Parallax

28 January, AD 814

Charlemagne dies at Aachen

He had ruled the Franks for forty-six years and most of western Europe for thirty. He was buried the day he died, and within a generation his grandsons were at war over the pieces.

Aachen, Frankish Empire (now Germany)

In the autumn of 813 Charles, king of the Franks and Lombards and for thirteen years emperor, went hunting as usual in the forest near his palace at Aachen. He was in his mid-sixties, lame in one foot, and had been troubled by fevers for four years, which he treated by ignoring his doctors, who wanted him to give up roast meat. He returned to the palace about the beginning of November to spend the winter by the hot springs he loved.

In January he was seized by a high fever and took to his bed. His biographer Einhard, who had lived at the court for more than twenty years, says that he prescribed for himself what he always did, a fast, taking almost nothing but a little water. A pain in the side developed, which the Greeks, Einhard notes, call pleurisy. On the seventh day, having received communion, he died at about nine in the morning. It was 28 January 814, in the forty-seventh year of his reign.

There had been no instructions about a grave, and after some discussion it was agreed that nowhere was fitter than the great church he had built beside the palace, with its eight-sided dome and its columns carried from Rome and Ravenna. He was buried there the same day. A gilded arch was raised above the tomb with an inscription calling him the great and orthodox emperor who nobly enlarged the kingdom of the Franks.

Einhard, writing some years later, listed the signs that had been noticed beforehand: eclipses of sun and moon, a black spot on the sun for seven days, the collapse of the wooden gallery between church and palace, a fireball that made the emperor’s horse throw him, and the fading of the word ‘Princeps’ from the inscription inside the dome. Charles, he says, treated all of it as though it had nothing to do with him.

The succession at least was settled. Of his legitimate sons only Louis, king of Aquitaine, was still alive, and the previous September Charles had had him acclaimed co-emperor in the same church, with no pope present. Louis reached Aachen about a month after the death. One of his first acts was to clear the palace of his father’s household, sending his unmarried sisters, whom Charles had kept with him and whose love affairs he had tolerated, to the convents they had been given.

How it came to this

Charles inherited half the Frankish kingdom from his father Pippin in 768 and the other half when his brother Carloman died in 771. He then campaigned almost every year for three decades. He took the Lombard kingdom in Italy in 774, absorbed Bavaria, destroyed the Avar state on the middle Danube and carried off its treasure, and fought the pagan Saxons between the Rhine and the Elbe for more than thirty years, with mass deportations and baptism imposed on pain of death. An expedition into Spain in 778 ended with the destruction of his rearguard by Basques in the Pyrenees, the episode later turned into the Song of Roland.

On Christmas Day 800, in St Peter’s in Rome, Pope Leo III placed a crown on his head and the congregation acclaimed him emperor, the first in the west for more than three centuries. Around him at Aachen he gathered scholars from England, Ireland, Italy and Spain, led by Alcuin of York, who reformed schools, corrected texts and developed the clear script from which modern lower-case letters descend. Einhard records that the emperor himself kept writing tablets under his pillow and practised forming letters, but had begun too late.

How each side saw it

Einhard and the Frankish court

Einhard’s Life of Charles, written within about fifteen years of the death and modelled on Suetonius’s lives of the Caesars, is the portrait every later one starts from: a tall, round-headed, cheerful man who loved swimming, his daughters and the company of scholars, and who dressed like an ordinary Frank. It was written by a courtier who owed him everything, and probably in part as a reproach to the troubled court of his son. It passes quickly over the brother’s death, the repudiated wives, the conspiracy of his eldest son Pippin the Hunchback and the brutality of the Saxon wars.

The Saxons

The Saxons of the eighth century left nothing in writing. Their conquest is known from the Frankish royal annals, which record that at Verden in 782 Charles had 4,500 surrendered Saxons beheaded in one day, and from his own law for the region, which set death as the penalty for refusing baptism or eating meat in Lent. Even Alcuin protested in letters that faith could not be forced and that tithes were destroying it. A century later Christian Saxon writers praised Charles as their apostle. In the 1930s some German nationalists revived the older grievance and called him the butcher of the Saxons.

Constantinople

To the Byzantine court there was already a Roman emperor, and it sat in Constantinople. The chronicler Theophanes describes the coronation of 800 with disdain and reports a rumour that Charles proposed to marry the empress Irene and unite east and west. The title was treated as a barbarian king’s usurpation, made possible only because a woman occupied the throne. After years of border fighting over Venice and Dalmatia, envoys of Michael I came to Aachen in 812 and addressed Charles as emperor, though not as emperor of the Romans, a title the east never conceded.

