Parallax

21 January, 1793

Louis XVI is guillotined

A drum roll cut off the last speech of the King of France. Whether the Republic had executed a traitor, murdered a martyr or simply cleared a throne is a question the French have never quite finished asking.

Paris, France

On the evening of 20 January 1793 Louis XVI was allowed two hours with his family in the Temple, the medieval tower in Paris where they had been held since August. His wife, Marie Antoinette, his sister, his fourteen-year-old daughter and his seven-year-old son clung to him. He promised to see them again in the morning. He had already decided that he would not, to spare them.

His valet, Clery, woke him at five. He heard mass said by Henry Essex Edgeworth, an Irish-born priest who had refused the oath to the Revolution’s church and whom the authorities had permitted him as confessor. He gave Clery his wedding ring and a packet of his family’s hair. At about eight the commander of the National Guard, Santerre, came for him. Louis asked a municipal officer, the former priest Jacques Roux, to take his will to the Queen; Roux replied that his job was to conduct him to the scaffold.

The closed carriage took nearly two hours to cross a silent city. Shops were shut, windows were ordered closed, and the route was lined several ranks deep with armed men, some 80,000 in all. Louis read the psalms from Edgeworth’s breviary. A royalist plot to rescue him on the way, organised by the Baron de Batz, produced a handful of men and a shout that nobody followed.

At the Place de la Revolution, the present Place de la Concorde, the guillotine stood near the empty plinth of a statue of Louis XV. The King took off his own coat and collar. When the executioners moved to tie his hands he resisted, indignant, until Edgeworth told him it was one more likeness to Christ. He climbed the steep steps, walked firmly to the edge of the platform and silenced the drummers with a look. In a voice that carried, he said that he died innocent of the crimes of which he was accused, that he pardoned the authors of his death, and that he prayed his blood would not fall upon France.

An officer on horseback ordered the drums to beat, and the rest was lost. The executioner Charles-Henri Sanson and his assistants strapped him to the plank. The blade fell at about twenty past ten. An assistant held up the head; after a pause came shouts of ‘Long live the Nation’ and ‘Long live the Republic’, and some spectators pressed forward to dip handkerchiefs and paper in the blood. He was thirty-eight. The body was taken to the Madeleine cemetery and buried in a deep pit under quicklime.

How it came to this

Louis had become king in 1774 at nineteen, conscientious, shy and indecisive, ruling a state that was sliding into bankruptcy. Calling the Estates-General in 1789 to raise taxes unleashed a revolution that made him, by 1791, a constitutional monarch with a veto. He never accepted it in his heart, above all the reorganisation of the Church. In June 1791 the family fled in disguise for the eastern frontier and was stopped at Varennes, leaving behind a manifesto repudiating everything he had signed. After that few believed his word.

War with Austria, his wife’s homeland, began in April 1792 and went badly. On 10 August a Parisian insurrection stormed the Tuileries palace and the monarchy was suspended; a newly elected Convention declared a republic in September. In November a locksmith revealed an iron safe hidden in the palace wall, holding the King’s secret correspondence, including dealings with emigres and payments to politicians. The Convention put him on trial before itself in December. He was found guilty on 15 January 1793 without a single contrary vote. The sentence was another matter.

How each side saw it

The Jacobins

For the deputies of the Mountain a trial was itself an error, because it supposed that the King might be innocent, and if he was innocent then the insurrection of 10 August was a crime. Saint-Just, in his first speech, argued that no one can reign innocently and that Louis should be judged as an enemy alien, not a citizen. Robespierre, who had opposed the death penalty in 1791, said that Louis must die so that the country might live. On this view the execution was not justice in the ordinary sense but an act of state that made the Republic irreversible and bound every deputy who voted for it.

The Girondins and the reluctant

Many deputies accepted the King’s guilt and feared his death. The Girondin leaders proposed referring the sentence to a vote of the whole people, which was rejected by 424 to 287. Others argued for imprisonment and banishment at the peace. Thomas Paine, a deputy for Calais, pleaded through an interpreter that the man be sent to America and that France not hand the English tyrant the pleasure of seeing him die. The King’s elderly former minister Malesherbes, who had volunteered to defend him, wept when he brought the verdict. Malesherbes was himself guillotined in 1794.

Royalists and the Church

Louis’s will, written on Christmas Day 1792, forgives his enemies and tells his son, if he should have the misfortune to become king, to seek no revenge. Royalists read it as the testament of a saint. Pope Pius VI declared in June 1793 that he had died in hatred of the Catholic faith and was in effect a martyr. Edgeworth’s memoir is the source for the scene on the scaffold; the famous farewell, ‘Son of Saint Louis, ascend to heaven’, was printed within days, and Edgeworth later said he had no memory of saying it. Requiem masses are still held each 21 January.

Sanson, the executioner

When a newspaper claimed that the King had been dragged to the block in terror, Sanson wrote to correct it. His letter, published in February 1793, is the nearest thing to a neutral eyewitness record. He describes the argument over the binding of the hands, the attempt to speak, and the order to proceed, and adds that the King bore it all with a composure and firmness that astonished everyone, and which he believed came from the principles of religion. Sanson went on to execute the Queen, Danton and, in the end, Robespierre.

