Parallax

16 January, 1809

Sir John Moore is killed at Corunna

A British army that had been chased 250 miles through the mountains of Galicia in midwinter turned at the sea and fought to cover its escape. Its commander lived just long enough to learn that the French had been held.

Corunna (A Coruna), Galicia, Spain

The army that came down to Corunna on 11 January 1809 looked like a mob of beggars. It had marched from Leon across the Galician mountains in three weeks of snow and rain, with Marshal Soult’s corps behind it. Shoes had rotted off. In the wine towns of Bembibre and Villafranca regiments had broken into the cellars, and hundreds of drunken stragglers had been left to the French cavalry. The paymaster’s barrels of silver dollars had been rolled over a cliff. About 5,000 men were missing, along with many of the soldiers’ wives and children who had followed the column.

The harbour was empty. The transports had been sent to Vigo and did not come round until the 14th. Sir John Moore used the days to rest and re-arm his infantry from the stores in the town, and to get rid of what he could not take. On the 13th some 4,000 barrels of powder were blown up, breaking windows across Corunna. The cavalry’s horses, lame and with no room for them aboard, were shot or had their throats cut on the beach. The sick, the cavalrymen and most of the guns were embarked, leaving about 15,000 infantry on a low ridge two miles south of the town.

Soult, with roughly the same number and more artillery on the higher ground opposite, attacked early in the afternoon of 16 January. The fighting centred on the village of Elvina on the British right, which changed hands several times. Moore, a Glasgow-born general of 47 who had trained the army’s new light infantry, rode forward to bring up the 42nd Highlanders and the Guards. A cannon shot struck him from his horse, carrying away his left shoulder and part of the collarbone so that the arm hung by a strip of flesh.

He was carried back to the town in a blanket by six soldiers, stopping them repeatedly so that he could look back at the firing. He would not let his sword be unbuckled. In his lodgings near the harbour he asked whether the French were beaten, and on being told they were said he hoped the people of England would be satisfied and that his country would do him justice. He spoke of his mother, sent a message to Lady Hester Stanhope through her brother, and died about eight in the evening.

His staff buried him before dawn in a bastion of the town wall, wrapped in his cloak, with the army chaplain reading the service as the French guns began again. By the 18th the army was at sea.

How it came to this

In 1808 Napoleon had removed the Spanish royal family and put his brother Joseph on the throne. Spain rose against the French, and a British force landed in Portugal. After its first commanders were recalled over an armistice thought too generous, Moore was given the army and ordered into Spain to support the Spanish forces. He advanced that autumn with some 30,000 men, only to learn that Napoleon had crossed the Pyrenees in person with a far larger army, scattered the Spanish and taken Madrid on 4 December.

Instead of falling back on Lisbon, Moore struck north-east at Soult’s isolated corps, calculating that the threat to French communications would pull Napoleon away from the unconquered south. It did. The emperor turned his main force north and drove it over the snowbound Guadarrama pass to trap the British. Moore heard of it on 23 December and ordered an immediate retreat to the coast. Napoleon followed as far as Astorga, then handed the pursuit to Soult and returned to Paris, where war with Austria was brewing.

How each side saw it

The French

Soult and Napoleon’s bulletins reported a victory, and on their own terms it was one. The British had been driven out of Spain, leaving their dead general, thousands of prisoners and great quantities of stores; Corunna surrendered two days after the fleet sailed and the naval base of Ferrol soon after. French accounts of the battle itself concede that the attack on the ridge failed, and blame the ground and the short winter day. Soult treated Moore’s grave with respect, and is said to have ordered an inscription to be cut near the place where he fell.

The Spanish

Spaniards had reason to feel deserted. The marquis of La Romana’s ragged army had covered part of the retreat and been wrecked doing so, and the allies then sailed away, leaving Galicia to French occupation. British soldiers had plundered and burned in the villages along the road, and their memoirs are full of contempt for Spanish troops and peasants; the peasants’ view of them survives mainly in complaints to the local juntas. The Spanish historian the count of Toreno judged the campaign harshly. Yet Corunna has tended Moore’s tomb ever since, and the Galicians rose against the French within months.

His critics and defenders in Britain

The remnant that landed in England, filthy and typhus-ridden, shocked the public, and the government let blame fall on the dead commander. The diplomat John Hookham Frere, who had pressed Moore to fight for Madrid, was among his accusers. William Napier, who had served under him, built his History of the War in the Peninsula around the opposite case: that Moore’s march saved southern Spain and Portugal for a year. A century later Sir Charles Oman accepted the strategy but thought the retreat needlessly hurried and badly disciplined. The Duke of Wellington said his own army could not have won without what Moore’s had done.

The women and children on the road

Several hundred soldiers’ wives had been allowed to follow the army, with children, and many more had come unofficially. They had no rations of their own and no transport. Nobody recorded their number or their names. They appear in the memoirs of men who passed them: Rifleman Benjamin Harris and the commissary August Schaumann both describe women dying in the snow, and one giving birth by the roadside and walking on. Those who fell behind were taken by the French, and what became of most of them is not known.