French and German traditions

France and Germany both count him as a founder. To the French he is Charlemagne, king of the Franks, hero of the medieval epics and first in the line of their kings. To Germans he is Karl der Grosse, a German-speaking ruler whose seat was Aachen and whose crown passed to the Holy Roman Emperors; Frederick Barbarossa had him declared a saint in 1165, by an antipope. Historians point out that neither nation existed in 814. Since 1950 the city of Aachen has awarded a prize in his name for services to European unity, a third tradition that claims him.

What is disputed

The date of death is firm; the date of birth is not. Einhard thought him about seventy-two, which gave the traditional year 742, but most scholars now follow Karl Ferdinand Werner and Matthias Becher in preferring 747 or 748. The figure of 4,500 executed at Verden has been doubted as an exaggeration or a copyist’s error, though the annals are explicit. Einhard’s claim that Charles would not have entered St Peter’s had he known the pope’s plan is widely thought a pose. The story that Otto III opened the tomb in 1000 and found him seated upright on a throne comes from later chroniclers and is generally treated as legend.

What followed

Louis the Pious held the empire together with difficulty, and his sons fought over it. By the Treaty of Verdun in 843 it was divided into western, middle and eastern kingdoms; the western and eastern parts are the distant ancestors of France and Germany, and the lands between them were contested into the twentieth century. The imperial title lapsed and was revived by Otto I in 962, lasting in that form until 1806. Charlemagne’s church still stands at Aachen, where German kings were crowned for six hundred years, and his bones lie there in a golden shrine made in 1215.

Read further

  • Einhard and Notker the Stammerer, Two Lives of Charlemagne, translated by David Ganz (2008)
  • Janet L. Nelson, King and Emperor: A New Life of Charlemagne (2019)
  • Rosamond McKitterick, Charlemagne: The Formation of a European Identity (2008)
  • Alessandro Barbero, Charlemagne: Father of a Continent (2004)
  • Johannes Fried, Charlemagne (2016)

Same day, other years

1077

A king is absolved in the snow at Canossa

Canossa, northern ItalyEurope

Henry IV, king of the Germans, had been excommunicated by Pope Gregory VII a year earlier in a quarrel over who should appoint bishops, and his princes had given him a year to be reconciled or lose his throne. In midwinter he crossed the Alps with his wife and small son and found the pope at Canossa, a castle of Countess Matilda of Tuscany. According to Gregory’s own letter, Henry stood for three days before the gate, barefoot and in a penitent’s woollen shirt. On 28 January the pope, urged by Matilda and by Abbot Hugh of Cluny, admitted him and lifted the sentence.

Seen from elsewhere. The fullest account, by the monk Lampert of Hersfeld, is hostile to Henry and heightens his abasement. Henry’s supporters could call it a success: a priest could not refuse a penitent, and the princes lost their pretext. He was excommunicated again in 1080 and drove Gregory from Rome. Johannes Fried has argued it was a negotiated treaty, which other medievalists reject.

1846

The Sikh army is driven across the Sutlej at Aliwal

Aliwal, Punjab, IndiaAsia

The Sikh kingdom of the Punjab, built by Ranjit Singh, had been in turmoil since his death in 1839, and in December 1845 its army crossed the Sutlej into territory held by the East India Company. On 28 January 1846 a Company force under Sir Harry Smith attacked a Sikh corps commanded by Ranjodh Singh Majithia near the village of Aliwal, with its back to the river. British and Indian cavalry, the 16th Lancers among them, broke into the Sikh infantry squares, and the defenders were pushed into the fords with the loss of all their guns. The larger battle of Sobraon followed in February, and the Punjab lost territory, its independence in practice, and Kashmir.

Seen from elsewhere. Sikh tradition, expressed in Shah Muhammad’s Punjabi ballad on the war, holds that the soldiers of the Khalsa fought bravely and were betrayed by their own leaders. The chief commanders, Lal Singh and Tej Singh, were in contact with the British, and Ranjodh Singh left the field at Aliwal early. British officers also testified to the Sikhs’ courage.

1932

Japanese marines attack Shanghai

Shanghai, ChinaAsia

Four months after the Japanese army seized Manchuria, a Chinese boycott of Japanese goods and a street attack on Japanese Buddhist monks in Shanghai gave the Japanese navy grounds for an ultimatum. Shortly before midnight on 28 January marines moved out of the International Settlement into the Chinese district of Zhabei. They met unexpected resistance from the Nineteenth Route Army under Cai Tingkai. The next morning aircraft from a Japanese carrier bombed the crowded district, one of the first heavy air attacks on a city’s civilian quarter. Fighting lasted five weeks, killed thousands of civilians, made several hundred thousand people homeless and ended in a truce that barred Chinese troops from their own largest city.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan said it was protecting its residents from mob violence. A Japanese officer, Tanaka Ryukichi, testified after 1945 that he had arranged the attack on the monks to create a pretext and divert attention from Manchuria. Many Chinese, including the Nineteenth Route Army’s officers, accused Chiang Kai-shek’s government of giving the defenders too little support.

Also on 28 January