What is disputed

The numbers were contested at once. Of 721 deputies voting on the sentence, 361 chose death without conditions, a majority of one; another 26 voted death but asked for a debate on delay, giving the usual figure of 387 to 334. A reprieve was then refused by 380 to 310, figures sometimes wrongly quoted for the sentence itself. Who gave the order for the drums, Santerre or another officer, was disputed by the men concerned. Historians divide on substance too: Michael Walzer argued the regicide was a justified founding act, David Jordan that the trial was fair by the standards of a revolution, others that it was a judicial murder that licensed the Terror.

What followed

Within weeks France was at war with Britain, the Dutch Republic and Spain, and the Vendee rose in a royalist and Catholic revolt that cost well over a hundred thousand lives. Marie Antoinette was guillotined in October; the boy the royalists called Louis XVII died in the Temple in 1795. Deputies who had voted for death, the regicides, were exiled when the Bourbons returned in 1815, and Louis XVIII built an expiatory chapel over the Madeleine grave. Emmanuel Macron remarked in 2015 that French democracy carries an absence at its centre, the figure of the king.

Read further

  • David P. Jordan, The King’s Trial: Louis XVI vs. the French Revolution (1979)
  • Michael Walzer, Regicide and Revolution: Speeches at the Trial of Louis XVI (1974)
  • John Hardman, The Life of Louis XVI (2016)
  • Henry Essex Edgeworth de Firmont, Memoirs of the Abbe Edgeworth (1815)
  • Jean-Baptiste Clery, Journal of Occurrences at the Temple during the Confinement of Louis XVI (1798)

Same day, other years

1525

The first adult baptisms in Zurich

Zurich, SwitzerlandEurope

A circle of young followers of the reformer Zwingli had concluded from their reading of the New Testament that baptism belonged to believers who asked for it, not to infants. After a public disputation the city council ruled against them and ordered all unbaptised children christened within eight days. On the evening of 21 January 1525 about fifteen of them met at the house of Felix Manz’s mother. George Blaurock, a former priest, asked Conrad Grebel to baptise him, and then baptised the others. The movement their opponents called Anabaptist, ‘rebaptisers’, dates from that night.

Seen from elsewhere. To Zwingli and the council, refusing infant baptism dissolved the bond between church and civic community and invited the disorder of the peasant risings. Zurich made rebaptism a capital crime; Manz was drowned in the Limmat in 1527. Catholic and Protestant states alike executed thousands of Anabaptists. Mennonites, Amish and Hutterites descend from them, and Zurich’s Reformed church formally asked forgiveness in 2004.

1924

Lenin dies at Gorki

Gorki, near Moscow, Soviet UnionEurope

Vladimir Lenin had been incapacitated by a series of strokes since 1922, the last of which left him unable to speak more than a few syllables. He died on the evening of 21 January 1924 at a country estate south of Moscow, aged fifty-three. In notes dictated a year earlier he had assessed his possible successors and recommended that Stalin be removed as the party’s general secretary for being too rude; the party leadership read the document and shelved it. Hundreds of thousands filed past the body in bitter cold. Petrograd was renamed Leningrad within the week.

Seen from elsewhere. His widow, Nadezhda Krupskaya, asked publicly that there be no monuments or cult; the Politburo had him embalmed and placed in a mausoleum, where he remains. Trotsky, convalescing in the Caucasus, claimed Stalin misled him about the funeral date. Admirers mourned the founder of the first workers’ state; opponents remembered the Red Terror, the suppression of rival parties and the famine of 1921-22.

1960

The Coalbrook mine collapses

Coalbrook, Orange Free State, South AfricaAfrica

At the Clydesdale colliery near Sasolburg, coal was mined by leaving pillars to hold up the roof, and over the years those pillars had been cut thinner to raise output for a nearby power station. A partial collapse on 28 December 1959 had been treated as a warning to be managed. On the afternoon of 21 January 1960 an area of workings some 180 metres down caved in over several square kilometres. By the usual count 435 men were trapped: about 429 Black migrant workers, most from Basutoland and Mozambique, and six white supervisors. Rescue drilling found only methane and water. No one was brought out, and no bodies were recovered.

Seen from elsewhere. Survivors testified that men who tried to leave after the first tremors that day were ordered back under threat of dismissal or arrest. The official inquiry criticised the mining method but no one was prosecuted, and compensation paid to the families of Black miners was a fraction of that paid for white ones. It remains South Africa’s worst mining disaster and led to the first systematic research on pillar strength.

1968

North Korean commandos reach the edge of the Blue House

Seoul, South KoreaAsia

Thirty-one men of the North Korean army’s Unit 124 cut through the fence of the demilitarised zone, crossed the frozen Imjin river and walked for three nights towards Seoul with orders to kill President Park Chung-hee. Four woodcutters who stumbled on them were lectured on communism and released, and reported them. On the night of 21 January 1968, dressed in South Korean uniforms, the unit came within a few hundred metres of the presidential residence before a police chief, Choi Gyu-sik, challenged them at a checkpoint and was shot. In the manhunt that followed twenty-nine commandos died, one was captured and one got home.

Seen from elsewhere. Pyongyang denied responsibility, though Kim Il-sung reportedly told a Southern envoy in 1972 that extremists had acted without his approval. Some thirty South Koreans and several American soldiers were killed. The South secretly trained its own assassination squad, Unit 684, which mutinied in 1971. The captured commando, Kim Shin-jo, became a Presbyterian pastor in Seoul.

Also on 21 January