On 11 January 1898 a court martial in Paris took a few minutes to acquit Major Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy of having sold military secrets to Germany. The verdict was unanimous and the crowd outside cheered him. For the small group who believed that Esterhazy, not the Jewish captain Alfred Dreyfus, had written the note on which Dreyfus had been convicted three years earlier, every legal road now seemed closed. The same day the officer who had found the evidence against Esterhazy, Colonel Georges Picquart, was placed under arrest.
Emile Zola, the most widely read novelist in France, had already written several articles on the case. He now shut himself up for two days and wrote an open letter of some four thousand words to the President of the Republic, Felix Faure. He took it to L’Aurore, a young radical daily. Its political editor, Georges Clemenceau, read it and lifted two words from the closing section to run in huge type across the front page: J’Accuse.
The paper normally sold about 30,000 copies. On the morning of Thursday 13 January it printed some 300,000 and sent out hundreds of extra street sellers, and most were gone within hours. The letter told the story of the case as Zola understood it, and ended with a list. He accused Lieutenant-Colonel du Paty de Clam of being the author of a judicial error; General Mercier, the former war minister, of complicity in it; Generals Billot, Boisdeffre and Gonse of knowing Dreyfus to be innocent and suppressing the proof; the handwriting experts of false reports; the first court martial of convicting on a secret document the defence never saw; and the second of acquitting a guilty man to order.
He knew what he was doing. The final paragraph points out that he is exposing himself to the law on defamation, names the articles, and says he does so on purpose: let them dare to bring him before a jury, in open court. He was not accusing the generals out of hatred, he wrote, but to hasten the explosion of truth and justice.
The government prosecuted him on a single sentence, the one about the second court martial, to keep the Dreyfus case itself out of the courtroom. The trial in February was held amid crowds shouting for his death. He was convicted, sentenced to a year in prison and fined 3,000 francs. When a retrial ended the same way in July he left at once for England, where he spent eleven months under false names in suburban hotels south of London.
How it came to this
In September 1894 a cleaner working for French counter-intelligence retrieved from a wastepaper basket in the German embassy an unsigned note, the bordereau, offering French military documents. Suspicion settled on Alfred Dreyfus, an artillery captain from a Jewish family of Alsace, the only Jew then training on the General Staff. The handwriting evidence was disputed. He was convicted in a closed court martial that December after the judges were secretly shown a file the defence knew nothing about, was publicly stripped of his rank in January 1895, and was shipped to solitary confinement on Devil’s Island off French Guiana.
In 1896 Picquart, the new head of the intelligence section, came across evidence that the handwriting was Esterhazy’s. His superiors told him to drop it and posted him to Tunisia, while his deputy, Major Henry, forged a document to strengthen the file against Dreyfus. The prisoner’s brother Mathieu and his wife Lucie kept up a campaign, and by late 1897 a senator, Auguste Scheurer-Kestner, and a handful of journalists had been convinced. Meanwhile an antisemitic press led by Edouard Drumont’s La Libre Parole treated the case as proof of Jewish treason.