Parallax

13 January, 1898

Zola accuses the French army

France’s best-selling novelist used a newspaper front page to name the generals he said had sent an innocent man to Devil’s Island, and dared them to put him on trial. They did.

Paris, France

On 11 January 1898 a court martial in Paris took a few minutes to acquit Major Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy of having sold military secrets to Germany. The verdict was unanimous and the crowd outside cheered him. For the small group who believed that Esterhazy, not the Jewish captain Alfred Dreyfus, had written the note on which Dreyfus had been convicted three years earlier, every legal road now seemed closed. The same day the officer who had found the evidence against Esterhazy, Colonel Georges Picquart, was placed under arrest.

Emile Zola, the most widely read novelist in France, had already written several articles on the case. He now shut himself up for two days and wrote an open letter of some four thousand words to the President of the Republic, Felix Faure. He took it to L’Aurore, a young radical daily. Its political editor, Georges Clemenceau, read it and lifted two words from the closing section to run in huge type across the front page: J’Accuse.

The paper normally sold about 30,000 copies. On the morning of Thursday 13 January it printed some 300,000 and sent out hundreds of extra street sellers, and most were gone within hours. The letter told the story of the case as Zola understood it, and ended with a list. He accused Lieutenant-Colonel du Paty de Clam of being the author of a judicial error; General Mercier, the former war minister, of complicity in it; Generals Billot, Boisdeffre and Gonse of knowing Dreyfus to be innocent and suppressing the proof; the handwriting experts of false reports; the first court martial of convicting on a secret document the defence never saw; and the second of acquitting a guilty man to order.

He knew what he was doing. The final paragraph points out that he is exposing himself to the law on defamation, names the articles, and says he does so on purpose: let them dare to bring him before a jury, in open court. He was not accusing the generals out of hatred, he wrote, but to hasten the explosion of truth and justice.

The government prosecuted him on a single sentence, the one about the second court martial, to keep the Dreyfus case itself out of the courtroom. The trial in February was held amid crowds shouting for his death. He was convicted, sentenced to a year in prison and fined 3,000 francs. When a retrial ended the same way in July he left at once for England, where he spent eleven months under false names in suburban hotels south of London.

How it came to this

In September 1894 a cleaner working for French counter-intelligence retrieved from a wastepaper basket in the German embassy an unsigned note, the bordereau, offering French military documents. Suspicion settled on Alfred Dreyfus, an artillery captain from a Jewish family of Alsace, the only Jew then training on the General Staff. The handwriting evidence was disputed. He was convicted in a closed court martial that December after the judges were secretly shown a file the defence knew nothing about, was publicly stripped of his rank in January 1895, and was shipped to solitary confinement on Devil’s Island off French Guiana.

In 1896 Picquart, the new head of the intelligence section, came across evidence that the handwriting was Esterhazy’s. His superiors told him to drop it and posted him to Tunisia, while his deputy, Major Henry, forged a document to strengthen the file against Dreyfus. The prisoner’s brother Mathieu and his wife Lucie kept up a campaign, and by late 1897 a senator, Auguste Scheurer-Kestner, and a handful of journalists had been convinced. Meanwhile an antisemitic press led by Edouard Drumont’s La Libre Parole treated the case as proof of Jewish treason.

How each side saw it

The army and the anti-Dreyfusards

Most officers, and at first most of France, believed Dreyfus guilty because seven of his brother officers had found him so. For them the matter was closed, and reopening it could only weaken the army that stood between France and a second defeat by Germany. Writers such as Maurice Barres and the Catholic daily La Croix went further and presented the campaign as the work of a Jewish ‘syndicate’ buying up journalists. Some senior officers knew the file was rotten and protected it out of loyalty to the institution. Many more simply trusted their chiefs. General Mercier maintained to his death in 1921 that Dreyfus was a traitor.

Alfred Dreyfus and his family

Dreyfus knew nothing of the article. On Devil’s Island he was forbidden news, kept behind a palisade and for a time shackled to his bed at night. His letters to Lucie, later published, show an officer who went on believing that the army he loved would discover its mistake. Mathieu Dreyfus’s memoir describes years of patient, careful work to find the real culprit, and some unease at allies who wanted a political battle. Bernard Lazare, the Jewish anarchist who published the first pamphlet for Dreyfus in 1896, felt pushed aside once famous names took up the cause.

Jews in France and Algeria

In the weeks after 13 January there were anti-Jewish riots in dozens of French towns: shop windows smashed, synagogues attacked, crowds chanting for death. In Algiers the violence went on for days and people were killed. The official bodies of French Jewry mostly kept silent, fearing that to defend Dreyfus as Jews would confirm the charge of clannishness. Theodor Herzl, who had reported Dreyfus’s degradation for a Vienna newspaper, later said the affair made him a Zionist; historians such as Jacques Kornberg think his turn had other causes and that he wrote the link in afterwards.

The socialists

The French left did not rally at once. Jules Guesde admired Zola’s letter but his party’s manifesto that January told workers to stay out of a quarrel between two factions of the bourgeoisie; Dreyfus was, after all, a rich officer. Jean Jaures at first hesitated too, then changed his mind and in the summer of 1898 published Les Preuves, a close demonstration of the forgeries. His argument that injustice to one man concerned the working class as much as anyone drew many socialists into the defence of the Republic.