What is disputed

Both sides claimed the battle. Casualties are estimates: about 800 to 900 British and perhaps 1,000 to 1,500 French. The loss on the whole retreat is usually put at 6,000 to 7,000. The larger dispute is whether Moore’s campaign was a failure redeemed by a brave ending or a deliberate diversion that worked; Napier and most modern historians, Charles Esdaile with reservations, lean to the second, noting that Napoleon never returned to Spain. Moore’s last words were recorded by his friend Colonel Paul Anderson and are well attested, though versions differ slightly. Wellington’s tribute is reported at second hand.

What followed

Three months later Sir Arthur Wellesley, the future Wellington, landed at Lisbon with a new army, and in May he drove Soult out of northern Portugal. The war in the Peninsula went on until 1814 and cost Napoleon, by his own later admission, more than any other. The light infantry Moore had trained became the Light Division, the best troops Wellington had. Moore himself is remembered in Britain largely through one poem, Charles Wolfe’s lines of 1817 on his burial, beginning ‘Not a drum was heard’, which generations of schoolchildren learned by heart. His tomb stands in a garden on the old walls of Corunna.

Read further

  • Christopher Hibbert, Corunna (1961)
  • Charles Oman, A History of the Peninsular War, Volume I (1902)
  • William Napier, History of the War in the Peninsula and in the South of France (1828-40)
  • Charles Esdaile, The Peninsular War: A New History (2002)
  • Benjamin Harris, The Recollections of Rifleman Harris (1848)

Same day, other years

27 BC

The Senate names Octavian ‘Augustus’

RomeEurope

Octavian, Julius Caesar’s great-nephew and heir, had been master of the Roman world since defeating Antony and Cleopatra. On 13 January 27 BC he announced to the Senate that he was handing the state back to it and to the people. The senators, as expected, begged him to stay, and he accepted command of the provinces that held most of the legions. Three days later, on 16 January, on the motion of Munatius Plancus, they voted him a new name, Augustus, ‘the revered one’. ‘Romulus’ had been considered and dropped as too kingly. Laurels were set at his door and a golden shield in the Senate house. He ruled for another forty years.

Seen from elsewhere. Augustus’s own record of his deeds says that from then on he excelled everyone in influence but held no more power than his colleagues in office. Tacitus, a century later, described a man who had won over the army with gifts and everyone else with the sweetness of peace, while those who might have objected were dead.

AD 929

Abd al-Rahman III proclaims a caliphate at Cordoba

Cordoba, al-Andalus (now Spain)Europe

The Umayyad rulers of Muslim Spain had called themselves emirs for 170 years, leaving the title of caliph, successor of the Prophet and head of all Muslims, to the Abbasids of Baghdad. On 16 January 929 Abd al-Rahman III ordered that he be named in Friday prayers as caliph and Commander of the Faithful. He had just ended a rebellion that had lasted half a century, Baghdad was weak, and a rival Shia caliphate, the Fatimid, had been declared in North Africa. Under him and his son, Cordoba became one of the largest and richest cities in the world, with a famous library and a palace city, Madinat al-Zahra, outside its walls. The caliphate fell apart in civil war after 1009.

Seen from elsewhere. Three men now claimed to be the sole caliph, and each court’s writers denied the others. The period is often praised as an age of tolerance among Muslims, Christians and Jews; critics reply that non-Muslims lived as protected but subordinate subjects, and Christian tradition honours a boy, Pelagius, said to have been martyred at this caliph’s court.

1979

The Shah leaves Iran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

After a year of demonstrations, strikes that shut the oil fields, and hundreds of deaths at the hands of his troops, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi agreed to leave the country ‘on holiday’. On 16 January 1979 he and Empress Farah drove to Mehrabad airport, where officers of the guard wept and tried to kiss his hand. He was in tears himself. He flew his own Boeing to Egypt, leaving a government under the moderate opposition figure Shapour Bakhtiar. In Tehran people danced in the streets and newspapers ran a two-word headline: the Shah is gone. Ayatollah Khomeini returned from exile on 1 February, and ten days later the army stood aside. The Shah died in Cairo in 1980.

Seen from elsewhere. The Shah, in his memoir, blamed his fall on abandonment by Washington and London after decades of alliance. To his opponents he was the ruler restored by a foreign-backed coup in 1953 and kept in power by the secret police. Many of the liberals and leftists who celebrated that day were themselves jailed, exiled or executed by the Islamic Republic.

1992

El Salvador’s civil war ends at Chapultepec

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

For twelve years the army of El Salvador, armed and financed by the United States, had fought the guerrillas of the FMLN to a stalemate at a cost of some 75,000 lives, most of them civilians. On 16 January 1992, after two years of talks brokered by the United Nations, President Alfredo Cristiani and the guerrilla commanders signed a peace agreement in Chapultepec Castle in Mexico City. The army was halved and its most notorious units disbanded, a new civilian police was created, and the FMLN became a political party that would later win the presidency. A truth commission reported in 1993 that the great majority of the abuses it examined were the work of state forces and death squads.

Seen from elsewhere. The army and the governing party maintained that they had saved the country from a Marxist takeover backed by Cuba and Nicaragua. Five days after the commission reported, the legislature passed a blanket amnesty; it was struck down only in 2016. Victims’ groups call the result peace without justice, and President Nayib Bukele has dismissed the accords as a farce.

Also on 16 January