere in 1264. Edward, having destroyed him, kept the idea, and summoned townsmen to parliaments of his own.

1841

A deal that neither government wanted hands over Hong Kong

Pearl River estuary, ChinaAsia

Britain had gone to war with Qing China in 1839 after the commissioner Lin Zexu confiscated and destroyed more than a thousand tons of British-owned opium at Canton. After British ships took the forts at the mouth of the Pearl River, the British plenipotentiary Charles Elliot and the Manchu negotiator Qishan agreed terms, which Elliot announced on 20 January 1841: an indemnity, the reopening of trade, and the cession of the island of Hong Kong. A naval party landed and raised the flag there six days later, on a shore that was home to a few thousand fishermen, farmers and stonecutters.

Seen from elsewhere. Both capitals rejected it. Palmerston dismissed Elliot for accepting ‘a barren island with hardly a house upon it’. The Daoguang emperor had Qishan taken to Beijing in chains for giving away territory. The war resumed, and the Treaty of Nanjing in 1842 confirmed the cession, the first of what China calls the unequal treaties. Hong Kong returned to China in 1997.

1942

Fifteen officials meet at Wannsee

Berlin, GermanyEurope

Reinhard Heydrich, head of the Reich Security Main Office, called senior civil servants and SS officers to a villa on the Wannsee lake on 20 January 1942. The meeting lasted about ninety minutes. Its purpose was to establish that his office had authority over what the minutes call the final solution of the Jewish question in Europe, and to secure the cooperation of the ministries. Eight of the fifteen held doctorates. The minutes, drafted by Adolf Eichmann, list eleven million Jews by country, including those of Britain and Ireland, and speak of evacuation to the east and of labour under which most would fall away.

Seen from elsewhere. Wannsee did not decide the genocide: mass shootings had killed hundreds of thousands since mid-1941 and gassing had begun at Chelmno in December. Historians differ on when Hitler’s decision came; Christian Gerlach places it in December 1941. Surviving participants claimed in court not to remember what was discussed. One copy of the minutes, of thirty, was found in 1947.

1973

Amilcar Cabral is assassinated

Conakry, GuineaAfrica

Cabral, an agronomist born in Portuguese Guinea to Cape Verdean parents, had founded the PAIGC in 1956 and led a guerrilla war that by 1973 controlled most of the countryside of what is now Guinea-Bissau, running schools, clinics and shops in the liberated zones. He was also one of the most original political thinkers of African independence. On the night of 20 January 1973 he was shot outside his house in Conakry, the movement’s base in exile, by Inocencio Kani, a disaffected PAIGC naval commander, in an attempted takeover that collapsed within hours.

Seen from elsewhere. The PAIGC and Guinea’s government blamed the Portuguese secret police, who had long tried to split mainland Guineans from the movement’s Cape Verdean leadership; Portuguese involvement has been widely alleged and never proved, and some point to resentments inside the party itself. The PAIGC declared independence that September. Portugal recognised it in 1974, after its own army overthrew the dictatorship.

Also on 20 January