What is disputed

Zola had no inside knowledge and got details wrong: he made du Paty de Clam the chief villain and scarcely mentioned Henry, the actual forger. That Esterhazy wrote the bordereau is accepted; he later claimed he did so on orders as a double agent, and a few writers have built theories of a French deception operation on this, which most historians reject. How far antisemitism caused the original accusation, as against making it stick, is debated. Zola died in 1902 of fumes from a blocked chimney. A roofer is reported to have confessed decades later to stopping it deliberately; the story surfaced in 1953 and cannot be proved.

What followed

Henry admitted his forgery in August 1898 and cut his throat in his cell. Dreyfus was brought back for a second court martial at Rennes in 1899, found guilty again ‘with extenuating circumstances’, then pardoned. France’s highest court finally cleared him on 12 July 1906 and he returned to the army, serving in the First World War. The affair split families, brought the word ‘intellectual’ into use as a noun, and helped produce the separation of church and state in 1905 and, on the other side, the nationalist movement Action Francaise. Zola’s two words remain the model for a public accusation.

Read further

  • Emile Zola, The Dreyfus Affair: ‘J’accuse’ and Other Writings, edited by Alain Pages (1996)
  • Jean-Denis Bredin, The Affair: The Case of Alfred Dreyfus (1986)
  • Ruth Harris, The Man on Devil’s Island: Alfred Dreyfus and the Affair that Divided France (2010)
  • Alfred Dreyfus, Five Years of My Life (1901)
  • Louis Begley, Why the Dreyfus Affair Matters (2009)

Same day, other years

1842

A lone surgeon rides into Jalalabad

Jalalabad, AfghanistanAsia

In 1839 a British and Indian army had invaded Afghanistan to replace its ruler with a more pliable one, Shah Shuja. Two years later Kabul rose against the occupation. On 6 January 1842 the garrison marched out for Jalalabad, ninety miles away through snowbound passes, under a promise of safe conduct: about 4,500 soldiers, most of them Indian sepoys, and some 12,000 servants, wives and children. Ghilzai tribesmen fired on the column from the heights day after day. On the afternoon of 13 January sentries at Jalalabad saw one rider on a dying pony. He was William Brydon, an assistant surgeon, with part of his skull sliced away by a sword.

Seen from elsewhere. Brydon was not the sole survivor: more than a hundred British captives were later released, and many Indian soldiers and followers survived as prisoners, slaves or beggars, largely unrecorded. Afghan epics such as the Akbarnama celebrate the expulsion of an invader. A British ‘Army of Retribution’ returned that autumn and burned the great bazaar of Kabul.

1953

Pravda announces a plot by ‘killer doctors’

Moscow, Soviet UnionEurope

On 13 January 1953 Pravda and the Soviet news agency reported the arrest of a group of eminent Kremlin physicians. Nine were named, six of them Jews. They were said to have murdered two Soviet leaders by deliberate mistreatment and to have been planning to kill more, on the orders of American and British intelligence acting through a Jewish charity. A campaign followed against ‘rootless cosmopolitans’; Jewish doctors were dismissed, patients refused treatment from them, and Soviet Jews waited for worse. Stalin died on 5 March. On 4 April Pravda announced that the case had been fabricated and the confessions obtained by forbidden methods. The surviving doctors were released. Two had died in custody.

Seen from elsewhere. Many survivors and memoirists were sure Stalin intended to follow a show trial with the deportation of Soviet Jews to Siberia. No order or plan has been found in the archives. The Russian historian Gennady Kostyrchenko considers the deportation a myth; Jonathan Brent and Vladimir Naumov argue that preparations were under way when Stalin died.

1963

Togo’s first president is shot at the embassy gate

Lome, TogoAfrica

Sylvanus Olympio had led Togo to independence from France in 1960. He ran a tight budget, kept the army at a few hundred men, and refused to enlist several hundred Togolese veterans of the French colonial forces who had come home from Algeria without work. In the night of 12 to 13 January 1963 a group of them attacked his house. He got over the wall into the grounds of the American embassy next door, was found there at dawn and was shot dead near the gate. It was among the first military coups in independent sub-Saharan Africa. A sergeant in the group, Etienne Eyadema, took power himself four years later to the day and ruled until 2005; his son succeeded him.

Seen from elsewhere. The soldiers said Olympio had become a dictator who jailed opponents and left them destitute. His family and many Togolese hold that France had a hand in the killing, since he was preparing to leave the French-backed currency; France has denied it. Eyadema at first boasted of firing the shots and later withdrew the claim.

1991

Soviet tanks storm the Vilnius television tower

Vilnius, LithuaniaEurope

Lithuania had declared its independence from the Soviet Union in March 1990, and Moscow had answered with an economic blockade. In January 1991 Soviet troops began seizing public buildings in Vilnius, and thousands of unarmed people gathered to guard the parliament, the radio and television centre and the television tower. In the early hours of 13 January tanks and paratroopers attacked the tower and the broadcasting centre. Fourteen civilians were killed, some shot and some crushed under tank tracks, and hundreds were hurt. A television presenter stayed on air until soldiers entered the studio. The crowd around parliament did not disperse, and the troops did not attack it. Seven months later the Soviet Union recognised Lithuania’s independence.

Seen from elsewhere. Mikhail Gorbachev always said he gave no order and learned of the attack afterwards; many Lithuanians do not believe him. In 2019 a Vilnius court convicted the former Soviet defence minister Dmitry Yazov and dozens of others, mostly in their absence. Russia called the trial illegal and opened criminal cases against the Lithuanian judges and prosecutors.

Also on 13 January